Risk Factors for Border Malaria in a Malaria Elimination Setting: A Retrospective Case-Control Study in Yunnan, China

The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, Mar 2015

Jian-Wei Xu, Hui Liu, Yu Zhang, Xiang-Rui Guo, Jia-Zhi Wang

A PDF file should load here. If you do not see its contents the file may be temporarily unavailable at the journal website or you do not have a PDF plug-in installed and enabled in your browser.

Alternatively, you can download the file locally and open with any standalone PDF reader:


Risk Factors for Border Malaria in a Malaria Elimination Setting: A Retrospective Case-Control Study in Yunnan, China

Am. J. Trop. Med. Hyg. Risk Factors for Border Malaria in a Malaria Elimination Setting: A Retrospective Case-Control Study in Yunnan, China Jian-Wei Xu 0 1 Hui Liu 0 1 Yu Zhang 0 1 Xiang-Rui Guo 0 1 Jia-Zhi Wang 0 1 0 Diseases , 6 Xiyuan Road, Puer, 665000, Yunnan , China 1 Yunnan Institute of Parasitic Diseases, Yunnan Provincial Center of Malaria Research, Yunnan Provincial Collaborative Innovation Center for Public Health and Disease Prevention and Control, Yunnan Provincial Key Laboratory of Vector-Borne Diseases Control and Research , Puer 665000 , China; The Fourth Hospital of Baotou Municipality, Inner Mongolia , Baotou , China; Yingjiang County Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Yingjiang China; Tengchong County Center for Disease Control and Prevention , Tengchong , China A retrospective case-control study was conducted to identify risk factors for border malaria in a malaria elimination setting of Yunnan Province, China. The study comprised 214 cases and 428 controls. The controls were individually matched to the cases on the basis of residence, age, and gender. In addition, statistical associations are based on matched analyses. The frequencies of imported, male, adult, and vivax malaria cases were respectively 201 (93.9%), 194 (90.7%), 210 (98.1%), and 176 (82.2%). Overnight stay in Myanmar within the prior month was independently associated with malaria infection (odds ratio [OR] 159.5, 95% confidence interval [CI] 75.1-338.9). In particular, stays in lowland and foothill (OR 5.5, 95% CI 2.5-11.8) or mid-hill (OR 42.8, 95% CI 5.1-319.8) areas, or near streamlets (OR 15.3, 95% CI 4.3-55.2) or paddy field or pools (OR10.1, 95% CI 4.4-55.8) were found to be independently associated with malaria. Neither forest exposure nor use of vector control measures was associated with malaria. In conclusion, travel to lowland and foothill or mid-hill hyperendemic areas, especially along the waterside in Myanmar, was found to be the highest risk factor for malaria. In considering the limitations of the study, further investigations are needed to identify the major determinants of malaria risk and develop new strategies for malaria elimination on China-Myanmar border. - Remarkable progress has been achieved in reducing malaria burden globally over the past 10 years.1,2 Nowadays, there are 99 endemic countries; of these, 65 are controlling malaria and 34 are pursuing elimination. The 34 eliminating countries have declared a national policy for malaria elimination or are pursuing spatially progressive elimination within their borders.2–4 Countries in the Asia Pacific region are mak ing particularly strong progress toward eliminating malaria.5 As one of countries with a great reduction in malaria incidence, China aims to eliminate malaria by 2020.6 In low transmission settings, malaria is increasingly imported, caused by Plasmodium vivax, and clustered demographically in adult men with shared epidemiological risk factors. Current malaria control interventions and strategies are not likely to be optimal, and novel strategies targeting high-risk groups are urgently needed. In high endemic, control settings, risk factors can be established through nationally representative crosssectional surveys, such as malaria indicator surveys. However, in areas where transmission is very low and malaria infections are rare, these surveys are unlikely to adequately detect cases or identify risk factors. Furthermore, such large-scale surveys require substantial financial and operational resources.7,8 Case-control analysis is a well-established method to study rare diseases and identify associated demographic, behavioral, and clinical risk factors, being particularly appropriate for rare diseases. As yet, this epidemiological tool has not to be extensively applied to malaria, which has traditionally been studied in high-endemic settings.7,9–11 In China, malaria has been eliminated from large parts of the country. The remaining at-risk areas can be characterized as low endemic and they are clustered in parts of central China, southern China, and Tibet. The southern province of Yunnan will be particularly challenging for elimination as it shares a 4,061 km border with malarious countries including Myanmar, Laos, and Vietnam.12,13 The epidemiology of malaria in this area is presumed to be similar to other parts of Southeast Asia, where reported malaria incidence and parasite species have been identified. Malaria tends to concentrate among migrant workers on border regions and in forest areas. For example, men who travel into the deep forest for work become infected with bites from Anopheles dirus (the primary vector in the deep forest of Southeast Asia) and return to their home villages on the forest fringe where they become reservoirs for transmission of the parasites by Anopheles minimus (the primary vector on the forest fringe of Southeast Asia) to their young children.14 However, these risk factors have not been evaluated in a controlled study. To improve understanding of risk factors of border malaria infection in Yunnan and to support the design and implementation of targeted interventions, we conducted a retrospective case-control study. Study site. The study was conducted in Tengchong and Yingjiang, two border counties at the Yunnan-Myanmar border (Figure 1). There are 39 health facilities that are required to report all suspected and laboratory-confirmed malaria cases through the China Information System for Disease Control and Prevention (CISDCP), the national internet-based disease reporting system. Basic demographic data and contact information are included in the reports. The epidemiology of malaria in this area has been described.14–16 Briefly, these sites were selected because they are formerly hyper-endemic areas and the current hot spots of border malaria in China, as a result there were enough cases for the study. Study design and data collection. The study was a retrospective case-control design and conducted from April to October 2012. The laboratory-confirmed cases were reported from all health facilities in Tengchong and Yingjiang from September 2010 to December 2011. Li and Fan15 reported that 97.5% (2,556 of 3,646) of malaria patients were imported from Myanmar and most of them were male adults in Tengchong. To exclude the confounding effect of age and sex, controls were matched by age and sex. The goal of malaria elimination was to achieve zero incidence of locally contracted cases. It was important to identify the risk factors of local malaria infection,17,18 therefore community of residence was also selected as one of matching criteria. Finally, the controls were matched two to one with cases on the basis of residence, age (±2 years), and gender. First, blood smears from malaria cases reported from September 2010 to December 2011 were reread by an expert microscopist for secondary confirmation. Using contact information available in the case reporting system, the confirmed cases were then visited at their homes by study staff and approached for orally informed consent. A paper survey with 35 questions was administered in Mandarin to assess demographics and potential risk factors including housing condition, local ecology, socio-economic status, behavior, occupation, activities, travel, malaria awareness and knowledge, and use of malaria prevention measures. Information on activities, housing, use of personal protective measures, and local ecology was obtained on both the subject’s home in Yunnan and at the locations where they had stayed 1 month before the date of malaria attack of case patients. Controls were then recruited from adjoining households of cases.13 Subjects matching the case by age (±2 years) and gender were invited to participate in the study. A finger prick was performed in consenting subjects to generate a blood slide for microscopy. Only subjects that were malaria free by microscopy were recruited as controls. The same questionnaire was then conducted with control subjects to collect data on potential risk factors. Ethical approval was obtained from the Ethics Committee of Yunnan Institute of Parasitic Diseases, China. The Ethics Committee approved a verbal consent procedure as sufficient because the study was interview-based, and screening for malaria by microscopy is one of the malaria control components. Questionnaires were conducted by a team of seven trained interviewers. Defining wealth tertiles. Details were recorded on principal components of housing characteristics (type of wall and roof), household appliances, and transport tools; and then were used to construct a wealth index. The wealth tertile was defined as 1) lowest tertile: soil and wood walls and terracotta roofs, only television sets or without any valuable electric items, only bikes or without any transport tools; 2) middle tertile: brick walls and terracotta roofs, television sets, motorcycles; 3) highest tertile: brick or reinforced concrete walls and roofs, television sets, and refrigerators, tractors or cars or trucks.19–22 Statistical analysis. Data were double entered and cleaned in EpiData 3.1 (EpiData Association, Odense, Denmark), and analyzed in Epi Info 2000 (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA). The statistical associations are based on matched analyses. For the case and the control group, the frequency and proportions of each predictor variable were calculated and compared using a c2 test. Variables likely associated with the outcome (P < 0.25) were selected as candidate variables for matched univariate and multivariate logistic regression.23 Missing data were excluded from these analyses. There were 214 malaria cases and 428 matched controls recruited to participate in the study. Of the 214 confirmed For cases and controls, N = 214 and N = 428, respectively, unless otherwise indicated. ITNs = insecticide-treated nets; LLINs = long-lasting insecticide nets. N = 213 N = 426 malaria case patients, 176 (82.2%) were vivax malaria and 38 (17.8%) were falciparum malaria. There were no mixed infections. Based on the CISDCP, 201 (93.9%) cases were imported from other countries, 12 (8.0%) locally acquired, Characteristics of cases and controls, Yunnan, China, 2012 Activities, housing conditions, and local ecology in Myanmar, data from cases and controls that stayed overnight in Myanmar before the malaria attack in the case 0.48 (0.32–0.72) 0.43 (0.25–0.74) 0.77 (0.46–1.30) 0.76 (0.52–1.12) 53.75 (29.94–97.67) 0.33 (0.15–0.73) 0.35 (0.14–0.82) 0.21 (0.10–1.46) 6.88 (3.20–15.07) 42.85 (6.07–860.16) 17.62 (7.17–45.27) 15.52 (4.27–66.72) 0.27 (0.06–0.99) 0.70 (0.13–3.21) Adjusted OR (95% CI) 0.69 (0.21–1.71) 0.64 (0.24–1.67) 0.89 (0.36–1.80) 0.92 (0.47–1.45) 159.5 (75.1–338.9) 2.44 (0.36–16.76) 0.71 (0.16–3.23) 0.73 (0.15–1.75) 5.45 (2.52–11.80) 42.82 (5.13–319.75) 15.30 (4.25–55.16) 10.12 (4.36–55.76) 0.44 (0.08–2.36) 0.62 (0.14–2.61) nets including ITNs or LLINs, using measures against mosquito bites including sleeping under a net did not differ significantly between case patients and matched controls. In Myanmar, activities and housing conditions of Chinese migrants, and vegetation nearby the staying site did not differ significantly between case patients and matched controls too. The study revealed that most case-patients were imported from the neighboring districts of Myanmar (93.9%), male (90.7%) and 16–50 years of age (90.7%), and vivax malaria (82.2%). Independent risk factors associated with malaria infection were overnight in the lowland, foothill, and half-hill areas of Myanmar. This coincides with comments in the literature: malaria cases are increasingly male, adult, clustered geographically, imported among migrant and other hard-toreach groups, and caused by P. vivax in eliminating settings.7 This is also similar in Cambodia, the males and adults had an increased risk of Plasmodium spp. infection.24 However, local malaria infection still exists, especially for patients < 15 years of age, and the youngest one only 3 years of age, who had never been in the neighboring districts of Myanmar, showed that local malaria transmission has not been interrupted completely. In the Greater Mekong Subregion (GMS), forests are commonly considered as a major determinant of malaria risk.14,25–29 In Vietnam a large proportion of all malaria cases and deaths occurred in the central mountainous and forested areas.28 In Myanmar, about 60% of the total malaria cases occurred in forest or forest fringe areas; forest workers (loggers, gem miners, etc.) were at high risk of malaria.29 The explanation is that forests and forest fringes are mountainous and hilly areas, difficult of access, sparsely inhabited by the ethnic minorities, and limited economic development and infrastructure. Men who travel into the deep forest for work become infected with bites from An. dirus and return to their home villages on the forest fringe where they become reservoirs for transmission of the parasites by An. minimus to their young children.14,29 However, the study found that malaria was associated with Chinese migrants staying in the lowland and foothill or mid-hill areas, especially along the waterside. The study results showed that the border crossers of the control group reported staying in forests more often than that of the case group, and the percentage of loggers among controls (86.5%) was higher than that among case patients (68.2%). One of the reasons might be that the study site was next to Kachin State of Myanmar, where malaria burden is particularly high and malaria outbreaks occur frequently, the malaria-related mortality rate was as high as 7.8 deaths per 1,000 people in 200529–31; Liu and others32 reported a mean parasite rate 16.3% (95% confidence interval [CI]: 12.9– 20.1%) among residents of Kachin State in 2010. In most parts of Southeast Asia, the year-round high rainfall and temperatures, and malaria vectors lead to persistent and intense malaria transmission.25 However, in northern Myanmar the mountainous areas border with China, the high altitude leads to its difference from most parts of Southeast Asia; the hilly forested areas have low temperatures, fewer mosquito breeding sites, less malaria vector, and less parasite reservoirs caused by sparse population. In theory, people who have a better knowledge of malaria transmission and methods of prevention, awareness and using measures for malaria prevention, should have reduced malaria infection. The reported investigation in the literature documented that use of bed nets provide useful protection against malaria infection.33,34 However, the results of the study did not show that the knowledge of malaria transmission and prevention was associated with the reduced risk of malaria infection; furthermore, it was not documented that the ownership and the use of bed nets or repellents was related to the reduced risk of malaria infection. On the contrary, the percentage of case patients (54.0%) who knew chemoprophylaxis was higher than that of controls (46.0%); and the percentage of case patients (43.1%) who used measures of bed nets or repellents against mosquito bites in Myanmar was higher than that of controls (13.9%). When malaria is rare to see in the eliminating setting of China, the better knowledge and behavior might be attributable to malaria infection. People who had malaria attacks might have more experience with malaria and they might actively seek knowledge and take action for malaria prevention and control. Overmatching may be one of the main limitations in this study. In the eliminating setting, malaria cases cluster on border areas, are increasingly male, adult, imported, among migrant and other hard-to-reach groups.7 Li and Fan reported that 97.5% (2,556 of 3,646) of malaria patients were imported from Myanmar and most of them were male adults in the study site.15 To exclude the confounding effect of age and sex, controls were matched by age and sex. The goal of malaria elimination was to interrupt local mosquito-borne malaria transmission in a defined geographical area, i.e., zero incidence of locally contracted cases; but imported cases will continue to occur, and continued intervention measures are required to prevent reintroduction.17,18 Therefore, community of residence was also selected as one of the matching criteria to identify the risk factors of local malaria infection. One of the purposes of using age, gender, and community of residence as matching criteria was to explore methods for reduction of the confounding effect from age and gender, and to identify risk factors of local malaria infection. However, we could not ensure whether this design might lead to overmatching and limiting assessment on these as independent risk factors. The study results did not identify any risk factors of local malaria infection because of only 12 (8.0%) locally acquired cases, therefore the purpose has not been achieved by using residence as one of the matching criteria. This failure showed that use of residence as a matching criterion may be inappropriate in a malaria elimination setting. Despite among 214 case-patients, 194 (90.7%) were male and 210 (98.1%) adult (³ 16 years), this study could not identify whether they are an independent risk or confounding factors because of using age and gender as the matching criteria. The study also had several other limitations. The first was the potential bias in capture of case patients. The cases were from records of public health facilities. The malaria patients who sought treatment from the private sector were excluded from this study. Some Chinese migrants carry anti-malarial drugs with them for self-saving during staying in Myanmar; however, the case-patients were from parasite-based diagnosis in China. In cases where the self-medication cured their malaria infection, they might not seek diagnosis and treatment from the public health service in China, which led to exclusion of them from the study too. These might lead to selection bias. The second is that some people declined to answer certain questions that they thought of as sensitive, and might cause responding bias. The third is that the financial support for this study only permitted an operation period of < 1 year, unable to recruit enough case patients in such a short period, therefore a design of retrospective case-control study was used. A weakness of this design was that the data were collected after the fact, and there are major challenges with recall bias, particularly in the control subjects who would have a hard time remembering the time before a date that is not relevant to them. In conclusion, imported malaria is particularly prominent, and most malaria patients are male, adult, and infection of P. vivax in the malaria elimination setting of Yunnan, China. The independent risk factors for malaria infection were staying in the lowland, foothill, and half hill, and availability of streamlets and paddy fields or pools nearby their staying sites of Myanmar. However, the study identified neither forest exposure nor use of vector control measures to be independently associated with malaria infection. In considering the limitations of the study, further research is needed to identify the major determinants of malaria risk on the China-Myanmar border, and to develop new strategies for malaria elimination; for example, how to promptly find and treat imported malaria infection in China, reduce malaria transmission and incidence in Myanmar through effective cooperation mechanism between China and Myanmar, and promote vigilance and use of personal protection among Chinese border crossers through effective behavior change in communication. Received May 23, 2014. Accepted for publication December 7, 2014. Published online January 19, 2015. Acknowledgments: We thank Michelle S. Hsiang and Hugh Sturrock from Global Health Group, University of California San Francisco for their comments and copyediting. Financial support: This study was funded by a grant to China National Strategy Application of the Global Fund to fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria (GFATM/CHN-S10-G13-M). 1. World Health Organization , 2011 . World Malaria Report. Geneva: WHO. 2. Bousema T , Griffin JT , Sauerwein RW , Smith DL , Churcher TS , 2012 . Hitting hotspots: spatial targeting of malaria for control and elimination . PLoS Med 9 : e1001165 . 3. Feachem RG , Phillips AA , Hwang J , 2010 . Shrinking the malaria map: progress and prospects . Lancet 376 : 1566 - 1578 . 4. Tatem AJ , Smith DL , Gething PW , Kabaria CW , Snow RW , Hay SI , 2010 . Ranking of elimination feasibility between malariaendemic countries . Lancet. 5. Gosling RD , Whittaker M , Gueye CS , Fullman N , Baquilod M , Kusriastuti R , Feachem RG , 2012 . Malaria elimination gaining ground in the Asia Pacific . Malar J 11 : 346 . 6. Ministry of Health (MOH), People's Republic of China , 2010 . Malaria Elimination Action Plan 2010 - 2020 . (in Chinese). Beijing: The Ministry , 1 - 2 . 7. Cotter C , Sturrock HJ , Hsiang MS , Liu J , Phillips AA , Hwang J , Gueye CS , Fullman N , Gosling RD , Feachem RG , 2013 . The changing epidemiology of malaria elimination: new strategies for new challenges . Lancet 382 : 900 - 916 . 8. Hsiang MS , Hwang J , Kunene S , 2012 . Surveillance for malaria elimination in Swaziland: a national cross-sectional study using pooled PCR and serology . PLoS ONE 7 : e29550 . 9. Cousens SN , Mertens TE , Kirkwood BR , Smith PG , Feachem RG , 1995 . Case-Control Studies of Common Childhood Diseases: The Example of Diarrhea . London: Macmillan Education. 10. Hayes RJ , Marsh K , Snow RW , 1992 . Case-control studies of severe malaria . Trop Med Hyg 95 : 157 - 166 . 11. Chalwe V , Geertruyden VJ , Mukwamataba D , Menten J , Kamalamba J , Mulenga M , Alessandro U , 2009 . Increased risk for severe malaria in HIV-1infected adults, Zambia . Emerg Infect Dis 15 : 749 - 755 . 12. Xu JW , Liu H , 1997 . Border malaria in Yunnan, China. Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health 28 : 456 - 459 . 13. Xu JW , Liu H , 2012 . The challenges of malaria elimination in Yunnan Province , People's Republic of China. Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health 43 : 819 - 824 . 14. Roll Back Malaria Mekong, 2003 . Mekong Malaria II: update of malaria, multi-resistance and economic development in the Mekong Region of Southeast Asia . Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health 34 (Suppl): 68 - 70 . 15. Li PS , Fan DH , 2005 . Analysis of 3646 malaria cases in Tengchong County of Yunnan Province 1999-2003 (in Chinese) . Parasitoses Infectious Dis 3 : 34 - 35 . 16. Chen GW , Wei C , Li HX , Yang LX , Huang Q , 2011 . Malaria epidemic trend and characteristics at monitoring sites in Yunnan Province in 2008 (in Chinese) . Chin J Parasitol Parasit Dis 29 : 54 - 57 . 17. World Health Organization , 2008 . Global Malaria Control and Elimination: Report of a Technical Review. Geneva: WHO. 18. World Health Organization , 2007 . A Field Manual for Low and Moderate Endemic Countries . Geneva: The World Organization. 19. Vyas S , Kumaranayake L , 2006 . Constructing socio-economic status indices: how to use principal components analysis . Health Policy Plan 21 : 459 - 468 . 20. Filmer D , Pritchett LH , 2001 . Estimating wealth effects without expenditure data-or tears: an application to educational enrolments in states of India . Demography 38 : 115 - 132 . 21. Smith L , Bruce J , Gueye L , Helou A , Diallo R , Gueye B , Jones C , Webster J , 2010 . From fever to anti-malarial: the treatmentseeking process in rural Senegal . Malar J 9 : 333 . 22. Gikandi P , Noor A , Gitonga C , Ajanga A , Snow R , 2008 . Access and barriers to measures targeted to prevent malaria in pregnancy in rural Kenya . Trop Med Int Health 13 : 208 - 217 . 23. Ward KA , Spokes PJ , McAnulty JM , 2011 . Case-control study of risk factors hospitalization caused by pandemic (H1N1) 2009 . Emerg Infect Dis 17 : 1409 - 1416 . 24. Incardona S , Vong S , Chiv L , Lim P , Nhem S , Sem R , Khim N , Doung S , Puijalon OM , Fandeur T , 2007 . Large-scale malaria survey in Cambodia: novel insights on species distribution and risk factors . Malar J 6 : 37 . 25. Prothero RM , 1999 . Malaria, forests and people in Southeast Asia . Singap J Trop Geogr 20 : 76 - 85 . 26. Guerra CA , Snow RW , Hay SR , 2006 . A global assessment of closed forests, deforestation and malaria risk . Ann Trop Med Parasitol 100 : 189 - 204 . 27. Trung HD , Van Bortel W , Sochantha T , Keokenchanh K , Quang NT , Cong LD , Coosemans M , 2004 . Malaria transmission and major malaria vectors in different geographical areas of Southeast Asia . Trop Med Int Health 9 : 230 - 237 . 28. Erhart A , Thang ND , Ky PV , Tinh TT , Overmeir CV , Speybroeck N , Obsomer V , Le XH , Le KT , Coosemans M , Dalessandro U , 2005 . Epidemiology of forest malaria in central Vietnam: a large scale cross-sectional survey . Malar J 4 : 58 . 29. Delacollette C , Souza C , Christophe E , Thimasarn K , Abdur R , Bell D , Dai TC , Gopinath D , Lu SH , Mendoza R , Ortega L , Rastogi R , Tantinimitkul C , Ehrenberg J , 2009 . Malaria trends and challenges in the greater Mekong Subregion . Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health 40 : 674 - 691 . 30. Cui L , Yan G , Sattabongkot J , Cao Y , Chen B , Chen X , Fan Q , Fang Q , Jongwutiwes S , Parker D , Sirichaisinthop J , Kyaw MP , Su XZ , Yang H , Yang Z , Wang B , Xu J , Zheng B , Zhong D , Zhou G , 2012 . Malaria in the Greater Mekong Subregion: heterogeneity and complexity . Acta Trop 121 : 227 - 239 . 31. WHO, 2008 . Malaria in the Greater Mekong Subregion: Regional and Country Profiles . Available at: http://www.whothailand.org/ EN/Section3/section. Accessed August 17 , 2014 . 32. Liu H , LI X , Chen H , Deng C , Long K , Kong L , 2011 . A crosssectional malaria survey in Mangwen District , Kachin State , Myanmar (in Chinese) . J Pathogen Bio 6 : 55 - 59 . 33. Xu JW , Wang LB , Liu XZ , Long SW , Yang GC , Yang XW , 2002 . Logistic analysis for the bed net role in malaria prevention . China Trop Med 2 : 90 - 93 . 34. Bermejo A , Veeken H , 1992 . Insecticide-impregnated bed nets for malaria control: a review of the field trials . Bull World Health Organ 70 : 293 - 296 .

This is a preview of a remote PDF: http://www.ajtmh.org/content/92/3/546.full.pdf

Jian-Wei Xu, Hui Liu, Yu Zhang, Xiang-Rui Guo, Jia-Zhi Wang. Risk Factors for Border Malaria in a Malaria Elimination Setting: A Retrospective Case-Control Study in Yunnan, China, The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 2015, 546-551, DOI: 10.4269/ajtmh.14-0321