Predation risk affects growth and reproduction of an invasive snail and its lethal effect depends on prey size
Predation risk affects growth and reproduction of an invasive snail and its lethal effect depends on prey size
Jing Guo 0 1 2
Pablo R. MartÂõn 0 2
Chunxia Zhang 0 1 2
Jia-en Zhang 0 1 2
0 Natural Science Foundation of China (grant number U1131006). URL:
1 Department of Ecology, College of Natural Resources and Environment, South China Agricultural University , Guangzhou , China , 2 Laboratorio de EcologÂõa, INBIOSUR (UNS/CONICET), Departmento de BiologÂõa, BioquÂõmica y Farmacia, Universidad Nacional del Sur, BahÂõa Blanca, Argentina, 3 Key Laboratory of Agro-Environment in the Tropics, Ministry of Agriculture , Guangzhou , China , 4 Guangdong Engineering Research Center for Modern Eco-agriculture and Circular Agriculture , Guangzhou , China
2 Editor: Manabu Sakakibara, Tokai University , JAPAN
The behavior of invasive species under predation risk has been studied extensively, but their growth and reproductive responses have rarely been investigated. We conducted experiments with juveniles and adults of the invasive freshwater snail Pomacea canaliculata, and we observed changes in growth and reproduction in response to predation risk from a caged predator (Trachemys scripta elegans). P. canaliculata produced eggs earlier in the presence of predators and injured conspecifics compared with the control group (no risk), although the total number of egg masses laid by per female was exceeded by that of the controls after 15 days. Egg hatching success noticeably decreased under predation risk, and the incubation period was significantly prolonged; however, the oviposition height of the snails was not affected. A lethal effect of predation risk was detected in juvenile snails but not in adults. The growth of juvenile P. canaliculata was inhibited under predation risk, probably due to a reduction in food intake. Adult females exhibited a greater reduction in growth under predation risk than males, which likely resulted in part from the high reproductive investment of females in egg laying. These results indicate that P. canaliculata snails under predation risk face a trade-off between predator avoidance and growth and reproduction, where the lethal effect of predation risk is linked to the size of the prey.
Most organisms must simultaneously consume enough energy for themselves while avoiding
becoming prey for predators [
]. They optimize trade-offs among different aspects (survival,
growth, reproduction, and so on) with energy limitation under predation risk [2±5]. Ample
evidence has indicated that prey growth, reproduction and behavior can be altered after
perceived predation risk [2,6±8]. Birth and growth rates are determinant of prey demography.
Changes in birth and growth rates under predation risk have attracted theoretical and empirical attention since the end of the last century . Growth is a crucial ecological trait that
gov.cn/; National Natural Science Foundation of
China to JZ; Science and Technology Planning
Project of Guangdong Province (grant number
2015B090903077) URL: http://www.gdstc.gov.cn/;
Guangdong Provincial Department of Science and
Technology to JZ; Overseas Joint Doctoral Training
Program of South China Agricultural University
(grant number 2017LHPY017). URL: http://www.
scau.edu.cn/ and South China Agricultural
University to JG. The funders had no role in study
design, data collection and analysis, decision to
publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
determines population development, and, in prey, this trait is affected by predation risk [
Moreover, an elevated predation risk is associated with reproductive activities (e.g., copulation,
pregnancy, spawning and breeding) because prey may exhibit morphological or behavioral
changes that make them vulnerable to predators during these activities [
predator-sensitive food hypothesis suggests that prey species often reduce foraging activity or efficiency in
response to predation risk, although this behavior can ultimately lead to marked decreases in
growth and reproduction [
In this study, we assessed the role of predation risk in the growth and reproductive output
of the dioecious freshwater snail Pomacea canaliculata, which is an invasive species in many
areas of the world, particularly in East and Southeast Asia [
]. The rapid growth and high
reproductive capacity of P. canaliculata are crucial for its ability to colonize and establish
populations in rice fields and other freshwater ecosystems [
]; these snails reach sexual
maturity in 2±3 months [
] and breed two to three generations per year [
] under ideal natural
Dozens of potential biological control agents have been studied to control the population
growth of P. canaliculata [
], but a few species can be applied to control snails in rice
fields to large effect, including the mallard duck Tadorna tadorna  and the common
carp Cyprinus carpio [
]. One of the major reasons that the snail P. canaliculata displays
diverse avoidance behaviors is to address the threat from predators [
]. These snails close
their operculum tightly to avoid predation [
], crawl above the waterline, or burrow into
sediment when they perceive predation risk in the form of infochemicals from predators,
artificially crushed conspecifics [
] or conspecifics that have been eaten or injured by
]. They can recognize predators by associative learning, which might help
them face many novel predators, especially as an invasive species [
]. However, the growth
and reproductive responses of P. canaliculata under predation risk are poorly understood,
although Ichinose and Tochihara [
] found that under predation risk from the common
carp Cyprinus carpio, the growth of P. canaliculata was unaffected and the investment in egg
In the present study, the red-eared slider turtle Trachemys scripta elegans was used to simu
late predation risk. This turtle is often kept as a pet in China, but it is an invasive alien species
native to the southeastern United States [
]. P. canaliculata is native to South America [
and has no co-evolutionary history with this turtle species. In China, most wild populations of
these species do not co-exist under natural conditions, though a few populations of these two
species co-exist in some habitats, such as ponds and streams.
Under predation risk by caged T. scripta elegans, the growth of juvenile and adult P.
canaliculata is expected to be inhibited since their avoidance behaviors are performed at the expense
of feeding time [
]. We studied their survival rates in the context of the juveniles being more
sensitive to predation risk [
]. Moreover, we measured the growth and survival of male and
female adult snails separately with regard to the sex differences in their alarm response [
and reproductive effort. In addition, we investigated the predator-induced reproductive
plasticity of P. canaliculata by assessing the effects of predation risk on the timing of egg mass
laying, the number of eggs, oviposition height, egg hatching success, and incubation period.
Finally, we assessed the trade-offs made by the invasive snail between predation risk avoidance
and growth and reproduction on basis of these studies. These findings should be conducive to
a more rational appraisal of the biocontrol efficiency of different predators on P. canaliculata,
since most studies have only considered the direct predation effects imposed on snails by
2 / 14
Materials and methods
All experiments were carried out in adherence to institutional guidelines for animal welfare
and were conducted under the protocol approved by the Animal Ethics Committee of the
South China Agricultural University (2015±06). We conducted experiments using P. canalicu
lata snails collected from an irrigation ditch near rice fields at the teaching and scientific
research base of South China Agricultural University in central Guangdong Province, China
(23Ê17' N, 113Ê37' E), where there are no endangered or protected species. No specific permits
were required for the field study and the locations are not protected.
The collected snails were reared in a 135-L rectangular aquarium (70 cm long × 52 cm wide ×
37 cm high) and fed lettuce (Lactuca sativa) under conditions of natural sunlight and a
temperature of 28±1ÊC. Mature and juvenile individuals were selected seven days before their use
in the experiments. The snails often reach sexual maturity at 25 mm in shell height [
shell height was measured with a Vernier caliper from the shell apex to the extreme basal
]. No turtle species were found at the collection site during the ten previous years
according to our own observations during several studies. Twelve turtles (T. scripta elegans)
weighing approximately 210 g each were purchased from Yuehe Pet Market in Guangzhou
(23Ê09' N, 113Ê24' E) and reared in an outdoor rectangular aquarium with the same size as
described above. The aquarium was tilted to ensure that the turtles had enough dry space to
rest (approximately one-third of the bottom of the aquarium). The turtles were fed live P.
canaliculata, and the water was changed every three days. The snails supplied ad libitum as food
were small (<20 mm shell height) so that the turtles could devour them quickly, thus reducing
their pain. Rearing lasted for more than 20 days in order to acclimatize the animals to the
Six 200-L polyethylene aquaria were placed outdoors in natural light and used to survey the
growth, reproduction and survival of adult P. canaliculata under predation risk. The aquaria
were divided into two equal compartments by a 0.9-mm thick metal plate with 5-mm circular
holes to allow for the passage of chemical signals from turtles and injured snails but to prevent
the passage of the turtles and snails from one compartment to the other (Fig 1). In each
aquarium, a 5-cm deep layer of sediment was placed at the bottom of one compartment; the distance
from the water surface to the top of the sediment was approximately 10 cm. The sediment was
obtained from a paddy field, air dried for a week and thoroughly mixed before use. In the
other compartment, a plastic box (21.5 cm long × 14 cm wide × 16 cm high) was provided as a
resting site for the turtles.
Like juvenile P. canaliculata, the opercula of females remain concave after sexual maturity,
whereas those of adult males become convex in the labral fringe close to the penis sheath [
observing this difference is the common method for determining the sex of a snail. Twenty
adult snails (10 females and 10 males) with shell heights of 25±31 mm were placed in the
compartment that contained sediment, and after 24 h of acclimation, two turtles and several P.
canaliculata snails (10±20 mm in shell height) were placed in the compartment without
sediment. Each aquarium was covered with plastic nets (2-mm mesh size) to prevent the snails and
turtles from escaping and mixing, and the base of the metal plate was sealed with transparent
tape to a height of 5 cm to prevent the soil from entering the other section. The six aquaria
3 / 14
Fig 1. Diagram of the aquarium used in the experiment.
were equally divided into two groups: predation risk and no predation risk (control). The
predation risk group was as described above, and the design of the control was identical except for
the absence of turtles.
The test snails were fed lettuce (L. sativa) and water lettuce (Pistia stratiotes), which were
supplied daily. The number of snails provided as turtle food was checked every day and new
snails were added in order to maintain a minimum of five live individuals during the
experiment. The experiment began when the turtles were introduced. For all of the egg masses laid
by the test snails, the date and the height of oviposition (from the lower point of each egg mass
to the water surface) were recorded. Although the height of the aquaria used in this experiment
was limited so that the maximum oviposition height of P. canaliculata could not exceed 26 cm,
more than 90% of the egg masses did not touch the top. We checked the egg masses and the
food provided for the test snails or turtles each morning because oviposition often occurs at
]. The date of oviposition was recorded as the day prior to finding the egg masses.
Approximately 5 cm of the water in the aquaria was replaced with tap water each week to avoid water fouling.
The experiment lasted 30 days and the water temperature fluctuated between 25 and 30ÊC.
The survival rate and growth of the test snails were examined at the end of the experiment; the
snail live weight was measured with a digital scale and the weight growth rate of males and
females was calculated from the averages of the living snails in each aquarium.
All of the P. canaliculata egg masses were carefully detached from the aquarium walls and
metal plates every two days with ultrathin blades. We randomly selected 4±6 egg masses in
each aquarium for transfer indoors; then were incubated at 27±2ÊC under natural light to
determine hatch success. The number of newborn snails and the day of the first hatching in
each egg mass were recorded. The incubation period was calculated from the day the eggs
were laid to the day of the first hatching [
]. The number of eggs in each of the non-incubated
egg masses was counted after the eggs were unfastened from each other in a 2% sodium
hydroxide solution for 1.5 h [
]. The total number of eggs in each aquarium was calculated as
the sum of the number of eggs in all egg masses.
4 / 14
Six small aquaria (56 cm long × 45 cm wide × 35 cm high) with the same design as
described above (Fig 1) were used to determine juvenile snail growth, feeding and survival
under predation risk, regardless of sex. The juvenile snails (shell height from 7 to 12 mm) were
fed daily with pre-weighed lettuce (L. sativa) and their intake was assessed by measuring the
wet weigh of the surplus lettuce after 24 hours. The experiment lasted 25 days, and the growth
and survival of juveniles were estimated using the aforementioned methods. No turtles died
during the two experiments, and all of the turtles continued to grow after the tests.
All of the statistical analyses were performed using SPSS version 20.0 (IBM Inc., USA).
Normality of data was tested by using the Shapiro-Wilk test, and the Mann-Whitney U test was
used to compare the six aquaria between the control and predation risk groups when this
assumption was not met. When the data satisfied the normal distribution, the effect of
predation risk on the periodic egg mass production per female was analyzed every three days and
cumulative one at the end of the experiment, using an independent sample t-test with the
aquaria as replicates. The growth and survival of adult and juvenile P. canaliculata, the total
eggs laid by females, and the food intake of juvenile snails under predation risk were also
analyzed using independent sample t-test. A nested ANOVA was used to analyze the effect of
predation risk on the oviposition height, hatching success, incubation period and clutch size (i.e.,
number of eggs per egg mass) of P. canaliculata; predation risk was categorized as a main
effect, and the aquaria was categorized as a nested effect with each egg mass as a replicate.
Differences were considered significant at p<0.05. The values are presented as the means with
More than 80 snails per aquarium were eaten by T. scripta elegans during the two experiments.
Over our many observations, approximately half of the adult and juvenile P. canaliculata often
buried themselves under predation risk; holes in the soil surface as well as buried snails were
observed frequently in the turtle group but rarely in the control group, indicating that the
turtles provided a consistently high degree of predation risk. When adult P. canaliculata were
under predation risk, egg masses were found in two aquaria on the first day; these egg masses
were found earlier than in the control, in which one egg mass first emerged on the third day.
Moreover, the number of egg masses laid by per female under predation risk was significantly
higher than that in the control during the first three days (t = -2.828, df = 4, p = 0.047, Fig 2B).
Subsequently, from the 9th-12th day, the number of egg masses increased in the absence of
turtles and surpassed the number of egg masses in the predation risk group (t = 3.333, df = 4,
p = 0.029), and this trend continued to the end of this experiment (Fig 2B). During the second
half of the study, the number of cumulative egg masses of P. canaliculata under predation risk
was gradually overtaken by the control. The gap widened as the experiment proceeded, and by
the end of the trial, the cumulative number of egg masses laid by per female was 1.53±0.16 in
the predation risk group and 2.41±0.32 in the control group, but the difference was not
significant (t = 2.492, df = 4, p = 0.067, Fig 2A).
The clutch sizes were significantly different in the control and predation risk groups,
(117.13 and 94.43 eggs, respectively) (Tables 1 and 2). Under predation risk, 1,385±133 eggs
per aquarium were produced, which was barely half the level of eggs produced under control
conditions (2,655±421; t = 2.878, df = 4, p = 0.045).
The difference in the oviposition height between the snails in the control and predation risk groups was not significant (Tables 1 and 2). The hatching success was 71.71% in the control
5 / 14
Fig 2. Cumulative (A) and Periodic (B) Egg Mass Production of Pomacea canaliculata under
Predation Risk. The asterisks indicate significant differences in the numbers of egg masses laid by per
female between the two groups. * p<0.05. Error bars represent standard errors of the mean in panels A and
B. N = 6.
Oviposition height (cm)
Hatching success (%)
Incubation period (d)
Aquaria (Predation risk)
Aquaria (Predation risk)
Aquaria (Predation risk)
Aquaria (Predation risk)
group, which was significantly higher than that under predation risk (23.50%, Tables 1 and 2).
The egg hatching success of P. canaliculata was found to be highly variable, ranging from
31.03% to 90.98% in the 16 egg masses that were randomly selected from the control group
(Table 1). By contrast, the highest hatching success under predation risk was just over 50%,
and 20% of the egg masses did not hatch at all. The P. canaliculata incubation period did differ
significantly between the control and predation risk groups (Tables 1 and 2). The statistical
analysis did not include the three unhatched egg masses in the predation risk group.
For adult P. canaliculata, all of the males and 93.33% of the females survived in the control
group, whereas only 86.67% of the males and females under predation risk were alive at the
end of the experiment. However, no statistically significant differences in the survival rate of
either male or female P. canaliculata were observed between the groups (Male: Z = -1.000,
p = 0.700, Mann-Whitney U test; Female: t = 0.707, df = 4, p = 0.519, Fig 3A). In stark contrast,
a lethal effect of predation risk was observed in juvenile snails, with only 26.67% of the
juveniles surviving in the presence of turtles; this survival rate was far below the 98.33% survival
rate observed in the control group (t = 6.081, df = 4, p = 0.004, Fig 3B).
Fig 3. Survival Rates of Adult (A) and Juvenile (B) Pomacea canaliculata under Predation Risk. The asterisks indicate
that the survival rate of P. canaliculata was significantly different between the control and predation risk groups. * p<0.05. Error
bars represent standard errors of the mean.
7 / 14
The weights of the individual male (control: 4.04±0.07 g, predation risk: 4.16±0.10 g;
t = 1.028, df = 4, p = 0.362) and female (control: 4.34±0.16 g, predation risk: 4.32±0.12 g;
t = 0.100, df = 4, p = 0.925) adult P. canaliculata in each group were similar at the start of the
experiment, but the growth of the snails was inhibited under the influence of the turtles. The
weight of the male snails increased by 57.76% in the control group and was nearly 1.5 times
higher than that of those under predation risk, although the difference was not significant
(Table 3). However, females under predation risk exhibited significantly lower increases in
weight compared with the controls (Table 3). Because juvenile snails (control: 0.22±0.00 g,
predation risk: 0.23±0.00 g, experiment initiation time; t = 0.543, df = 4, p = 0.616) experience a
period of rapid growth, their increases in weight in the control group were greater than those
in adults (Table 3). However, in the surviving 26.67% of juveniles under predation risk, their
growth was strongly inhibited (Table 3). The food intake per P. canaliculata juvenile during
the whole experiment was significantly lower (t = 5.004, df = 4, p = 0.007) in the predation risk
group (1.27±0.44 g) than in the control group (3.94±0.30 g).
Our study revealed negative effects of the perceived risk of predation by turtles on the fitness
components of an invasive snail. Predation risk affected the fecundity of females, hatching
success of eggs, and female growth of adult P. canaliculata. The negative effects of predation risk
on survival and growth were stronger in juveniles than in adults.
In China, the turtle T. scripta elegans lives primarily in rivers and lakes, and is rarely found
in rice fields [
], whereas P. canaliculata is mainly distributed in shallow waters such as
paddies and canals [
]. In addition, the North American turtle and the South American apple
snail have no co-evolutionary history in their native ranges nor have the test snails used in the
experiments coexisted with any turtle species at the collection site before our research.
Therefore, the response of the snail to predation risk by T. scripta elegans may be quite unspecific
]. The avoidance behaviors of P. canaliculata in response to predation risk by the Asiatic
turtle Chinemys reevesii also support this hypothesis [24±26,29]. Predation risk is likely
perceived by the snails in the form of chemicals compounds released by the injured or eaten snails
]. This evidence indicates that the effects found here may be common to other
subaquatic vertebrate that are predators of this snail in the invaded range.
Compared with controls, egg laying by P. canaliculata under predation risk was faster at the
beginning of the experiment. Nearly half of the adult snails, especially the females [
themselves in sediment for several hours after perceiving the predation risk. Nonetheless, this
did not prevent the females in our study from trying to lay as many eggs as possible despite
the risk of predation. Another freshwater snail, Biomphalaria glabrata, also showed an increase
in egg laying soon after exposure to a trematode parasite without parasitization [
egg laying is likely a strategy for the snails to maximize reproduction success when encountering
8 / 14
critical threats, and increased early reproductive output by an iteroparous species may be
associated with future decreases in the parents' reproduction [
]. But this compensation response
should be advantageous for P. canaliculata, which have a low probability of long adult life under
predator threat [
Indeed, the number of egg masses laid by per female P. canaliculata under predation risk
was exceeded by that in the controls in the second half of the experiment; by the end of the
experiment the number of egg masses under predation risk was approximately 2/3 of that of
the control. Suppressed oviposition, even to the point of a cessation of egg laying, has been
observed in other snails under predation risk [
]. Generally, the growth and reproductive
activities of these snails are irreconcilable with predator avoidance .
Furthermore, the clutch size decreased by approximately 20% under predation risk
compared with that of the control group. Combining the number of females and egg masses they
laid, a significant difference was observed in the total number of eggs laid between the groups;
a similar phenomenon has been observed for other freshwater snails [
]. Prey show
increased allocation of resources to predator avoidance, inevitably resulting in a decreased
reproductive output . In addition, the insufficient food intake as a result of behavioral
defense under predation risk can also lead to restricted growth and smaller-sized individuals,
which could eventually affect the fecundity of P. canaliculata females, as fecundity is
proportional to their size [
In the present study, the hatching success of P. canaliculata eggs in the control group was
71.63%, which was close to the hatching success observed in a survey conducted in Kumamoto
City, Japan [
]. However, P. canaliculata under predation risk showed a marked decline in
egg hatching success to just over 20%. Ever-present predation risk has a major adverse effect
on normal copulation in some snails [
]. Copulation in P. canaliculata averages
approximately 10 h, and sperm transfer begins two hours after penis-sheath intromission and is
related to copulation duration [
]. Perhaps predation risk leads to shorter copulations,
resulting in a higher proportion of eggs being unfertilized. In a previous study [
], the proportion
of hatched eggs under carp predation risk was not observed to change, which was likely
because the adult snails were too large to be influenced by the carp [
] and were thus affected
to a lesser extent. In addition, the hatching success of single egg masses was found to be highly
variable in several studies [
] and perhaps this variability blurred the effects of carp.
In the current study, the oviposition height of P. canaliculata was not observed to change in
the presence of predators, which was likely because the snails are less vulnerable to predation
once out of water. The incubation period was prolonged by nearly a day and a half for P.
canaliculata under predation risk (unhatched egg masses in the predation risk group were not
considered), which has also been reported for the marine snail Nucella lamellosa [
] and some
other taxa [
]. Theoretically, individuals need to maximize the trade-off between survival
and growth, and a delay in hatching under predation risk indicates that in the presence of
predators their offspring might be more secure during pre-hatching stages than during
posthatching stages . That is exactly the case for P. canaliculata, for which the eggs are secured
outside the water, which prevents the eggs from becoming prey for freshwater predators.
Moreover, the warning coloration of eggs and their antinutritive, antidigestive and neurotoxic properties allow them to successfully avoid potential predators . After hatching, the newborn snails can presumably be captured when they fall into the water; thus, delaying hatching might increase offspring survival.
According to our investigation, the survival of adult P. canaliculata was not affected by pre
dation risk, which is a common observation in juveniles and adults of other prey species
]. However, for some prey, physiological stress in the presence of predators leads to
increased vulnerability to other lethal factors, leading to death . For example, the survival
9 / 14
of juvenile Concholepas conchololepas snails decreased under predation risk [
Leucorrhinia intacta dragonfly larvae exhibited high death rates after exposure to caged predators
]. Even predation risk produced a cross-generational lethal effect on offspring of the
freshwater snail Physa acuta [
]. In the present study, the lethal effect on P. canaliculata under
predation risk was likely linked to the individual size because most of the deaths were among
juveniles with shell heights of 5±15 mm. This result can be partly explained by the fact that
juvenile P. canaliculata are more sensitive to predation risk than adults [
], a phenomenon
that has been observed in some other species [
]. In addition, the sizes of juveniles were
similar to those of most of the snails used as turtle food in this study, and previous research has
shown that juvenile P. canaliculata respond more strongly to extracts of conspecifics with
similar size than to those of conspecifics with different size [
Some lethal or sublethal factors, including insufficient energy intake , stress hormones
], predator feces and secretions may affect the survival of the snails under predation risk.
These possibilities require further study. In the particular case of P. canaliculata, we propose
two possible explanations for the increased mortality. The reduction in feeding time due to
predation risk is probably responsible for reduced growth [
], but may also have had lethal
effects in those snails whose levels of stored reserves were already low . These snails
probably succumbed to the combined effect of reduced food intake and increased energy
expenditure during burrowing. The additional time that the snails under predation risk remained
buried may have reduced their O2 intake due to the impossibility to reach the water surface
with siphon to breathe air, and this in turn may have built up an O2-debt with deleterious
The present study is the first to report a lethal effect of predation risk on P. canaliculata,
even though the predator avoidance behaviors of this snail have been documented in many
studies. The duration of predation risk might be an important factor, as our study lasted 25
days; this study time far exceeded the lengths of other studies, which lasted less than one day
because the behavioral responses of P. canaliculata to predation risk can occur within several
Defense against predators is often associated with slowed growth in prey species [
this study, the growth rates of adult female and juvenile P. canaliculata decreased under
predation risk. The potential causes likely included a reduction in feeding time associated with the
burrowing activity to avoid predators [
], as the food intake of juvenile P. canaliculata
under predation risk dropt to 32% of that in the control group. Moreover, the energy
expenditure on morphological and immune defenses under predation risk might also cause the growth
arrests observed in P. canaliculata (unpublished data) and other snails [64±66]. The degree of
growth inhibition under the risk of predation was greater in adult female snails than in males,
which is likely because males show weaker responses to predation risk , allowing them to
spend more time eating. In addition, females invest more energy into reproduction in order to
ensure more offspring. This phenomenon embodies a trade-off between growth and
reproduction under inadequate feeding conditions caused by predation risk.
Even though the alarm responses and avoidance behavior of P. canaliculata [
result in low predation rates in rice fields, it seems plausible that the indirect effects of
infochemicals from predators as well as eaten or injured snails may reduce the population growth
and spread of the snails through the combined effects on growth, fecundity, hatching success
and juvenile survival. However, the effect of the turtle T. scripta elegans on P. canaliculata still
deserves further consideration in the context of complicated ecosystems, whether the turtle
could slow the snail invasion, through predation and the related effects reported here, or
accelerate it, by reducing species richness in local communities. Moreover, the presence of the turtle
or other predators would inevitably lead to predation risk for P. canaliculata. The effects of
10 / 14
predation risk on prey population dynamics should be taken into full account [
], as these
effects are at least half as strong as direct consumption [
]. The predation risk significantly
sustains a relatively stable predator-prey dynamics, and its influence is likely to rise with an
increasing number of prey [
]. Combined with the multiple effects of predation risk in this
study, the risk effects should be included in works that evaluate the performance of predators
in controlling the numbers of the invasive snail P. canaliculata.
S1 Data. Minimal dataset.
We thank Meng Xu for his assistance with the statistical analysis. We also thank Phil Darby and four anonymous reviewers for their valuable suggestions, which greatly improved this article.
Conceptualization: Jing Guo, Jia-en Zhang.
Formal analysis: Jing Guo, Pablo R. MartÂõn, Jia-en Zhang.
Funding acquisition: Jing Guo, Jia-en Zhang.
Investigation: Jing Guo, Chunxia Zhang.
Project administration: Jia-en Zhang.
Resources: Jia-en Zhang.
Software: Jia-en Zhang.
Supervision: Jia-en Zhang.
Visualization: Jia-en Zhang.
Writing ± original draft: Jing Guo.
Writing ± review & editing: Jing Guo, Pablo R. MartÂõn, Jia-en Zhang.
11 / 14
12 / 14
13 / 14
1. McPeek MA , Grace M , Jean MLR . Physiological and behavioral responses to predators shape the growth/predation risk trade-off in damselflies . Ecology . 2001 ; 82 : 1535 ± 1545 .
2. Orrock JL , Preisser EL , Grabowski JH , Trussell GC . The cost of safety: refuges increase the impact of predation risk in aquatic systems . Ecology . 2013 ; 94 : 573 ± 579 . PMID: 23687883
3. Fraser DF , Gilliam JF . Nonlethal impacts of predator invasion: facultative suppression of growth and reproduction . Ecology . 1992 ; 73 : 959 ± 970 .
4. Urban MC . The growth-predation risk trade-off under a growing gape-limited predation threat . Ecology . 2007 ; 88 : 2587 ± 2597 . PMID: 18027761
5. PavlovaÂ V , Berec LK , Boukal DS . Caught between two Allee effects: trade-off between reproduction and predation risk . J Theor Biol . 2010 ; 264 : 787 ± 798 . https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtbi. 2010 . 03 .009 PMID: 20227422
6. Creel S , Winnie JA Jr, Christianson D. Glucocorticoid stress hormones and the effect of predation risk on elk reproduction . P Natl Acad Sci USA . 2009 ; 106 : 12388 ± 12393 .
7. Creel S , Schuette P , Christianson D. Effects of predation risk on group size, vigilance, and foraging behavior in an African ungulate community . Behav Ecol . 2014 ; 25 : 773 ± 784 .
8. Preston DL , Boland CE , Hoverman JT , Johnson PTJ . Natural enemy ecology: comparing the effects of predation risk, infection risk and disease on host behaviour . Funct Ecol . 2014 ; 28 : 1472 ± 1481 .
9. Ghalambor CK , Peluc SI , Martin TE . Plasticity of parental care under the risk of predation: how much should parents reduce care? Biol Lett . 2013 ; 9 : 20130154 . https://doi.org/10.1098/rsbl. 2013 .0154 PMID: 23760165
10. Auld JR , Houser R . Age-dependent effects of predation risk on reproductive success in a freshwater snail . Evolution . 2015 ; 69 : 2793 ± 2798 . https://doi.org/10.1111/evo.12769 PMID: 26345490
11. Hayes KA , Joshi RC , Thiengo SC , Cowie RH . Out of South America: multiple origins of non-native apple snails in Asia . Divers Distrib . 2008 ; 14 : 701 ± 712 .
12. Matsukura K , Okuda M , Cazzaniga NJ , Wada T. Genetic exchange between two freshwater apple snails, Pomacea canaliculata and Pomacea maculata invading East and Southeast Asia . Biol Invasions . 2013 ; 15 : 2039 ± 2048 .
13. Halwart M. The golden apple snail Pomacea canaliculata in Asian rice farming systems: present impact and future threat . Int J Pest Manag . 1994 ; 40 : 199 ± 206 .
14. Song HM , Mu XD , Gu DE , Luo D , Yang YX , Xu M , et al. Molecular characteristics of the HSP70 gene and its differential expression in female and male golden apple snails (Pomacea canaliculata) under temperature stimulation . Cell Stress Chaperon . 2014 ; 19 : 579 ± 589 .
15. Cowie RH . Apple snails (Ampullariidae) as agricultural pests: their biology, impacts and management . In: Barker GM, editor. Molluscs as crop pests . Wallingford: CABI; 2002 .
16. Zhou W , Wu Y , Yang J . Viability of the Ampullaria snail in China . Fujian J Agr Sci . 2003 ; 18 : 25 ± 28 .
17. Yusa Y , Sugiura N , Wada T. Predatory potential of freshwater animals on an invasive agricultural pest, the apple snail Pomacea canaliculata (Gastropoda: Ampullariidae) , in Southern Japan. Biol Invasion . 2006 ; 8 : 137 ± 147 .
18. Guo J , Zhang J -E. Status, problems and countermeasures in biological control of Pomacea canaliculata . Chinese J Ecol . 2015 ; 34 : 2943 ± 2950 .
19. Liang K , Zhang J-E , Fang L , Zhao B , Luo M , Parajuli P , et al. The biological control of Pomacea canaliculata population by rice-duck mutualism in paddy fields . Biocontrol Sci Technol . 2013 ; 23 : 674 ± 690 .
20. Ichinose K , Tochihara M , Wada T , Suguiura N , Yusa Y. Influence of common carp on apple snail in a rice field evaluated by a predator-prey logistic model . Int J Pest Manage . 2002 ; 48 : 133 ± 138 .
21. Hayes KA , Burks RL , Castro-Vazquez A , Darby PC , Heras H , MartÂõn PR , et al. Insights from an integrated view of the biology of apple snails (Caenogastropoda: Ampullariidae) . Malacologia . 2015 ; 58 : 245 ± 302 .
22. Guo J , Zhang J-E , Zhao B , Luo M , Zhang C. The role of spotted green pufferfish Tetraodon nigroviridis in controlling golden apple snail Pomacea canaliculata: an effective biological control approach involving a new agent . Biocontrol Sci Technol . 2016 ; 26 : 1100 ± 1112 .
23. Ichinose K. Influence of age and body size on alarm responses in a freshwater snail Pomacea canaliculata . J Chem Ecol . 2002 ; 28 : 2017 ± 2028 . PMID: 12474897
24. Aizaki K , Yusa Y. Learned predator recognition in a freshwater snail, Pomacea canaliculata . Malacologia . 2010 ; 52 : 21 ± 29 .
25. Yoshie H , Yusa Y. Effects of predation on the exotic freshwater snail Pomacea canaliculata (Caenogastropoda: Ampullariidae) by the indigenous turtle Chinemys reevesii (Testudines: Geoemydidae) . Appl Entomol Zool . 2008 ; 43 : 475 ± 482 .
26. Ueshima E , Yusa Y. Antipredator behaviour in response to single or combined predator cues in the apple snail Pomacea canaliculata . J Molluscan Stud . 2015 ; 81 : 51 ± 57 .
27. Ichinose K , Tochihara M. Increased per-capita investment in egg production by female apple snail in the presence of predatory common carp . Behaviour . 2003 ; 140 : 935 ± 945 .
28. Lindsay MK , Zhang Y , Forstner MR , Hahn D. Effects of the freshwater turtle Trachemys scripta elegans on ecosystem functioning: an approach in experimental ponds . Amphibia-Reptilia . 2013 ; 34 : 75 ± 84 .
29. Xu W , Zhang J , Du S , Dai Q , Zhang W , Luo M , et al. Sex differences in alarm response and predation risk in the fresh water snail Pomacea canaliculata . J Molluscan Stud . 2014 ; 80 : 117 ± 122 .
30. Dong S , Zheng G , Yu X , Fu C . Biological control of golden apple snail, Pomacea canalibulata by Chinese soft-shelled turtle, Pelodiscus sinensis in the wild rice, Zizania latifolia field . Sci Agr . 2012 ; 69 : 142 ± 146 .
31. Ip KKL , Liang Y , Lin L , Wu H , Xue J , Qiu J-W. Biological control of invasive apple snails by two species of carp: Effects on non-target species matter . Biol Control . 2014 ; 71 : 16 ± 22 .
32. Estebenet AL , MartÂõn PR . Shell interpopulation variation and its origin in Pomacea canaliculata (Gastropoda: Ampullariidae) from Southern Pampas, Argentina . J Molluscan Stud . 2003 ; 69 : 301 ± 310 .
33. Estebenet AL , MartÂõn PR , Burela S. Conchological variation in Pomacea canaliculata and other South American Ampullariidae (Caenogastropoda, Architaenioglossa) . Biocell . 2006 ; 30 : 329 ± 335 . PMID: 16972558
34. Estebenet AL , MartÂõn PR . Pomacea canaliculata (Gastropoda: Ampullariidae): life-history traits and their plasticity . Biocell . 2002 ; 26 : 83 ± 89 . PMID: 12058384
35. Gilal AA , Muhamad R , Omar D , Aziz NAA , Gnanasegaram M. Effectiveness of an automated digital infrared CCTV multi-camera system in investigating mating and oviposition behavior of apple snails, Pomacea spp . J Entomol Zool Stud . 2015 ; 3 : 254 ± 259 .
36. Albrecht E , Carreño NB , Castro-Vazquez A . A quantitative study of copulation and spawning in the South American apple-snail, Pomacea canaliculata (Prosobranchia: Ampullariidae) . Veliger . 1996 ; 39 : 142 ± 147 .
37. Liu D , Shi HT , Liu YX , Wang JC , Gong SP , Wang J , et al. Investigation on distribution status of redeared slider turtle Trachemys scripta elegans in China . Bull Biol , 2011 ; 46 : 18 ± 21 .
38. Ito K. Environmental factors influencing overwintering success of the golden apple snail, Pomacea canaliculata (Gastropoda: Ampullariidae) , in the northernmost population of Japan. Appl Entomol Zool , 2002 ; 37 : 655 ± 661 .
39. Carlsson N , Kestrup A , Martensson M , Nystrom P . Lethal and non-lethal effects of multiple indigenous predators on the invasive golden apple snail (Pomacea canaliculata) . Freshw Biol . 2004 ; 49 : 1269 ± 1279 .
40. Ichinose K , Yusa Y , Yoshida K. Alarm response of hatchlings of the apple snail, Pomacea canaliculata (Gastropoda: Ampullariidae), to aqueous extracts of other individuals . Ecol Res . 2003 ; 18 : 213 ± 219 .
41. Aizaki K , Yusa Y. Field observations of the alarm response to crushed conspecifics in the freshwater snail Pomacea canaliculata: effects of habitat, vegetation, and body size . J Ethol . 2009 ; 27 : 175 ± 180 .
42. Minchella DJ , Loverde PT . A cost of increased early reproductive effort in the snail Biomphalaria glabrata . Am Nat . 1981 ; 118 : 876 ± 881 .
43. Rawlings TA . Effect of elevated predation risk on the metabolic rate and spawning intensity of a rocky shore marine gastropod . J Exp Mar Bio Ecol . 1994 ; 181 : 67 ± 79 .
44. Koch N , Lynch B , Rochette R . Trade-off between mating and predation risk in the marine snail, Littorina plena . Invertebr Biol . 2007 ; 126 : 257 ± 267 .
45. Rigby MC , Jokela J . Predator avoidance and immune defence: costs and trade-offs in snails . P Roy Soc Lond B Bio . 2000 ; 267 : 171 ± 176 .
46. Hoverman JT , Relyea RA . How flexible is phenotypic plasticity? Developmental windows for trait induction and reversal . Ecology . 2007 ; 88 : 693 ± 705 . PMID: 17503597
47. Tamburi NE , MartÂõn PR . Effects of food availability on reproductive output, offspring quality and reproductive efficiency in the apple snail Pomacea canaliculata . Biol Invasions . 2011 ; 13 : 2351 ± 2360 .
48. Yusa Y. Nuclear sex-determining genes cause large sex-ratio variation in the apple snail Pomacea canaliculata . Genetics . 2007 ; 175 : 179 ± 184 . https://doi.org/10.1534/genetics.106.060400 PMID: 17057241
49. Burela S , MartÂõn PR. Evolutionary and functional significance of lengthy copulations in a promiscuous apple snail, Pomacea canaliculata (Caenogastropoda: Ampullariidae) . J Molluscan Stud . 2011 ; 77 : 54 ± 64 .
50. Mochida O. Spread of freshwater Pomacea snails (Pilidae, Mollusca) from Argentina to Asia . Micronesica. 1991 ; 3 : 51 ± 62 .
51. Miner BG , Donovan DA , Andrews KE . Should I stay or should I go: predator- and conspecific-induced hatching in a marine snail . Oecologia . 2010 ; 163 : 69 ± 78 . https://doi.org/10.1007/s00442-010-1570-z PMID: 20151156
52. Ireland DH , Wirsing AJ , Murray DL . Phenotypically plastic responses of green frog embryos to conflicting predation risk . Oecologia . 2007 ; 152 : 162 ± 168 . https://doi.org/10.1007/s00442-006 -0637-3 PMID: 17216211
53. De Roeck ERM , Artois T , Brendonck L . Consumptive and non-consumptive effects of turbellarian (Mesostoma sp .) predation on anostracans . Hydrobiologia . 2005 ; 542 : 103 ± 111 .
54. Dreon MS , Frassa MV , CeolÂõn M , Ituarte S , Qiu J-W , Sun J , et al. Novel animal defences against predation: a snail egg neurotoxin combining lectin and pore-forming chains that resembles plant defense and bacteria attack toxins . PLoS One . 2013 ; 8: e63782 . https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone. 0063782 PMID: 23737950
55. NystroÈm P. Non-lethal predator effects on the performance of a native and an exotic crayfish species . Freshw Biol . 2005 ; 50 : 1938 ± 1949 .
56. McCauley SJ , Rowe L , Fortin M-J . The deadly effects of ªnonlethalº predators . Ecology . 2011 ; 92 : 2043 ± 2048 . PMID: 22164828
57. ManrÂõquez PH , Jara ME , Opitz T , Castilla JC , Lagos NA . Effects of predation risk on survival, behaviour and morphological traits of small juveniles of Concholepas concholepas (loco) . Mar Ecol Prog Ser . 2013 ; 472 : 169 ± 183 .
58. Childress MJ , Lung MA . Predation risk, gender and the group size effect: does elk vigilance depend upon the behaviour of conspecifics? Anim Behav . 2003 ; 66 : 389 ± 398 .
59. Stone AI . Age and seasonal effects on predator-sensitive foraging in squirrel monkeys (Saimiri sciureus): a field experiment . Am J Primatol . 2007 ; 69 : 127 ± 141 . https://doi.org/10.1002/ajp.20334 PMID: 17154385
60. Preisser EL , Bolnick DI , Benard MF . Scared to death? The effects of intimidation and consumption in predator-prey interactions . Ecology . 2005 ; 86 : 501 ± 509 .
61. Tamburi NE , MartÂõn PR . Effects of absolute fasting on reproduction and survival of the invasive apple snail Pomacea canaliculata in its native range . Curr Zool . 2016 ; 62 : 369 ± 375 .
62. Seuffert ME , MartÂõn PR . Dependence on aerial respiration and its influence on microdistribution in the invasive freshwater snail Pomacea canaliculata (Caenogastropoda, Ampullariidae) . Biol Invasion . 2010 ; 12 : 1695 ± 1708 .
63. Steiner UK , Van Buskirk J. Predator-induced changes in metabolism cannot explain the growth/predation risk tradeoff . PLoS One . 2009 ; 4: e6160 . https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone. 0006160 PMID: 19582147
64. Brookes JI , Rochette R . Mechanism of a plastic phenotypic response: predator-induced shell thickening in the intertidal gastropod Littorina obtusata . J Evol Biol . 2007 ; 20 : 1015 ± 1027 . https://doi.org/10.1111/j. 1420- 9101 . 2007 . 01299 . x PMID : 17465912
65. Auld JR . The effects of predation risk on mating system expression in a freshwater snail . Evolution . 2010 ; 64 : 3476 ± 3494 . https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1558- 5646 . 2010 . 01079 . x PMID : 20624174
66. Sandland GJ , Carmosini N. Combined effects of a herbicide (atrazine) and predation on the life history of a pond snail, Physa gyrina . Environ Toxicol Chem . 2006 ; 25 : 2216 ± 2220 . PMID: 16916041
67. Ydenberg RC , Butler RW , Lank DB , Smith BD , Ireland J . Western sandpipers have altered migration tactics as peregrine falcon populations have recovered . P Roy Soc B-Biol Sci . 2004 ; 271 : 1263 ± 1269 .