The effects of high dose of two manganese supplements (organic and inorganic) on the rumen microbial ecosystem
The effects of high dose of two manganese supplements (organic and inorganic) on the rumen microbial ecosystem
Svetlana KisÏ idayovaÂ 0 1 2
Peter PristasÏ 0 1 2
Michaela Zimovč aÂkovaÂ 0 2
Monika BlanaÂ r WencelovaÂ 0 1 2
Lucia Homol'ovaÂ 0 1 2
KatarÂõna MihalikovaÂ 0 1 2
Klaudia Čobanov aÂ 0 1 2
ĽubomÂõra GresÏ aÂ kovaÂ 0 1 2
Zora VaÂ radyovaÂ 0 1 2
0 Funding: This study was funded by the Grant Agency of the Ministry of Education , Science , Research and Sport of the Slovak Republic and the Slovak Academy of Sciences VEGA 2/0069/17 to
1 Institute of Animal Physiology, Slovak Academy of Sciences, KosÏice, Slovakia, 2 Institute of Biology and Ecology, University of P. J. SÏafaÂ rik, KosÏice , Slovakia
2 Editor: Garret Suen, University of Wisconsin Madison , UNITED STATES
Little is known about the effects of the high dose and types of manganese supplements on rumen environment at manganese intake level close above the limit of 150 mg/kg of dry feed matter. The effects of high dose of two manganese supplements (organic and inorganic) on rumen microbial ecosystem after four months of treatment of 18 lambs divided into three treatment groups were studied. We examined the enzyme activities (α-amylase, xylanase, and carboxymethyl cellulase), total and differential microscopic counts of rumen ciliates, total microscopic counts of bacteria, and fingerprinting pattern of the eubacterial and ciliates population analyzed by PCR-DGGE. Lambs were fed a basal diet with a basal Mn content (34.3 mg/kg dry matter; control) and supplemented either with inorganic manganous sulfate or organic Mn-chelate hydrate (daily 182.7, 184 mg/kg dry matter of feed, respectively). Basal diet, offered twice daily, consisted of ground barley and hay (268 and 732 g/kg dry matter per animal and day). The rumens of the lambs harbored ciliates of the genera of Entodinium, Epidinium, Diplodinium, Eudiplodinium, Dasytricha, and Isotricha. No significant differences between treatment groups were observed in the total ciliate number, the number of ciliates at the genus level, as well as the total number of bacteria. Organic Mn did decrease the species richness and diversity of the eubacterial population examined by PCR-DGGE. No effects of type of Mn supplement on the enzyme activities were observed. In comparison to the control, α-amylase specific activities were decreased and carboxymethyl-cellulase specific activities were increased by the Mn supplements. Xylanase activities were not influenced. In conclusion, our results suggested that the intake of tested inorganic and organic manganese supplements in excess may affect the specific groups of eubacteria. More studies on intake of Mn supplements at a level close to the limit can reveal if the changes in microbial population impact remarkably the other rumen enzymatic activities.
Nutritional requirements for Mn vary depending on the animal species and the stage of the life
cycle. Ruminants are not well able to use Mn naturally present in the feed. Only 1% or less of
LG. The funders had no role in study design, data
collection and analysis, decision to publish, or
preparation of the manuscript.
manganese is absorbed from the ruminant diet [
]. Manganese is necessary component and
cofactor of enzymes involved in lipid, carbohydrate and protein metabolism, fertility and
immune functions [2±4], so Mn is added to various mineral food supplements. The maximum
EU authorized total content of Mn is 150 mg/kg of complete feed for food-producing animals,
except fish, for which it is 100 mg/kg [
]. Manganese oxide and manganese sulfate
monohydrate are safe Mn sources for all animal species. The addition of these compounds at the
permitted level does not threaten either the safety of consumers or the environment [
organic forms of microelements are considered to be more available to animals [
bioavailability of manganese from manganese methionine was 120% of that present in the
sulfate form in experiments conducted with lambs . Possible reasons may be that they form
fewer complexes with other components of food, or they are less likely to cause adverse effects
in the digestive tract [
]. The organic forms of Mn could have a more extensive use, and
therefore, they can be added in smaller amounts to feed, since such Mn is more absorbed and is also
less likely to be removed from the body, thus leading to less accumulation in the environment
The impact of the high dose of Mn on rumen environment both in vivo and in vitro is little
described. An increased amount of Mn in the diet could affect the activity of microorganisms
or their produced enzymes. In the in vitro studies, the decrease of rumen cellulose digestion
was observed with more than 100 μg/ml added inorganic Mn and the increase of rumen
cellulose digestion was observed with 5±30 μg/ml added inorganic Mn [
]. Added inorganic
Mn (100 ppm) increased in vitro dry matter digestibility in cattle rumen content fermentation
in vitro . The omission of Mn resulted in a significant lowering of the rumen cellulose
digestion in vitro [
]. On the other hand, a high concentration of Mn can enhance the
cellulolytic activities of other organisms, e.g., Aspergillus niger. The cellulase activities of A. niger were
increased with added inorganic Mn in the range of 0.16 g/l to 0.59 g/l [
]. No other studies
describe the effects of high Mn dose (either organic or inorganic) on rumen microbial
activities or population composition.
This work contributes to the expansion of knowledge on the effects of Mn sources (organic
and inorganic) on the rumen microbial ecosystem at Mn intake level close to the limit. We
hypothesized that the dose of Mn close above the maximum authorized level (150 mg/kg)
could affect the rumen microbial population composition and their activities irrespective of
the Mn sources. In the present study, we investigated the effects of high dose of two manganese
supplements (organic and inorganic) on some aspects of the lamb rumen microbial ecosystem.
We examined the enzyme activities (α-amylase, xylanase, and carboxymethyl cellulase), total
and differential microscopic counts of rumen ciliates, total microscopic counts of bacteria, and
fingerprinting pattern of the eubacterial and ciliates population analyzed by polymerase chain
reaction denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (PCR-DGGE).
Material and methods
The experimental protocol was approved by the Ethical Committee of the Institute of Animal
Physiology, SAS, and the State Veterinary and Food Office (Ro-1479/11-221/3). All animals
were kept, and the experimental procedures used in this study were performed in accordance
with European Community guidelines (Directive 2010/63/EU).
Animals, diets and experimental design
Eighteen ewe lambs of the Improved Valachian breed (wool type) with a mean age of 7 months
and an initial average weight of 21.1±0.5 kg were used. Before experimentation, the lambs
were reared with their mothers in one herd. The lambs were allotted in a completely
2 / 12
randomized single factor design with three dietary treatments and six replicates. The animals
were fed a basal diet providing 34.3 mg Mn/kg DM (Table 1). To examine the effects of high
dose of two types Mn supplements the animals were treated with either inorganic manganese
(IMn, 182.7 mg total Mn/kg DM) or organic manganese (OMn, 184 mg total Mn/kg DM). No
manganese supplement was added to the control group. The three experimental diets were
offered to lambs for a 16-week treatment period. Each lamb was fed a basal diet offered twice
daily. The IMn as manganese sulfate monohydrate (MnSO4.H2O, Sigma-Aldrich, USA) or
OMn as manganese glycine chelate (Glycinoplex-Mn22%, Phytobiotics, Futterzusatzstoffe
GmbH, Eltville, Germany) was daily mixed with ground barley grains, and the barley
consumption by each animal was visually checked. During the entire experimental period, the
lambs were housed individually in 1.65×1.25 m pens with free access to fresh potable water
through an automatic cup waterer. A trace mineral lick without Mn was offered to each lamb
once a week (Table 1). Animals were slaughtered at the end of the experiment in an abattoir at
the Institute of Animal Physiology (KoÏsice, № SK U 07016). The lambs were not fed at the day
of the slaughtering. Rumens were surgically removed, ligated at the reticulum and omasum,
and transferred to the next lab for collecting samples of total contents. The content in isolated
rumens was thoroughly mixed, and total rumen contents were collected for eubacterial and
ciliate population PCR-DGGE analysis, for a microscopic count of ciliates and total bacteria and
the evaluation of enzyme activities against polysaccharides (starch, xylan, and
carboxymethylcellulose). For eubacterial and ciliate population DGGE analysis and evaluation of enzyme
activities, the total rumen content of approximately 10 g/animal was divided into 2 ml
Eppendorf microtubes and frozen at -70ÊC until analysis. For the microscopic counts, about 15
g/animal of total rumen content was preserved with an equal amount of 10% formaldehyde
solution (w/w) in 50 ml polypropylene tubes with screw caps and stored at 8ÊC in a refrigerator
Qualitative analysis of the eubacterial and ciliated protozoa populations by
Total community DNA was isolated from rumen content samples (5 g) using a QIAamp DNA
Stool Mini Kit (Qiagen, Valencia, CA, USA) according to the manufacturer's instructions. The
quality of the community DNA was assessed by 0.8% agarose gel electrophoresis. DNA was
visualized by ethidium bromide staining and recorded using the Gel Logic 212 PRO imaging
system (Carestream, NY, USA). Total DNA (50 ng) was used as a template for PCR
amplification of the 16S rRNA gene. In the first round of PCR, universal primers for 16S rRNA fD1
3 / 12
(5'-AGA GTT TGA TCC TGG CTC AG-3'), rP2 (5'-ACG GCT ACC TTG TTA CGA
CTT-3') and conditions specified by  were used to amplify of about 1500 base pairs
regions of the 16S rDNA genes. The obtained 16S rDNA fragments were subsequently used as
a template for the second round of PCR using specific bacterial primers GC-clamp-968f
(5'CGC CCG GGG CGC GCC CCG GGC GGG GCG GGG GCA CGG GGG GAA CGC GAA
GAA CCT TAC—3') and 1401r (5'- CGG TGT GTA CAA GACCC—3') and the conditions
specified by [
]. For the analysis of protozoal populations approximately 200 bp of the 18S
rDNA gene were amplified in one step using the primers (forward± 5-'GGT GGT GCA TGG
CCG-3', reverse± 5'-AAT TGC AAA GAT CTA TCC C-3' with a 45 nucleotide
GCclamp linked to the 5` terminus of the reverse primer) and the conditions specified by [
PCR reactions were performed in a 50 μL PCR mixture containing 1 μl of DNA, 1 x PCR
buffer, 2 mmol/l MgCl2, 1 μl of a 200 μmol/l sample of each dNTP, 1.25 U Platinum Taq DNA
polymerase (Invitrogen, CA USA) and 25 pmol of each primer using a MJ Mini thermal cycler
(Bio-Rad Laboratories, USA). The specificity of PCR reactions was monitored by 1.2% agarose
gel electrophoresis. PCR products generated with GC-968f and 1401r primers were subjected
to DGGE analysis. DGGE was performed using the DCodeTM Universal Mutation Detection
System (Bio-Rad Laboratories, Hercules, CA, USA). PCR reaction products in a total volume
of 45 μl were loaded onto an 8% (w/v) polyacrylamide gel (40% Acrylamide-Bis 37.5:1) in 1 x
TAE (40 mM Tris, 20 mM acetate, 1mM EDTA) containing a linear denaturing gradient
ranging from 30±60% denaturant (100% denaturant solution consists of 7 M urea and 40%
formamide). Electrophoresis was run for 17 h at a constant voltage of 50 V and a temperature 60ÊC.
The ethidium bromide stained DGGE gels were recorded using the GelLogic Pro
documentation system, and the DGGE fingerprints obtained were processed using Phoretix1D software
(TotalLab Ltd, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK) without any user interference.
Estimation of total bacterial and ciliated protozoal counts
The number of rumen ciliates was estimated by counting microscopically the protozoa in an
aliquot of the suitably diluted sample streaked on a glass slide . At least four replicates were
counted per sample. The methyl green was used to reveal the ciliates nuclei. The iodine
solution was used to reveal the skeletal plates. The abundance of total bacteria was estimated by
direct bacterial count through image analysis of pictures taken under bright field illumination
of dried smears of formaldehyde-fixed samples [20±22]. Two smears stained with methylene
blue and with known dimensions and known volumes per sample (animal) were prepared
according to the Breed method [
]. Twenty randomly selected pictures per smear were taken.
The images were processed and analyzed using ImageJ software according to ImageJ software
]. Ciliates and bacteria numbers per gram of wet rumen content were
expressed as geometric means of log-natural transformed values ± geometric standard
Preparation of crude protein extracts and measurement of hydrolytic
Preparation of crude protein extracts from rumen contents, and measurements of hydrolytic
enzyme activities against starch, xylan, and carboxymethyl-cellulose (CMC) were carried out
according to [
]. Thawed samples of rumen contents were resuspended at a 1:5 ratio in citrate
] with pH 6.8 containing a protease inhibitor cocktail (Complete Mini EDTA-free
protease inhibitor cocktail tablets, Roche Diagnostics, Meylan, France). The suspensions were
then sonicated on ice (three times for 30 seconds, Ultrasonic Homogenizer 4710 Series;
ColeParmer Instrument Co., Chicago, IL), and the sonicated extracts were used as crude protein
4 / 12
extracts. The protein concentrations in the extracts were measured using the Bradford assay
], with bovine serum albumin as the standard. The activities of polysaccharide-degrading
enzymes were determined by measuring the amount of reducing sugar formation from the
respective polymeric substrates after incubation with the crude protein extracts [
Hydrolytic reactions were performed at 39ÊC and pH 6.8 during 2h incubations. The
hydrolytic activities were measured for each rumen content sample (animal) and each enzyme
separately in three different assays (n = 6). Enzymatic activities were expressed in SI units, katals (1
kat = 1 mol/s). One katal is the amount of enzyme that converts 1 mole of substrate per second,
so 1 U = 16.67 katal. Specific catalytic activities were expressed as microkatals of reducing
sugar equivalent produced per gram of protein (μkat/g).
Statistical analysis was performed using analysis of variance as a single factor design with three
levels of treatment (Control, IMn, OMn). DGGE fingerprints were transformed into a
bandmatching table, and a dendrogram was constructed using the Dice similarity coefficient and
UPGMA (Unweighted Pair Group Method with Arithmetic Mean) algorithm implemented in
the Phoretix1D software package. Normalized band volumes calculated by Phoretix1D were
used for calculation of diversity indices. The biodiversity indices (Shannon-Wiener diversity
index, Evenness, and species richness) [
] were calculated for every lane using Species
Diversity and Richness software version 4.1.2 (Pisces Conservation Ltd, Pennington, UK). Statistical
differences in population variability were evaluated using One-way Anova with Bonferroni's
Multiple Comparison Test. Ciliates and total bacteria microscopic counts were expressed per
gram of wet weight of rumen content. The effects of manganese supplements on microbial
counts (ciliates and bacteria), the Shannon-Wiener biodiversity index and genus evenness of
major ciliates (Entodinium, Eudiplodinium, Epidinium, Isotricha, Dasytricha, and Diplodinium)
were evaluated by the nonparametric Kruskal-Wallis method [
]. Differences in protein
concentration and enzymatic activities were estimated by parametric One-way Anova with
Bonferroni's Multiple Comparison Test. Only results obtained on rumen contents which were
colonized by ciliates were statistically evaluated. Values of enzymes activities of rumen
contents with missing out ciliates of organic Mn group were excluded from the statistical
evaluation due to extreme values (n = 2). Treatment effects were determined to be significant at
P < 0.05. GraphPad Prism software was used for statistical evaluations (GraphPad Software,
Inc. San Diego, CA, USA).
Qualitative analysis of eubacterial and ciliated protozoa populations by
DGGE analysis of the eubacterial population led to the detection of highly variable DGGE
profiles showing from 7 to 28 bands per sample (Dice similarity coefficients 0.2±0.75). A similar
dendrogram (Fig 1A) indicated that inorganic Mn did not influence the composition of the
eubacterial population. Organic Mn addition, however, led to a shift in the eubacterial
population. Samples from animals fed organic Mn showed the decreased variability of the eubacterial
population, observed as a disappearance of bands. The average number of bands in samples
from animals fed organic Mn was 11.6 compared to 20.2 and 22.8 for animals fed inorganic
Mn or control animals, respectively. The Shannon-Wiener diversity index was statistically
lower (P = 0.05) in animals fed organic Mn compared to animals fed inorganic Mn or control
animals (1.8 compared to 2.5 for both control and inorganic Mn-supplemented animals).
5 / 12
Fig 1. Effects of manganese on rumen microbial community. Principal component analysis of denaturing gradient
gel electrophoresis (DGGE) patterns of the rumen eubacterial (A) and ciliated protozoal (B) community in lamb fed
two types of manganese supplements for 16 weeks; Control group, Lanes 1±5; Inorganic Mn, Lanes 6±10; Organic Mn,
DGGE analysis of the population of ciliated protozoa led to the detection of 5 to 16 bands per
sample. Similar banding patterns were observed for most samples (Dice similarity coefficients
0.6±0.9), except sample 11. The similarity dendrogram (Fig 1B) indicated that Mn supplements
did not influence the composition of the protozoal population. The average Shannon-Wiener
diversity index of the protozoal population of animals fed organic Mn was 1.5 compared to 1.9
and 1.8 for animals fed inorganic Mn or control animals, respectively. The differences,
however, were not statistically significant (Table 2, P > 0.05).
Effects of manganese supplements on total bacterial and ciliated protozoal
Rumens of lambs were colonized with the B type population of ciliated protists, except two
animals in the group with OMn supplement (Table 3). Major genera were Entodinium (76±84%),
Epidinium (E. ecaudatum caudatum, 8±13%), Eudiplodinium (E. maggii, 2±4%), Dasytricha (D.
ruminantium, 5±9%) and Isotricha (I. intestinalis, I. prostoma, 1±2%). Few empty pellicles of
6 / 12
Within a row, means with a different superscript letter (a, b) differ at P < 0.05
Microscopic counts of major genera of ciliates (Entodinium, Eudiplodinium, Epidinium, Isotricha, Dasytricha, and Diplodinium)
Number of bands were evaluated in DGGE profiles; Values are means ± standard deviation
large ciliates and a few disintegrated small ciliates were visible microscopically in the rumen
contents of two animals of the group with OMn supplement (S1 Fig). Average total
microscopic counts of ciliates were 13.13±13.68 per gram of wet rumen content, expressed as
geometric means of log-natural transformed values. Average total microscopic counts of
prokaryotes were 23.26±23.60 per gram of wet rumen content, expressed as geometric means
of log-natural transformed values. No effects of type of manganese supplements on the
microbe counts were observed at the tested doses (Table 3). No treatment effects were
observed on the population variability of the major genera of ciliates (Entodinium,
Eudiplodinium, Epidinium, Isotricha, Dasytricha, and Diplodinium), expressed as the Shannon-Wiener
diversity index and Evenness index (Table 2).
Effects of manganese supplements on protein content and polysaccharide
No effects of type of manganese supplements were observed on protein concentration in
rumens harboring ciliates (Table 3). The protein concentrations were low in two rumens
without observable live ciliates (supplemented with organic manganese). Alfa-amylase specific
catalytic activities were decreased in rumen contents supplemented with inorganic manganese in
comparison to the control group (P < 0.021). CMC-ase specific katalytic activities were
increased in both supplemented groups in comparison to the control group (IMn, P < 0.05;
OMn, P < 0.01). Manganese supplements did not influence xylanase activity.
In general, the count of ciliated protists in rumens varies from a few thousand to millions of
protozoa per gram of rumen content, depending mainly on the feed taken by the host [
In our samples, we estimated the number of ciliates microscopically from 56.3 × 104 to
93.3 × 104 per gram of wet rumen content (13.13±13.48 as log-natural transformed values).
The numbers of rumen bacteria occur in the range of 109±1011 per gram of wet rumen
]. In our samples, we estimated the number of bacteria from 1.35 × 1010 to
1.81 × 1010 per gram of wet rumen contents (23.26±23.60 as log-natural transformed values).
Their counts were in the range typical for domesticated ruminants. PCR-DGGE detects only a
limited part of the microbial diversity in a rumen because the diversity of bacteria in the
rumen is extraordinarily high. Rumen bacterial community may easily contain more than
10,000 different species, while the DGGE resolution of more than 20±50 bands on a gel is
]. DGGE can evaluate just the most dominant members of the bacterial communityÐ
7 / 12
OMn, no ciliates
Ciliates (bacteria) numbers per gram of wet rumen content were expressed as geometric means of log-natural transformed values ± geometric standard deviation; %,
genus percentage of total ciliates number; ND, not detectable; CMC-ase, carboxymethyl-cellulase; Counts of microbes, protein and enzymes values are means ± standard
deviation; Katalytic activity, μkat/l; Specific katalytic activity, μkat/g protein. Within a row, means with a superscript symbol ( ) differ against to control group
P < 0.05
P < 0.01.
accounting for at least 3% of total population. DGGE profiles demonstrate the overall changes
in community documented by the composition of abundant members of the community.
DGGE seems to be useful for assessing changes in the main constituents of rumen microbial
community. In our study, DGGE analysis revealed a decrease of eubacterial variability in the
group supplemented with organic manganese. Similar effects of inorganic manganese of
0.013±0.045 g/kg of feed dry matter on sheep rumen prokaryotes were observed in the study of
], where manganese treatments did not affect the total number of rumen bacteria or the
size structure of bacteria population. Our results point to the potentially adverse effects of the
high experimental dose of organic manganese on some groups of rumen microbes. It seems
that organic manganese may be more accessible (bioavailable) for rumen microbes, resulting
in their higher sensitivity in comparison with a similar concentration of inorganic manganese.
The analysis of Mn content in whole cells of rumen microbes could validate the assumption on
the better bioavailability of organic Mn.
We cannot explain the absence of live ciliates in the rumen contents of two lambs by the
action of the organic manganese supplement exclusively because we did not examine the
animals before experimentation. On the other hand, the spontaneous disappearance of protozoa
8 / 12
from rumens can occur in young lambs [
]. However, the presence of empty pellicles and
disintegrated ciliates points to recent events of ciliates death. According to authors' long-term
experiences, the presence of empty pellicles in rumen content point to the death of ciliates
approximately 24-48h ago. In rumen content, the pellicles of ciliates persist no longer than
48h. Usually, pellicles are not present in rumen contents at the presence of live protozoa.
Otherwise, that means, that ciliates colonized rumens. However, these indices did not correspond
with the DGGE analysis, which revealed ciliates bands in the respective samples (see L11, L15).
It seems the DNA of ciliates is relatively resistant to gut microbial digestion. They can be yet
detected in feces [
] though no live ciliates have been observed in the feces of ruminants to
date, except parasitic Buxtonella species [
]. Therefore, interpretation of molecular data
should be made with caution, if no other observations (e.g., microscopic) are made.
Rumen protozoa may impact the level of microbial protein synthesis since they prey on
rumen bacteria [19,38±40]. Several studies revealed that the absence of ciliated protists resulted
in a higher number of bacteria and higher synthesis of microbial protein in the rumen [41±
43]. However, we did not record any differences in the numbers of bacteria in the rumen
samples of two ciliates-free animals compared to faunated animals. Also, the amount of protein in
these samples was much lower than in the others, which does not coincide with previous
studies. The type of analysis can cause contradictions in the concentration of proteins in our results
and the results of other works. On the other hand, a more probable reason may be that there
was not enough time to compensate microbial protein by the growth of prokaryotes after the
probably recent event of ciliates death. However, we observed a slight nonsignificant increase
of protein contents of Mn treated groups which may impact some enzyme activities.
Rumen ciliates can remarkably influence hydrolytic activities in the rumen. The effect of
manganese on the enzymatic hydrolytic activities of rumen microorganisms is poorly studied.
In our study, we observed a decrease the amylolytic specific catalytic activity only in the group
with inorganic Mn in comparison to the control group. The results are consistent with other
studies in which a negative impact of ciliates on rumen amylolytic bacteria was found [
CMC-ase specific activity was increased by both Mn supplements in comparison to control
group. Manganese is an important lignocellulolytic agent [
]. Hydrolysis of cellulose in an in
vitro rumen mixed culture was affected by Mn in the study of [
]. The omission of Mn
significantly reduced cellulolytic activity in vitro in the study of [
]. On the other hand, a high dose
of Mn resulted in the inhibition of cellulolytic activity in vitro [
]. Rumen ciliates can
contribute significantly to the fiber digestion in the rumen. The presence of ciliates can stimulate
cellulolysis by the bacteria. Studies in vitro and in vivo indicated that approximately a quarter to
one-third of fiber breakdown in the rumen was protozoal [
]. High dose of either organic
or inorganic Mn has no effects on xylanase activity. We found no effects of type of Mn
supplements on the measured enzyme activities, in contrast to studies which claim that organic
forms of Mn are biologically more accessible and more usable [
The results of this work suggest that the high dose of Mn close to the limit, both inorganic and
organic, does not affect the number and species composition of ciliates and the number of
bacteria. However, it may influence the composition of the eubacterial community and the
enzymatic activities of rumen microorganisms, especially amylolytic and cellulolytic activities.
S1 Fig. The image of rumen content with the pellicles of dead rumen protozoa. The red
arrows point to the pellicles of dead rumen ciliates of un lamb of the OMn group (scale bars
9 / 12
indicate 10 μm).
The authors thank Mrs. V. VenglovskaÂ for her skilled technical assistance and Mr. David L.
McLean for the language revision of the manuscript.
Conceptualization: Klaudia ČobanovaÂ, ĽubomÂõra GreÏsaÂkovaÂ, Zora VaÂradyovaÂ.
Data curation: Svetlana KiÏsidayovaÂ, Peter PristaÏs, KatarÂõna MihalikovaÂ.
Formal analysis: Svetlana KiÏsidayovaÂ, Peter PristaÏs, Michaela ZimovčaÂkovaÂ, Lucia Homol'ovaÂ,
KatarÂõna MihalikovaÂ, Zora VaÂradyovaÂ.
Funding acquisition: Klaudia ČobanovaÂ, ĽubomÂõra GreÏsaÂkovaÂ.
Investigation: Svetlana KiÏsidayovaÂ, Peter PristaÏs, Michaela ZimovčaÂkovaÂ, Monika BlanaÂr
WencelovaÂ, Lucia Homol'ovaÂ, KatarÂõna MihalikovaÂ, Zora VaÂradyovaÂ.
Methodology: Svetlana KiÏsidayovaÂ, Peter PristaÏs, Zora VaÂradyovaÂ.
Project administration: Klaudia ČobanovaÂ, ĽubomÂõra GreÏsaÂkovaÂ.
Resources: Klaudia ČobanovaÂ, ĽubomÂõra GreÏsaÂkovaÂ.
Supervision: Peter PristaÏs, Klaudia ČobanovaÂ, ĽubomÂõra GreÏsaÂkovaÂ.
Validation: Klaudia ČobanovaÂ, Zora VaÂradyovaÂ.
Visualization: Svetlana KiÏsidayovaÂ, Peter PristaÏs.
Writing ± original draft: Svetlana KiÏsidayovaÂ, Peter PristaÏs.
Writing ± review & editing: Svetlana KiÏsidayovaÂ, Peter PristaÏs, Klaudia ČobanovaÂ, ĽubomÂõra
10 / 12
Williams AG, Coleman GS. The Rumen Protozoa. New York: Springer-Verlag New York Inc.; 1992.
11 / 12
1. Hidiroglou M. Manganese in ruminant nutrition . Can J Anim Sci . 1979 ; 59 : 217 ± 236 . https://doi.org/10. 4141/cjas79- 028
2. Suttle NF . Manganese. In: Suttle NF, editor. The mineral nutrition of livestock. 4th ed. Wallingford: CABI; 2010 . pp. 355 ± 376 .
3. Spears JW . Trace mineral bioavailability in ruminants . J Nutr . Department of Animal Science, Interdepartmental Nutrition Program, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC 27695 ±7621, United States ; 2003 ; 133 .
4. Crowley JD , Traynor DA , Weatherburn DC . Enzymes and proteins containing manganese: an overview . In: Sigel A , Sigel H , editors. Metal Ions in Biological Systems: Volume 37 : Manganese and Its Role in Biological Processes . Marcel Dekker; 2000 . pp. 209 ± 78 .
5. Register (EC) No 1831 / 2003 . European Union Register of Feed Additives . Edition 250. Appendixes 3e , 4 ± 24 . 01 . 2017 . 2017 .
6. Gresakova L , Venglovska K , Cobanova K. Dietary manganese source does not affect Mn, Zn and Cu tissue deposition and the activity of manganese-containing enzymes in lambs . J Trace Elem Med Biol . 2016 ; 38 : 138 ± 143 . http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jtemb. 2016 . 05 .003 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtemb. 2016 . 05 .003 PMID: 27267351
7. Kinal S , Korniewicz A , Søupczyńska M , Bodarski R , Korniewicz D , ČermaÂk B. Effect of the application of bioplexes of zinc, copper and manganese on milk quality and composition of milk and colostrum and some indices of the blood metabolic profile of cows . Czech J Anim Sci . 2007 ; 52 : 423 ± 429 .
8. Henry PR , Ammerman CB , Littell RC , Rao PV , Miles RD . Relative bioavailability of manganese from a manganese-methionine complex and inorganic sources for ruminants . J Dairy Sci. Natl. Acad. Sci ., Washington, DC; 1992 ; 75 : 3473 ±8. https://doi.org/10.3168/jds.S0022- 0302 ( 92 ) 78123 - 5 PMID: 1474213
9. Yan F , Waldroup PW . Evaluation of MINTREX® Manganese as a Source of Manganese for Young Broilers . Int J Poult Sci . 2006 ; 5 : 708 ± 713 . https://doi.org/10.3923/ijps. 2006 . 708 .713
10. Pitropovska E , PechovaÂ A , HauptmanovaÂ K , HusaÂkovaÂ T , Pavlata L . The effect of manganese supplementation on its concentrations in blood, hair, and organs of goat kids . Acta Vet Brno . 2014 ; 83 : 219 ± 224 . https://doi.org/10.2754/avb201483030219
11. Martinez A . Effect of some major and trace element interactions upon in vitro rumen cellulose digestion [Internet]. 1971 .
12. Martinez A , Church DC . Effect of Various Mineral Elements on Rumen Cellulose Digestion . J Anim Sci. The American Society of Animal Science; 1970 ; 31 : 982 . https://doi.org/10.2527/jas1970.315982x PMID: 5481274
13. Arelovich HM , Owens FN , Horn GW , Vizcarra JA. Effects of supplemental zinc and manganese on ruminal fermentation, forage intake, and digestion by cattle fed prairie hay and urea . J Anim Sci . 2000 ; 78 : 2972 ± 9 . PMID: 11063324
14. Chamberlain CC , Burroughs W. Effect of Fluoride, Magnesium and Manganese Ions on in Vitro Cellulose Digestion by Rumen Microorganisms . J Anim Sci . 1962 ; 21 : 428 . https://doi.org/10.2527/jas1962. 213428x
15. Damisa D , Ameh J , Umoh V. The effect of changes in manganese concentrations on cellulase yield from bagasse fermented with mutagenised strain of Aspergillus niger AH3 . Int J Biol Chem Sci . 2008 ; 2 : 368 ± 372 . https://doi.org/10.4314/ijbcs.v2i3. 39749
Weisburg WG , Barns SM , Pelletier DA , Lane DJ . 16S ribosomal DNA amplification for phylogenetic study . J Bacteriol . 1991 ; 173 : 697 ± 703 . PMID: 1987160
17. NuÈbel U , Engelen B , Felske A , Snaidr J , Wieshuber A , Amann RI , et al. Sequence heterogeneities of genes encoding 16S rRNAs in Paenibacillus polymyxa detected by temperature gradient gel electrophoresis . J Bacteriol . 1996 ; 178 : 5636 ± 43 . PMID: 8824607
18. Regensbogenova M , Pristas P , Javorsky P , Moon-Van Der Staay SY , Van Der Staay GWM , Hackstein JHP , et al. Assessment of ciliates in the sheep rumen by DGGE . Lett Appl Microbiol . 2004 ; 39 : 144 ± 147 . https://doi.org/10.1111/j. 1472 - 765X . 2004 . 01542 . x PMID : 15242452
20. Selinummi J , SeppaÈlaÈ J , Yli-Harja O , Puhakka JA . Software for quantification of labeled bacteria from digital microscope images by automated image analysis . Biotechniques . 2005 ; 39 : 859 ± 63 . PMID: 16382904
21. Choudhry P . High-Throughput Method for Automated Colony and Cell Counting by Digital Image Analysis Based on Edge Detection . PLoS One. Public Library of Science; 2016 ; 11 : e0148469. https://doi. org/10.1371/journal.pone. 0148469 PMID: 26848849
22. Siritantikorn S , Jintaworn S , Noisakran S , Suputtamongkol Y , Paris DH , Blacksell SD . Application of ImageJ program to the enumeration of Orientia tsutsugamushi organisms cultured in vitro . Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg . 2012 ; 106 : 632 ± 635 . https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trstmh. 2012 . 05 .004 PMID: 22789674
23. HoraÂkovaÂ K. MikroskopickeÂ metoÂdy (Microscopic methods) . In: Betina V , BaraÂtovaÂ H , FargasÏovaÂ A , Frank V , HoraÂkovaÂ K , SÏturdÂõk E, editors. MikrobiologickeÂ laboratoÂrne metoÂdy (Microbiological laboratory methods) . Bratislava: Alfa; 1988 . pp. 173 ± 206 .
24. Abramoff MD , Magalhães PJ , Ram SJ . Image processing with ImageJ . Biophotonics Int. Laurin Pub . Co; 2004 ; 11 : 36 ± 42 .
25. Laho T , VaÂradyovaÂ Z , MihalikovaÂ K , KisÏidayovaÂ S. Fermentation Capacity of Fecal Microbial Inocula of Przewalski Horse, Kulan, and Chapman Zebra and Polysaccharide Hydrolytic Activities of Fecal Microbial Constituents (Ciliates and Bacteria) of Kulan and Chapman Zebra . J Equine Vet Sci . 2013 ; 33 : 143 ± 149 . https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jevs. 2012 . 05 .064
26. Bradford MM . A rapid and sensitive method for the quantitation of microgram quantities of protein utilizing the principle of protein dye binding . Anal Biochem . 1976 ; 72 : 248 ± 254 . PMID: 942051
27. Bailey MJ , Biely P , Poutanen K. Interlaboratory Testing of Methods for Assay of Xylanase Activity . J Biotechnol . 1992 ; 23 : 257 ± 270 .
28. Miller GL , Blum R , Glennon WE , Burton AL . Measurement of carboxymethylcellulase activity . Anal Biochem . 1960 ; 2 : 127 ± 132 .
29. Magurran AE . Measuring biological diversity . Blackwell Pub; 2004 .
30. Kruskal WH , Wallis WA . Use of Ranks in One-Criterion Variance Analysis . J Am Stat Assoc . 1952 ; 47 : 583 ± 621 . https://doi.org/10.1080/01621459. 1952 .10483441
31. Dehority BA . Rumen microbiology . Thrumpton: Nottingham University Press; 2004 .
32. Agarwal N , Kamra DN , Chaudhary LC . Microbial ecosystem of domesticated ruminants . In: Puniya AK , Singh R , Kamra DN , editors. Rumen Microbiology: From Evolution to Revolution . Springer India; 2015 . pp. 17 ± 30 .
33. Loisel P , Harmand J , Zemb O , Latrille E , Lobry C , Delgenes J-P , et al. Denaturing gradient electrophoresis (DGE) and single-strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) molecular fingerprintings revisited by simulation and used as a tool to measure microbial diversity . Environ Microbiol . Blackwell Publishing Ltd; 2006 ; 8 : 720 ± 731 . https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1462- 2920 . 2005 . 00950 . x PMID : 16584483
34. Masters D , Paynter D , Briegel J , Baker S , Purser D. Influence of manganese intake on body, wool and testicular growth of young rams and on the concentration of manganese and the activity of manganese enzymes in tissues . Aust J Agric Res . 1988 ; 39 : 517 . https://doi.org/10.1071/AR9880517
35. Fonty G , Senaud J , Jouany JP , Gouet P . Establishment of ciliate protozoa in the rumen of conventional and conventionalized lambs: influence of diet and management conditions . Can J Microbiol . 1988 ; 34 : 235 ± 241 . PMID: 3138013
36. Hook SE , Steele MA , Northwood KS , Wright A-DG , McBride BW . Impact of High-Concentrate Feeding and Low Ruminal pH on Methanogens and Protozoa in the Rumen of Dairy Cows . Microb Ecol . 2011 ; 62 : 94 ± 105 . https://doi.org/10.1007/s00248-011 -9881-0 PMID: 21625972
37. Tomczuk K , Kurek L , Stec A , Studzinska M , Mochol J . Incidence and clinical aspects of colon ciliate Buxtonella sulcata infection in cattle . Bull Vet Inst Pulawy . 2005 ; 49 : 29 ± 33 .
38. Leng RA . Dynamics of protozoa in the rumen of sheep . Br J Nutr . 1982 ; 48 : 399 ± 415 . PMID: 6810918
39. Jouany JP . Defaunation of the rumen . In: Jouany JP, editor. Rumen microbial metabolism and ruminant digestion . Paris: INRA Editions; 1991 . pp. 239 ± 2362 .
40. Jouany JP . Effect of rumen protozoa on nitrogen utilization by ruminants . J Nutr . 1996 ; 126 : 1335S± 46S . PMID: 8642481
Wallace RJ , Broderick GA , Brammall ML . Microbial protein and peptide metabolism in rumen fluid from faunated and ciliate-free sheep . Br J Nutr . 1987 ; 58 : 87 ± 93 . PMID: 3304417
42. Eugene M , Archimede H , Sauvant D. Quantitative meta -analysis on the effects of defaunation of the rumen on growth, intake and digestion in ruminants . Livest Prod Sci . 2004 ; 85 : 81 ± 97 .
43. Bird S , Seccombe M. A comparative study of faunated lambs and lambs reared from birth free of ciliate protozoa . Proc Aust Soc Anim Prod . ASAP; 1998 . p. 391 .
44. Arakaki C , Mitsumori M , Itabashi H , Shirasaka S , Minato H . Influence of the presence of protozoa on the rumen microbial population of cattle . J Gen Appl Microbiol . 1994 ; 40 : 215 ± 226 .
45. Belzecki G , Michalowski T . Effect of selected rumen fauna on the digestion of starch and outflow of alpha-glucose polymers from the reticulo-rumen of sheep . J Anim Feed Sci . 2005 ; 14 : 215 ± 218 .
46. Martinez A . Effect of some major and trace element interactions upon in vitro rumen cellulose digestion [Internet] . Oregon State University. 1971 .
47. Michalowski T. The distribution of fibrolytic activity in the rumen of ciliate-free and faunated sheep . J Anim Feed Sci . 2005 ; 14 : 287 ± 290 .
48. Demeyer DI . Rumen microbes and digestion of plant cell walls . Agric Environ . 1981 ; 6 : 295 ± 337 .
49. Bao YM , Choct M , Iji PA , Bruerton K. Effect of organically complexed copper, iron, manganese, and zinc on broiler performance, mineral excretion, and accumulation in tissues . J Appl Poult Res . 2007 ; 16 : 448 ± 455 .
50. Formigoni A , Fustini M , Archetti L , Emanuele S , Sniffen C , Biagi G. Effects of an organic source of copper, manganese and zinc on dairy cattle productive performance, health status and fertility . Anim Feed Sci Technol . 2011 ; 164 : 191 ± 198 . https://doi.org/10.1016/j.anifeedsci. 2011 . 01 .010