MODEL OF LEARNING COGNITIVE MORAL DEVELOPMENT THROUGH PICTORIAL STORY IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
IJAEDU- International E-Journal of Advances in Education, Vol. IV, Issue 10, April 2018
MODEL OF LEARNING COGNITIVE MORAL DEVELOPMENT THROUGH
PICTORIAL STORY IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
Risa Wismaliya1*, Kama Abdul Hakam2, Mubiar Agustin3
1
S.Pd., Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia, INDONESIA,
Dr., M.Pd, Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia, INDONESIA,
3
Dr., M.Pd., Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia, INDONESIA,
*Corresponding author
2
Abstract
One of learning model in character education that raised constructive value is cognitive moral development
(cmd). This model (cmd) has a special characteristic syntax, which is moral dilemma. The moral dilemma is
made by the teacher in a dilemma story that is presented to the student as a stimulus to make students feel
in a dilemmatic situation. Students must choose one option from two options presented. The choice is not
about right and wrong but focus on point of the student’s reason what they chose. The students’ choice in
the moral dilemma shows the stages of students’ moral development that developed by kohlberg from the
pre-conventional, conventional and post-conventional stages, which have 6 stages. The study was
th
conducted on 5 graders of elementary school, so that only 4 stages applied of 6 stages of moral
development. Characteristics of elementary school student between 10-12 years classified as concrete
operational stage (Jean Piaget, 1983), it’s result the moral dilemmas that are displayed not only in the form
of a flowing dilemmatic story but need a connection thoughts through the picture.The pictorial story contain
with moral dilemmas will be displayed with some pictures that repserent the meaning purpose of the story to
facilitate the students in digesting the meaning of the story moral dilemmas content. There are 3 situations
that are presented in one moral dilemma story. First picture is introduction story which describe the situation
(at school / home / play environment). Second picture is contains of dilemma conflict situation which directing
to the third picture, it’s "confusion" as a symbol of dilemma between choosing two choices.The finding of this
study is after the students read the pictorial story with moral dilemma then the students fill out the evaluation
sheet in the form of Defining Issues Test (essay closed) from James Rest to know their level of moral
development (stage 1-4). This method of research used experiments with classes that are given treatment
through pictorial story media and control classes that are not given treatment. The results of this study
indicated a higher change in the students' moral reasoning rather than control class.
Keywords: Cognitive moral development, moral dilemmas, pictorial story, stage of moral development.
1. INTRODUCTION
Based on some researchs in Moral Education, it shows that the importance of guidance and moral
development of students from an early age in the form of construction model value, as developed by
Cognitive Moral Development model initiated by Lawrence Kohlberg (1958 and 1975; Hakam, 2008a,
http://ijaedu.ocerintjournals.org
77
IJAEDU- International E-Journal of Advances in Education, Vol. IV, Issue 10, April 2018
Hakam, 2017b; Setianingsih, 2017), because the tradition of fostering the character of students who have
been done in the Indonesian schooling through the approach of value transmission, that is the inheritance of
value through model training, modeling, conditioning and habituation only foster certain character of the
character that is getting the child to accept and implement the values noble is taught, so that learners are
directed to be a person who is obedient, disciplined, and submissive. However, such learners are particularly
vulnerable when confronted with value conflicts, individuals who receive such character education are often
unable to resist temptation and ultimately take erroneous action because their moral considerations are
rarely honed. Therefore, Character Education rooted in Durkheim's sociological thoughts should be
juxtaposed together with Moral Education which is rooted in Piaget's psychological thoughts which
emphasizes moral cognitive development. (Snarey in Nuccy, 2008).
The results of Setiyaningsih dissertation (2017) study recommends the need for creative teachers in
developing the Cognitive Moral Development model in Elementary Schools in preparing moral dilemmas that
are more suited to the cognitive development stages of the students because the use of a moral dilemma
with a purely moral dilemma story is less able to significantly increase moral judgment. In line with the results
of this study, Samuelson's (2007) study showed that discussion-based curriculum utilizing film cliches
containing the moral dilemma of popular Hollywood films resulted in a significantly increased moral judgment
compared with non-participating students. In line with the findings of this study Hakam (2017) recommends
the need to research how the development of moral dilemmas as a medium of moral learning in elementary
school students who think is still in concrete phase so that the original moral dilemma hypochesis hypothesis
becomes more factual in the form of picture story dilemma.
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
Reality in Indonesia in value education uses only value transmission culture (inheritance value), and less
value development, it can be seen from micro strategy and macro strategy of character education in
Indonesia. (Hakam, 2017) In macro terms, character education by Kemendiknas implements three
strategies: First through top-down intervention in the form of socialization, regulation, capacity building,
implementation and cooperation, monitoring and evaluation; both explore practical experience in the field
(bottom-up); the third is revitalization program. Character education process must go through the process of
intervention and habituation (Dasim Budimansyah: 2010). Intervention is a process of character education
that is done formally, packaged in learning and learning interaction (Learning and intruction) is deliberately
designed to achieve the goal of character building by applying a variety of structured learning (Structured
learning exsperiences) to include two impacts as well as the impact of instructional (instructional effect) and
nurturant effect. Character education in school and at home can be achieved with five strategies (Kusnadi,
2013, p.54). These five strategies include; the cultivation of moral knowledge, creation of the environment
(habituation), conditioning, reinforcement and modeling. Thus, the macro and micro strategy of Character
Education in Indonesia uses a tradition of value transmission, which emphasizes inheritance, training,
habituation and modeling. This value transmission model is very important in cultivation the value but it is not
sufficient enough to prepare the next generation of moral successors. Therefore, it’s required a education
model that can sharpen and improve moral consideration of student (...truncated)