The W7-X Stellarator Project
The W7-X Stellarator Project
F. Wagner
Max-Planck-Institut für Plasmaphysik, Garching
EURATOMAssociation
Design work in preparation for Europe’s next major step in stellarators as an alter
native for magnetically confined plasma fusion has demonstrated that advanced
devices can be optimized.
Europe is following two strategic paths on its
way to demonstrating a commercially viable
fusion reactor for electric power generation.
One path envisages energy production at
the GW level in the shortest possible timescale using a self-sustaining, energy pro
ducing plasma (a so-called burning plasma).
To achieve this important goal, the four
major fusion programmes (Europe, USA,
Japan and Russia) have merged their
knowledge and will jointly build and operate
the International Thermonuclear Experimen
tal Reactor (ITER). The device will demon
strate the feasibility of large-scale fusion
energy production and will address ques
tions related to the physics and fusion tech
nology of the burning plasma state, notably
ignition and control, plasma stability in the
presence of a large population of highenergy particles, α-particle losses, power
exhaust, and tritium breeding. ITER will be a
tokamak since this configuration is at the
most advanced stage of development and
provides the most credible basis for extra
polating to the size and requirements of a
burning plasma.
Although the ITER line has the best
prospects for demonstrating and exploring
a burning plasma it nevertheless admits to
drawbacks with respect to an economically
viable fusion reactor. Being founded on
existing data, ITER represents the highcurrent tokamak line which is unlikely to
lead to a reactor operating in the steadystate. Moreover, its plasma is easily dis
rupted (i.e., prone to sudden current
quenches) and performance peaks in the
high-current corner of operational space.
So ITER will be forced to walk along a
brink: any loss of equilibrium will incur a cur
rent quench within a few milliseconds ac
companied by mechanical and electrical
Friedrich Wagner is responsible for the experimental
aspects of work on the W7-AS stellarator at the MaxPlanck-lnstitut fur Plasmaphysik (IPP), BoltzmannStrasse 2, D-85748 Garching. He is a member of the
IPP Directorate and has been an Honorary Professor
at the TU Munich since 1993. Professor Wagner
graduated in 1970 from TU Munich where he was
awarded a Ph.D. in low-temperature physics in 1972.
He joined the IPP in 1975 after spending two years at
Ohio State University, USA, becoming the project
head of ASDEX in 1986 and a Fellow of the MaxPlanck Gesellschaft in 1988.
hazards. The device will be designed to
withstand disruptions, but their frequency
has to be limited.
Concept Improvement
Tokamaks
The deficiencies of the ITER line — diffi
culty of steady-state operation, the stresses
accompanying disruption of the plasma,
and the large size of a high-current device
— are being tackled in Europe’s second
path, which is called concept improvement.
Existing concepts satisfy the physics requi
rements and provide some of the techno
logy for the most urgent next step, namely
realization of a burning plasma. But im
provements are needed and in the case of
tokamaks, they should lead to the so-called
Advanced Tokamak offering superior con
finement and stability in smaller, low-current
devices. Rigourous optimization of the mag
netic and kinetic ingredients in turbulent
transport and of magneto-hydrodynamic
stability is essential. Unfortunately, many
critical aspects can only be assessed using
empirical data.
A self-sustaining bootstrap current is of
utmost importance in tokamaks. Such
devices are based on a strong toroidal
current flowing within the plasma which
provides a pololdal field component super
imposed on the toroidal one to establish a
rotational transform, where magnetic field
lines twist and wind helically to embrace
the torus. The current is called a bootstrap
current because it flows without external
excitation, being generated by pressure dif
ferences within the plasma and not, as is
usually the case, by induction as in a trans
former. The strategy for optimizing advan
ced tokamaks is centred on a large boot
strap current. If the fraction of the total
current provided by the bootstrap current
is large it might be possible to design a
steady-state, low-current tokamak that re
quires a moderate external current drive
(such a current is created by Injecting either
particles or high-frequency waves).
Fig. 1 — The outermost flux surface of the W7-X stellarator with a band of field lines and
some of the modular coils. The W7-X’s five toroidal field periods will maintain a plasma with
obvious poloidal field components and a strong indentation such that the plasma is bean
shaped at the corners of the pentagon. The rotational transform of W7-X is chosen to be
about 1 as this value allows the safe realization of maximal magnetic shear. The major
radius of the device will be 5.5 m at an aspect ratio of 10. As stellarators are made for
steady-state operation, W7-X will have superconducting coils. The maximum field is 3 T and
is matched to the present electron cyclotron heating frequency of 140 GHz.
Europhys. News 26 (1995)
3
Stellarators
Stellarators represent Europe’s second
approach for confining toroidal plasmas.
They aim to do this using magnetic fields
generated by currents lying outside the
plasma region. They share with the tokamak
the basic concept of nested magnetic sur
faces for achieving confinement, but a net
toroidal plasma current is not required. Such
devices are especially attractive since they
provide intrinsic steady-state operation and
are inherently disruption-free. However,
the classical stellarator based on Lyman
Spitzer’s original design published in 1958
also requires concept improvement to qua
lify as a commercially viable reactor.
The basic element of the stellarator coil
system is a helical coil which embraces the
toroidal plasma. The suitability of helical
systems for reactors has been questioned
from the technical point of view since they
are difficult to fabricate and are operated
close to the technical limits: a modular
design based on a set of single coils is
therefore essential. The modular coils inevi
tably have to be non-planar because they
also provide the poloidal field component.
Such an approach would facilitate optimiza
tion, thereby removing one of the major
drawbacks of the classical stellarator.
Stellarators (cover illustration) form part
of the concept improvement programme
and several major issues are being tackled.
The plasma cross-section in a classical
stellarator has a larger aspect ratio than for
tokamaks, and the twist angle of rotational
transform in the plasma core Is generally
smaller. As a result, the equilibrium of the
nested flux surfaces suffers from a large
outward shift of the core region (the Shafranov shift) and operation is limited to low
values of the ratio β of the plasma to mag
netic field energy. Indeed, stellarators (...truncated)