Expression of Concern: Akt Regulates Drug-Induced Cell Death through Bcl-w Downregulation
Expression of Concern: Akt Regulates Drug- Induced Cell Death through Bcl-w Downregulation
The PLOS ONE Editors
OPEN ACCESS ? Fig 1B: Lane 1 of the Akt blot is similar to lane 2 of the ?-actin blot, though with different aspect ratio. ? Fig 2A: The background in lane 2 of the Akt blot is notably different than the background in other lanes. The authors have provided the original blot image in support of this panel in S1 File; the area above and below the band in lane 2 is different in the raw blot image versus the published image.
Copyright: ? 2019 The PLOS ONE Editors. This is
an open access article distributed under the terms
of the Creative Commons Attribution License,
which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and
reproduction in any medium, provided the original
author and source are credited.
Total extract blots in Fig 4C of [
] were duplicated in error in Fig 2C of [
]. The authors
clarified that the correct panels were shown in the PLOS ONE figure; the Cell Death and
Differentiation article was retracted in 2017 due to concerns about this figure [
The authors clarified that there were some errors in the reporting of the Fig 4C experiments
]. First, the Results section text incorrectly reports that the experiment was conducted in
HEK293 cells. As noted in the figure legend, these experiments were done in HeLa cells.
Second, the original published version of Fig 4C included a panel label indicating that upper blot
was generated using samples from an anti-Flag immunoprecipitation. As noted in the Results
text, figure legend, and updated figure provided with this notice, the immunoprecipitation was
performed using an anti-HA antibody. Third, the transfections that were performed were not
clearly and correctly relayed in the Fig 4C legend; this has been addressed in the updated
legend provided with this notice.
The authors have provided raw data underlying graphs reported in Figs 5A and 6B (S7?S10
Files). Please note that the final graphs for Fig 5A were derived from the combination of
independent experiments; the authors have provided the original raw counts for one of these
Fig 2. Akt activity regulates Bcl-w expression. (A) HeLa cells were transfected with 2 ?g of HA-Akt wt, Akt D+, or HA-Akt D? cDNA and 2 ?g Flag-Bcl-w for 48 hrs.
Protein extracts were immunoprecipitated with an anti-HA monoclonal antibody. Immunoprecipitates were resolved on 12% SDS-PAGE and transferred to Hybond-C
nitrocellulose. Membranes were incubated with anti-Flag antibody (0.2 ?g/ml). 50 ?g of total sample extracts were also analyzed by western blot using the indicated
antibodies. Loading control was obtained using anti-? actin antibody. (B) HeLa cells were transfected with 4 ?g of HA-Akt wt, HA-Akt D+, or HA-Akt D? cDNA for 48
hrs. Protein extracts were blotted with anti-Bcl-w antibody in order to detect endogenous levels of Bcl-w. Loading control was obtained with anti-? actin antibody. (C)
Cells were transfected with 100 nM of siAkt-RNA for 48 hrs. Cellular proteins were solubilized and analyzed by western blot using the indicated antibodies. (D) HeLa
cells were treated with 10, 20 or 40 ?M of LY294002 for 24 hrs. Protein extracts were analyzed by western blot using the indicated antibodies. Loading control was
obtained using anti-?-actin antibody. (E) Bcl-w HeLa cells were treated with 10 ?M of MG-132 for 8 hrs. 40 ?g of protein extracts were analyzed by western blot with
anti-Bcl-w antibodies. Loading control was obtained using anti-? actin antibody.
Fig 4. Akt phosphorylates Bcl-w in vitro and in vivo. (A) HeLa cells were transfected with 2 ?g of DNA of Flag Bcl-w, solubilized, and 1 mg of protein extract was
immunoprecipitated with an anti-M2 Flag antibody. Immunoprecipitates were incubated with recombinant constitutive active Akt (rAkt), and in vitro kinase assay was
conducted as described in the methods. Samples were loaded onto 2.5% SDS-PAGE and analyzed by autoradiography. As positive control we used Histone2B (H2B). (B)
HeLa Bcl-w stable expressing clones were serum starved for 18 hrs and then stimulated with 100 nM insulin or with 20% serum for 15 min as indicated. Cells were
solubilized and immunoprecipitated with an anti-M2 Flag antibody. Immunoprecipitates were loaded onto SDS-PAGE and blotted with an anti-phospho Akt substrate
antibody that recognizes all the phosphorylated Akt substrates. Total extracts were analyzed by western blot using the indicated antibodies. (C) HeLa cells were transfected
with 2 ?g of HA-GSK3? and either 2 ?g of pcDNA3 empty vector (lane 2) or 2 ?g of Flag-Bcl-w (lane 3) for 48 hrs. Cells used for the samples in lane 1 were untransfected
controls (C-). Cells were stimulated with 100 nM insulin for 15 min, solubilized, immunoprecipitated using an anti-HA antibody, and analyzed by western blot using an
anti-phospho-Gsk3? antibody (top panel). Total extracts were analyzed by western blot using anti-Flag, anti-HA, and anti-?-actin antibodies (panels 2?4, respectively).
Bcl-w overexpression does not affect Akt activity. Vertical lines in Fig 4A and 4C indicate where fragments of the original blot images were spliced to remove or rearrange
lanes. The raw uncropped blots are provided in S4 File. Note that the Flag-Bcl-w and HA-GSK3? data in the second and third panels of Fig 4C were obtained using
independent blots for which the corresponding ?-Actin control blots are provided in S4 File. The ?-Actin panel shown in the figure is for the anti-HA blot, but the authors
clarified that the same protein extracts were used for both blots.
3 / 4
experiments. S10 File also includes an updated version of the graph shown in Fig 6B, based on
re-calculations from the raw data.
The authors clarified that the raw data supporting Figs 1A, 1B, 1C, 2B, 2C, 3A, 3B, 3C, 5B,
6A, 6C are no longer available due to the amount of time that has elapsed since the results
Given the extent of the concerns about the published figures in this article, the PLOS ONE
Editors issue this Expression of Concern.
The authors disagree with this Expression of Concern.
Corrected versions of Figs 2 and 4 are provided here.
S1 File. Raw blots provided in support of Akt panel in Fig 2A.
S2 File. Raw blot supporting ?-Actin results in Fig 2A.
S3 File. Correct original raw blot for ?-Actin results in Fig 2D.
S4 File. Raw blots provided in support of Fig 4A?4C.
S5 File. Raw blot provided in support of HA total extract blot in Fig 7A.
S6 File. Raw blot provided in support of EE total extract blot in Fig 7A.
S7 File. Excel sheet of raw viability data for Fig 5A.
S8 File. Raw data provided in support of Fig 5A and S7 File. S9 File. Raw data provided in support of Fig 6B and S10 File.
S10 File. Excel sheet with raw data and recalculated data provided in support of graph in
1. Garofalo M , Quintavalle C , Zanca C , De Rienzo A , Romano G , Acunzo M , et al. ( 2008 ) Akt Regulates Drug-Induced Cell Death through Bcl-w Downregulation . PLoS ONE 3 ( 12 ): e4070. https://doi.org/10. 1371/journal.pone. 0004070 PMID: 19114998
2. Quintavalle C , Incoronato M , Puca L , Acunzo M , Zanca C , Romano G et al. ( 2010 ) c-FLIPL enhances anti-apoptotic Akt functions by modulation of Gsk3? activity . Cell Death and Differentiation 17 , 1908 - 1916 . https://www.nature.com/articles/cdd201065 PMID: 20508645
3. ( 2017 ) Retraction to : Cell Death and Differentiation 2010 ; 17 : 1908 - 1916 . https://doi.org/10.1038/cdd. 2010.65 Cell Death and Differentiation 24 , 1134 . https://www.nature.com/articles/cdd20177