Body image dissatisfaction and associated factors in adolescents
DOI: 10.1590/1413-81232020257.27452018
Giulia Xavier de Carvalho (https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7002-4479) 1
Ana Paula Nogueira Nunes (https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1825-6990) 2
Claudia Leite Moraes (https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3223-1634) 3
Gloria Valeria da Veiga (https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7985-0213) 1
1
Instituto de Nutrição Josué
de Castro, Universidade
Federal do Rio de Janeiro.
Av. Carlos Chagas Filho
373, Cidade Universitária.
21941-902 Rio de Janeiro
RJ Brasil.
2
Universidade Federal dos
Vales do Jequitinhonha e
Mucuri. Diamantina MG
Brasil.
3
Instituto de Medicina
Social, Universidade do
Estado do Rio de Janeiro.
Rio de Janeiro RJ Brasil.
Abstract This study aimed to examine the factors associated with body dissatisfaction in adolescents. This is a cross-sectional study with students from two public and four private schools in
the metropolitan region of Rio de Janeiro. Body
dissatisfaction was evaluated using the Body Silhouette Scale, by the difference between the image they perceive as their current image and the one
they would like to have. The association was assessed by hierarchical logistic regression multinomial
model, by estimating odds ratios (OR) and 95%
confidence intervals (95%CI). Among the 1,019
adolescents evaluated (13-19 years), 75% showed
body dissatisfaction, 41.4% wishing for a smaller
silhouette and 33.7% wishing for larger silhouettes. The wish for a smaller silhouette was more
significant in girls, overweight adolescents, those
with an unsatisfactory meal pattern, and with
higher waist circumference. Adolescents that had
been exposed to teasing due to their body shape
increased the probability of wishing for both smaller and larger silhouettes. Strategies are required
for a more positive perception of body image, especially for girls and for overweight adolescents,
which provide guidance on adequate meal consumption and prevent exposure to peer teasing,
valuing coexistence and well-being in the face of
existing bodily differences.
Key words Body image, Adolescents, Overweight
free themes
Body image dissatisfaction and associated factors in adolescents
2769
Carvalho GX et al.
2770
Introduction
Body image is part of the mechanism of personal identity that has a multidimensional construction1. In contemporary Western society, it is
common to observe many people trying to fit the
ideal beauty standards, generating dissatisfaction with body image when not successful2. Such
dissatisfaction is more evident in adolescents
because they are more vulnerable to pressures
imposed by society, family, friends and the media
to reach the perfect body as a way of obtaining
acceptance and social success3.
In the search for the aesthetic ideals imposed,
many adolescents resort to very restrictive diets,
exaggerated physical exercise, the use of diuretics
and laxatives, anabolics, as well as the search for
unnecessary aesthetic plastic surgeries4. Such behaviors may be in the genesis of eating disorders
such as anorexia nervosa, bulimia and binge eating, which can severely compromise the health of
young people.
Dissatisfaction with body image has been
related to some demographic factors such as being adolescent and female5, psychosocial, such as
being involved with exposure to bullying6, related to lifestyle habits, such as physical inactivity,
and irregular dietary practices7-9, and nutritional
status, such as being overweight5,10. However, the
interrelation between these factors requires that
they are analyzed in a multidimensional context
and from a hierarchical perspective that allows
the identification of those who associate with the
outcome independently.
Therefore, this study intends to evaluate the
level of body dissatisfaction in adolescents and
identify higher risk subgroups, based on the analysis of possible associated factors. Such research
may be useful to subsidize the discussion about
the problem and implement strategies that promote a more positive body image among adolescents, thus avoiding adverse health effects caused
by such dissatisfaction.
Methods
Evaluated population
Data from adolescents enrolled in the 1st
year of high school were analyzed in two public
schools and four private schools in the metropolitan region of Rio de Janeiro in 2010, which were
part of the baseline of the Longitudinal Study on
Adolescent Nutritional Assessment (ELANA).
The exclusion criteria of the main study were
being physically disabled, thus preventing anthropometric evaluation, pregnant adolescents
and those who were undergoing some drug
treatment for weight control. In total, 1,131 eligible participants were identified for the study.
Of these, 92 did not participate because they did
not submit authorization from their parents or
guardians (17), because they refused to participate (66) or because they were absent on the day
of data collection (9). Specifically, for this study,
20 adolescents who did not present data related to self-perceived body image were excluded,
totaling 1,019 adolescents to be analyzed, corresponding to a response rate of 90%.
Data collection and study variables
Data was collected between February and August 2010 by a properly trained team, with the
authorization of parents or guardians and following the students’ assent.
Information was collected from self-completed questionnaires to investigate outcome variable
(body dissatisfaction) and exposure variables:
demographic (gender, age, skin color/ethnicity),
socioeconomic status (economic class, household head schooling and school type), psychosocial (exposure to teasing), lifestyle (meal pattern,
tobacco use, current experimentation and consumption of alcohol, physical activity and sedentary behavior), anthropometric and body composition variables (body mass index and body fat
percentage).
The Body Silhouettes Scale adapted for adolescents11 was applied to evaluate perceived body
image. It consists of nine silhouettes for girls and
nine for boys, ranging from the figure corresponding to the extreme thinness (nº1) to obesity (nº 9)12. The scale was accompanied by the following questions: 1. Check the figure you think
you look the most; 2. Mark the picture you would
most like to appear with. The variable “body
dissatisfaction” was defined by the difference
between the score corresponding to the silhouette that the adolescents thought was their current one (question 1) and what they would like
to look like (question 2), which can range from
-8 to +8. The negative score indicated a desire
to have larger silhouettes and the positive score
showed the desire to have smaller silhouettes.
Skin color/ethnicity information was obtained by self-evaluation. The adolescents were
questioned about how they classified themselves
and could choose the same options investigated
2771
consumption of the three meals) to 1 (up to 3
to 6 times a week in, at most, one of the three
meals), as per the criterion proposed by Estima
et al.16.
Experimentation in alcohol consumption
and current consumpt (...truncated)