Optimal Control of Multiple Transmission of Water-Borne Diseases
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
International Journal of Mathematics and Mathematical Sciences
Volume 2012, Article ID 421419, 16 pages
doi:10.1155/2012/421419
Research Article
Optimal Control of Multiple Transmission of
Water-Borne Diseases
G. Devipriya and K. Kalaivani
P. G. Department of Mathematics, Women’s Christian College, Chennai 600006, India
Correspondence should be addressed to G. Devipriya,
Received 29 March 2012; Accepted 25 May 2012
Academic Editor: B. N. Mandal
Copyright q 2012 G. Devipriya and K. Kalaivani. This is an open access article distributed under
the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and
reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
A controlled SIWR model was considered which was an extension of the simple SIR model by
adjoining a compartment W that tracks the pathogen concentration in the water. New infections
arise both through exposure to contaminated water as well as by the classical SIR person-person
transmission pathway. The controls represent an immune boosting and pathogen suppressing
drugs. The objective function is based on a combination of minimizing the number of infected
individuals and the cost of the drugs dose. The optimal control is obtained by solving the
optimality system which was composed of four nonlinear ODEs with initial conditions and four
nonlinear adjoint ODEs with transversality conditions. The results were analysed and interpreted
numerically using MATLAB.
1. Introduction
Most of the major problems that humanity face in the twenty-first century are related to
water quantity and/or quality issues. These problems are going to be more aggravated
in future by climate change, resulting in higher water temperatures, melting of glaciers,
and an intensification of the water cycle 1, with potentially more floods and droughts
2. With respect to human health, the most direct and most severe impact is the lack of
improved sanitation, and related to it is the lack of safe drinking water, which currently
affects more than one-third of the global population. Additional threats include, for example,
exposure to pathogens or to chemical toxicants via the food chain, for instance, the result
of irrigating plants with contaminated water and of bioaccumulation of toxic chemicals by
aquatic organisms, including seafood and fish or during recreation like swimming in polluted
surface water.
2
International Journal of Mathematics and Mathematical Sciences
Water-borne diseases are infectious diseases caused by pathogenic microorganisms
that most commonly are transmitted in contaminated fresh water, whether in bathing, washing, drinking, or in the preparation of food. Though these diseases spread either directly
or indirectly through flies or filth, water is the chief medium for spread of these diseases,
and hence, they are termed as waterborne diseases. More than one-third of Earth’s accessible
renewable freshwater is consumptively used for agricultural, industrial, and domestic purposes 3. As most of these activities lead to water contamination with diverse synthetic and
geogenic natural chemicals, it comes as no surprise that chemical pollution of natural water
has become a major public concern in almost all parts of the world.
The main acute disease risk associated with drinking water in developing and
transition countries is due to pathogens, which include viruses, bacteria, and protozoa,
which spread via the oral-fecal route 4. These diseases are more prevalent in areas with
poor sanitary conditions. Campylobacter jejuni, Microsporidia, Yersinia enterocolitica, Cyclospora, Caliciviruses, and environmental bacteria like Mycobacterium sp., Aeromonas sp., Legionella pneumophila, and multidrug-resistant Pseudomonas aeruginosa have been associated with
waterborne illnesses. These pathogens travel through water sources and interfuse directly
through persons handling food and water. The main distribution of many water-borne
pathogens varies substantially from one country to another. Some pathogens such as Vibrio cholerae, Hepatitis E virus, and Schistosomiasis are restricted to certain tropical countries;
others, such as Cryptosporidiosis and Campylobacteriosis, are probably widespread.
Rotavirus infections predominate in the winter months and account for approximately
140 million cases/year with 600,000–800,000 deaths/year 5. Recent evidence on Entamoebahistolytica in children Dhaka, Bangladesh, the causative agent of Amoebiasis Amoebic
dysentery, shows that infection occurred in 80 percentage of children over a four-year period
with a reinfection rate of 53 percentage 6. According to WHO records of infectious disease
outbreaks in 132 countries from 1998 to 2001, outbreaks of waterborne diseases are at the top
of the list, with cholera as the most frequent disease, followed by acute diarrhea and typhoid
fever 7.
Recent literature related to this work has been discussed below. The literature on
economic epidemiology is varied and growing, and there are several good surveys, such
as Gersovitz and Hammer 8 and Klein et al. 9. The earliest contribution, by Sanders 10,
considered the treatment in different versions of the SIS model from a planner’s perspective.
Goldman and Lightwood 11 studied treatment in the controlled SIS model but considered
different cost structures, that is, on the assumption that the medical authorities operate
without an explicit budget constraint. Rowthorn 12 extended the analysis of the controlled
SIS model, by considering how different kinds of budget constraints affect the optimal
solution.
Arnone and Walling 13 presented the information on pathogen sources, health effects
of waterborne pathogens, relevant water quality legislation, and an evaluation of pathogen
indicators. Joh et al. 14 predicted that in the case of waterborne diseases, suppressing the
pathogen density in aquatic reservoirs may be more effective than minimizing the number of infected individuals. Shannon et al. 15 have developed improved disinfection,
decontamination, reuse, and desalination methods to work in concert to improve health,
safeguard the environment, and reduce water scarcity, not just in the industrialized world,
but in the developing world, where less chemical and energy intensive technologies
are greatly needed. Batterman et al. 16 studied the historical practices and different
disciplinary approaches to water-related infectious disease and proposed an interdisciplinary
public-health-oriented systems approach to research and intervention design. Finally, they
International Journal of Mathematics and Mathematical Sciences
3
illustrated using a case study that focuses on diseases associated with water and sanitation
management practices in developing countries where the disease burden is the most severe.
Schwarzenbach et al. 17 discussed the main groups of aquatic contaminants and their effects
on human health and app (...truncated)