Novel Applicators for Local Microwave Hyperthermia Based on Zeroth-Order Mode Resonator Metamaterial
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
International Journal of Antennas and Propagation
Volume 2014, Article ID 631398, 7 pages
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2014/631398
Research Article
Novel Applicators for Local Microwave Hyperthermia Based on
Zeroth-Order Mode Resonator Metamaterial
David Vrba and Jan Vrba
Department of Biomedical Technology, Faculty of Biomedical Engineering, Czech Technical University in Prague,
Zikova 4, 166 36 Prague, Czech Republic
Correspondence should be addressed to David Vrba;
Received 17 January 2014; Accepted 11 March 2014; Published 9 April 2014
Academic Editor: Haider Raad Khaleel
Copyright Β© 2014 D. Vrba and J. Vrba. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License,
which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
It is demonstrated that a theory of zero-order mode resonator (ZOR) metamaterial (MTM) structure can be used for the
development of a novel class of applicators for microwave thermotherapy, for example, for hyperthermia in cancer treatment or
for physiotherapy. The main idea of creating such an applicator is to generate and radiate a plane electromagnetic (EM) wave into
the treated biological tissue, at least in a certain extent. The main aim of this paper is to investigate whether an EM wave generated
by ZOR MTM structure and emitted into the biological tissue can produce a homogeneous SAR distribution in the planes parallel
to the applicator aperture and achieve a penetration depth approaching the theoretical limit represented by SAR distribution and
penetration depth of an ideal EM plane wave. EM field distribution inside a virtual phantom of the treated region generated by the
applicator that is based on the proposed ZOR MTM principle is investigated using a well-proven full-wave commercial simulation
tool. The proposed applicator type shows both a low unwanted leaked electromagnetic field and a fairly homogeneous electric field
in its aperture as well as in the virtual phantom of the treated region.
1. Introduction
The main aim of this paper is to verify whether it is feasible
to apply principles of ZOR MTM radiating structures in
the design of efficient applicators for radiofrequency (RF)/
microwave (MW) thermotherapy, especially for hyperthermia cancer treatment and for physiotherapy. For this aim,
MTM antennas inspired by those described in [1, 2] will be
investigated and adapted with respect to requirements of
effective hyperthermia treatment (i.e., we will study the homogeneity of SAR distribution in the treated region). In order to
achieve an optimal waveform shape of the radiated EM wave,
applicators have to be designed in a certain way. The best possible results can be obtained by comparing various shapes of
waveforms of EM waves (e.g., plane wave, cylindrical wave,
and spherical wave) for local and deep local treatment waveform of plane wave. This can ensure
(i) the best possible value of the effective treatment
depth;
(ii) the best possible homogeneity of SAR 3D distribution
(i.e., its distribution on the surface and in the whole
volume of the area to be treated).
SAR distribution inside the virtual phantom of the treated
region, created using the proposed applicator, and the reflection coefficient of the proposed applicator are investigated
using the well-proven full-wave commercial simulation tool
COMSOL Multiphysics. Based on our previous experience
[1β3], an excellent agreement between simulation and measurement results can be expected. That is why the conclusions
made in this paper are based on the results of numerical
simulations only.
2. MTM Zeroth-Order Mode Resonator
The concept of MTM phenomenon was first comprehensively
introduced by Veselago in 1968 [4]. In the aforementioned
publication, he speculated on the existence of materials whose
permittivity (π) and permeability (π) were simultaneously
negative. He named these materials left-handed (LH), as the
E, H, and k vectors of the studied EM wave formed a lefthanded triad if the wave propagated through such environment. The first experimental verification of MTM phenomena was performed by a research group at the University of
California, San Diego (UCSD), in 2001 [5].
2
International Journal of Antennas and Propagation
CL
LR
Z
CR
LL
Y
(a)
(b)
Figure 1: (a) Infinitesimal element of MTM (b) and its equivalent circuit consisting of inherent series inductor πΏ π
, shunt capacitor πΆπ
,
artificially inserted series capacitor πΆπΏ , and shunt inductor πΏ πΏ .
3. Design of the Applicator Based on
ZOR MTM Structure
In this section, we will study the possibility of creating MTM
based applicators for local microwave hyperthermia cancer
treatment at a frequency of 434 MHz. The basic part of the
proposed applicator will consist of the ZOR.
The working idea of ZOR is based on a special case of
resonance that can occur when the TL meets the conditions of
the MTM phenomenon. The phase constant π½ = 0 is at
working frequency in this case, which implies infinite guided
wavelength π π = 2π/|π½| along the MTM structure as well as
zero phase shift (ππ = βπ½π = 0) [11]. It is very important
to note that this phenomenon enables creation of a very
special kind of resonator whose physical length is completely
independent of the classical resonance condition (i.e.,
required to be a natural number multiple of the half working
wavelength in case of either open-circuited or short-circuited
TL) [11]. The typical voltage wave distribution along the
resonant length for the negative (π < 0) and zero (π = 0)
resonances is shown in Figure 2. In the case of zeroth-order
mode resonance (π = 0), the value of the voltage along the
m=0
m = β1
m = β2
Voltage
An infinitesimally short lossless transmission line (TL)
section can be described by a simple equivalent circuit consisting of a series inductor πΏ π
and a shunt capacitor πΆπ
[6].
The lossless MTM cell implemented in planar technology
consists of a TL section with artificially inserted series
capacitors πΆπΏ and shunt inductors πΏ πΏ (with subscript πΏ
denoting its left-handed properties). The equivalent circuit of
the MTM cell can be then represented by four-lumped elements (as shown in Figure 1) [6].
Several different EM radiating structures based on the
MTM principle were introduced in the past [7β10]. Since
the very beginning of the development, however, real implementation possibilities of such antennas, for example, in
communication technology, have been very limited because
of their poor radiation efficiency. MTM antennas with very
good radiation efficiency were first presented in [1, 2].
m = β3
z
π
0
Length
Figure 2: Voltage distribution in case of open-circuited TL of length
β. Mode π = 0 represents the ZOR with infinite guided wavelength.
ZOR is constant. A more comprehensive description of ZOR
properties can be found in [11].
The zeroth-order resonant frequency of the proposed
ZOR MTM applicator is equal to (...truncated)