Comparison of Analgesia in Subcutaneous Infiltration of Ropivacaine and Magnesium Sulfate for Postoperative Pain Control of Cholecystectomy
Novelty in Biomedicine
Original Article
Comparison of Analgesia in Subcutaneous Infiltration of
Ropivacaine and Magnesium Sulfate for Postoperative Pain Control
of Cholecystectomy
Shayesteh Khorasanizadeh1, Maryam Panahi1, Gholamreza Mohseni1, Faranak Behnaz1, Masih Ebrahymy
Dehkordy1, Houman Teymourian1*
1
Department of Anesthesia, Shohada Tajrish hospital, Shahid Behesti university of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
Received: 28 May, 2019; Accepted: 24 September, 2019
Abstract
Background: The purpose of this study was to compare the effect of analgesia of Ropivacaine and magnesium
sulfate as subcutaneous infiltration at the site of surgical cutaneous cholecystectomy in the postoperative period.
Materials and Methods: To achieve the research goals, 80 patients referred to Shohada Tajrish Hospital in
Tehran in 2016, which were randomly divided into two groups: Ropivacaine and magnesium sulfate. Patients in
both groups had similar anesthetic procedures and all of them were monitored standard were recorded within 24
hours of operation. Overall morphine dose was also recorded for postoperative pain.
Results: The findings showed that there was a significant difference between the two groups in the Ropivacaine
group in the next hours despite the no significant difference in age, sex, BMI, duration of operation and pain
scoring at first and third hours. In addition, the comparison of the number of requests for at least one dose of
morphine in the Ropivacaine group is significantly lower. In addition, the comparison of the number of
requests for at least one dose of morphine in the Ropivacaine group is significantly lower. The occurrence of
PONV is also higher in the magnesium sulfate group, but this difference is not significant.
Conclusion: Local injection of Ropivacaine reduced acute pain after open cholecystectomy surgery in
comparison to local injection of magnesium sulfate. In addition, the use of Ropivacaine is associated with a
significant reduction in the need for intravenous morphine for analgesia.
Keywords: Magnesium sulfate, Ropivacaine, VAS, Open cholecystectomy
*Corresponding Author: Houman Teymourian, MD; Associate professor, Department of Anesthesia, Shohada Tajrish hospital, Shahid
Behesti university of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran. Email:
Please cite this article as: Khorasanizadeh Sh, Panahi M, Mohseni Gh, Behnaz F, Ebrahymy Dehkordy M, Teymourian H. Comparison
of Analgesia in Subcutaneous Infiltration of Ropivacaine and Magnesium Sulfate for Postoperative Pain Control of Cholecystectomy. Novel
Biomed. 2020;8(1):13-19.
Introduction
it was the eighth surgery in the US operating room2.
Cholecystectomy can be done either open or
laparoscopic. Open cholecystectomy is done with a
surgical incision of 12-8 cm and under the edge of the
ribs on the right side3 and the pain after this, is a
common problem for patients.
Reducing postoperative pain will facilitate functional
Cholecystectomy is a surgical procedure for the
removal of gallbladder and a common therapeutic
treatment for Gallstone symptoms and other
pathologies1, and in 2011, the 8th surgery in the
operating room was in the United States and in 2011
NBM
13
Novelty in Biomedicine 2020, 1, 13-19
Khorasanizadeh et al.
Comparison of Analgesia in Subcutaneous Infiltration of Ropivacaine and Magnesium …
recovery, the length of hospital stay and reducing
postoperative morbidity and uncontrolled pain after
surgery, causing chronic postoperative pain4. Despite
the major complications of high-dose opiates such as
respiratory supplements, ileus, nausea and vomiting,
they are still the main drug for controlling
postoperative pain, and, on the other hand, reducing
the dose of opiate can increase the amount of
postoperative pain. Substitutes for opiates are nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), which
also have side effects including reduced homeostasis,
renal dysfunction and gastrointestinal bleeding.
Different methods have been used to control
postoperative pain in abdominal surgery.
Among the peripheral nervous block5, injection of
Ropivacaine into the peritoneum, and the effect of
local infiltration of tramadol, Ropivacaine, Lidocaine
in the subcutaneous site of surgery, have been
considered in some studies. Magnesium sulfate is an
auxiliary drug in controlling pain by antagonizing the
calcium channel in the NMDA receptor6,7. Also,
magnesium is a safe and inexpensive drug that can
reduce postoperative pain and reduce pain relief8,9. In
general, upper abdominal surgery causes more pain
than lower abdominal surgery, which usually lasts for
48 to 72 hours and is considered to be moderate to
severe pain in severity10-12. Although today
laparoscopic cholecystectomy is most commonly
done by laparoscopy, but some cases of this operation
are performed in certain circumstances. Postoperative
analgesia plays an important role in the recovery of the
patient, since the inflammatory mediators released
after surgical trauma have a deleterious effect on the
functioning of the organs of the body and the recovery
of the patient after surgery13,14. Complications due to
lack of adequate control of pain during the
postoperative period include the release of
neuroendocrine hormone and cytokines, which in the
cardiovascular system leads to hypertension,
tachycardia, dysrhythmia, and ultimately myocardial
schizoids15 and reduces FRC in the pulmonary
system16,17, increased respiratory rate of hypoxemia,
Hypercapnia, and pneumonia in susceptible
individuals. In the GI system, control of the GI reflex18
and the decrease in the activity of the immune
system19, and all of these complications postoperative
pain control is necessary. Various techniques have
NBM
been proposed to eliminate postoperative pain. High
levels of opiates are often needed to control severe
postoperative pain, which is associated with multiple
side effects20. Lesion infiltration with local anesthetics
is an easy and effective method for controlling
postoperative pain that has recently been used
extensively21-23. But the effect of this method is not
clear enough to control postoperative pain. The two
groups of magnesium sulfate and Ropivacaine were
compared in this way.
Regarding the high prevalence of cholecystectomy
surgery and the adverse effects of pain on the body and
quality of life of patients, and the use of opiates and
systemic analgesics after surgery is associated with
complications and because of repeated appearances
with dissatisfaction of patients with epidural analgesia,
it seems that the choice of local analgesia is preferable
in some cases. The cost-effectiveness and availability
of used drugs is another reason to choose it.
In a case control study by Demiroglu et al6, which is
done in Turkey, the effect of using systemic and
regional magnesium sulfate on the amount of tramadol
was studied in patients undergoing laminectomy
surgery and observed that tramadol consumption was
significantly lower in group B than in the other two
grou (...truncated)