Mortality trends in sickle cell patients.
Am J Blood Res 2020;10(5):190-197
www.AJBlood.us /ISSN:2160-1992/AJBR0112865
Original Article
Mortality trends in sickle cell patients
Juan Cintron-Garcia, Germame Ajebo, Vamsi Kota, Achuta K Guddati
Division of Hematology/Oncology, Georgia Cancer Center, Augusta University, Augusta, GA 30909, USA
Received April 19, 2020; Accepted September 1, 2020; Epub October 15, 2020; Published October 30, 2020
Abstract: Background: Sickle cell disease affects a significant portion of US patients with African descent. It continues to be one of the leading causes of frequent hospitalizations and high in-hospital morality risk. Until the approval
of disease-modifying therapies in last two years, medical therapy has relied mostly on management of pain episodes and the use of hydroxyurea. We discuss the nationwide analysis of trends in in-hospital mortality in patients
with Sickle Cell Disease from 2000 to 2014. Methods: Trends of in-hospital mortality in sickle cell patients were
analyzed from a database provided by the Agency of Healthcare Research and Quality. From the data hospitalization
rates and in-hospital mortality in categories by region in the US, hospital size, health insurance status, comorbidities
and gender were examined. Patterns of in-hospital mortality were analyzed by logistic regression. Results: Ratio for
hospitalization and mortality among the four regions described Northeast, Midwest, South, West with respective
values of 0.63%, 0.65%, 0.76% and 0.89% with P = 0.008 and OR = 1.07. Odds ratio for sickle cell patients that died
during hospitalization and health insurance status was OR = 0.08. Comorbidities considered in sickle cell patients;
diabetes mellitus (DM), hypertension (HTN), hyperlipidemia (HLD), chronic kidney disease (CKD), smoking status.
The odds ratio for comorbidities show A-fib with a value of OR = 4.47, followed by hypertension OR = 1.92, diabetes
mellitus OR = 1.44 and chronic kidney disease OR = 1.29, smoking status OR = 0.60. Mortality-hospitalization ratio
by gender was: males 0.77% and females 0.69% with OR = 0.87. Conclusions: In-hospital mortality by US regions,
as well as health insurance status are important measurable elements that show the impact of the disease from a
public health perspective. Further and more specific data of regions by states, comorbidities by states and sex, as
well as health insurance status by states will provide further insight in local mortality trends.
Keywords: Delay time, polymerization, social determinants of health, sickle cell, literacy
Introduction
Sickle cell disease (SCD) encompasses a group
of genetic diseases that result from a single
point mutation in the position 6 of the gene
that encodes hemoglobin subunit ß [1]. It includes sickle cell anemia (SCA), sickle cell hemoglobin C (HbSC) and sickle ß-thalassemia.
The molecular structure of hemoglobin consists of combined globin subunits which in
association with the heme cofactor confers its
oxygen carrying capacity. Adult hemoglobin is
made up of two α subunits and two ß subunits
[1]. The substitution of valine for glutamic acid
within the molecular structure of the ß-globin
subunit, is the mutation which drives in the production of hemoglobin S (HbS) [2]. It is an autosomal recessive disease, where the two copies
of the ß subunits need to be mutated for evident clinical manifestation. Surface charge in
hemoglobin S is characterized by a variation
which under conditions of deoxygenation tends
to polymerize and create fibers as a conse-
quence of intracellular crystallization. The gradually increasing fibers through crystallization
contributes to the rigidity of the red cell and
progressively higher viscosity of blood. Of note,
there is a latency period of time or “delay time”
where hemoglobin is deoxygenated, however it
does not become polymerized during the initial
fraction of time [3]. If transit through microvasculature is beyond the delay time, hemoglobin
will be at higher risk of aggregating and will
favor “sickling” [3]. As hemoglobin S polymerizes, it weakens the erythrocyte membrane, promoting a dehydrated state with a higher tendency to hemolyze. Repeated episodes of deoxygenation over time causes an irreversible
stiffness of the red cell - a “sickle” shape. Acquired sickle shape and stiffness of the red
cells results in higher blood viscosity, red cell
membrane fragmentation and as a consequence shortened red blood cell lifespan. This is
a continuous process as the higher viscosity
results in a slower transit through the microvasculature causing higher oxygen extraction
Mortality in sickle cell patients
[3]. The lower oxygen affinity of HgS and its
deoxygenation worsens the sickling of the red
cells. Progressively slower transit of red cells
through the capillaries increases the delay time, worsens the deoxygenation and sickling as
the process continues [3].
Over time sickle cell disease leads to a chronic
inflammatory state through episodic vaso-occlusion causing ischemia, pain and important
organ system complications. The process of
intravascular hemolysis and release of cellfree hemoglobin creates reactive oxygen species which cause nitric oxide (NO) consumption
and oxidative damage [4]. As a third pathophysiologic mechanism, the reduced bioavailability
of NO is thought to trigger the expression of
adhesion molecules and at the same time production of the vasoconstrictor endothelin-1 [1].
Endothelial cells in activated state are associated with increased vascular tone and production of inflammatory mediators responsible for
vascular damage [1]. There is an overall increase in activation of the endothelium, coagulation proteins, leukocytes and platelets with
increased adhesion to endothelium mediated
to some extent by P-selectin [1, 5]. It is thus a
predisposing factor to endothelial dysfunction
and proliferative changes in the intima and
smooth muscle of the vasculature, which results in eventual systemic, pulmonary hypertension and organ injury [4].
Microvascular phenomena also manifest with
multiple organ damage. Beginning early in life
complications that stem from microvascular
changes predispose patients to vaso-occlusive pain episodes. This same mechanism can
also manifest as cerebrovascular events, acute chest syndrome (due to vaso-occlusion of
pulmonary vasculature). Acute chest syndrome
is in fact the second most common cause of
hospital admissions and most common cause
of sickle cell mortality [6]. The cascade of consequences as a result of generalized vasculopathy translates into cardiopulmonary complications, in which heart failure with or without
pulmonary hypertension is the primary cause
of mortality [7].
Gradually there is more organ involvement in
these patients, including progressive decrease
in renal function [8]. Renal medulla is the most
prominent site of injury as capillaries here are
relatively hypoxic, acidic and hypertonic all of
which favor sickling [9]. This results in greater
adhesion of erythrocytes to the (...truncated)