LiDAR and 2D Electrical Resistivity Tomography as a Supplement of Geomorphological Investigations in Urban Areas: a Case Study from the City of Wrocław (SW Poland)
MAREK KASPRZAK
0
ANDRZEJ TRACZYK
0
0
Institute of Geography and Regional Development, University of Wrocaw
, Plac Uniwersytecki 1, 50-137 Wrocaw,
Poland
In urbanized areas, particularly in lowland terrains and floors of large river valleys, the natural land configuration is often hard to recognize due to a long history of human activity. Accordingly, archaeological works in cities, which supply knowledge on settlement conditions, are usually accompanied by geological and geomophological research. Lately, data from light detection and ranging (LiDAR) have become a valuable source of information on urban land configuration. Geophysical methods are also becoming increasingly popular in background studies. The paper presents a method of using and linking these sources of spatial information about landforms in such areas. The main aim is to identify to what extent these complementary sources of data and the proposed method can be used in such a specific environment to reconstruct natural, buried terrain morphology. The city of Wrocaw in Central Europe serves as an example. To this end geomorphometric studies were conducted with the use of digital elevation models (DEMs) based on LiDAR scanning and derivated land-surface parametersSAGA Wetness Index, Channel Network Base Level and Altitude above Channel Network. The study also involved determining morphological edges and measurements of the meanders of the Odra, as well as expanding information on the spatial distribution of alluvia and the structure of slope breaks. To this end, geophysical measurements were conducted using the Two-Dimensional Electrical Resistivity Tomography method. Additionally, five typical sequences of man-made ground present within the perimeter of the city were distinguished. As a result, a map of the main landforms of Wrocaw is presented. Finally, we argue that although high resolution DEM and derivate land-surface parameters are very useful in terrain analysis, places with thick man-made ground or strongly levelled areas must be recognized by geoarchaeological excavations or geological bore holes. The geophysical survey is useful to identify buried morphological edges and older relief elements in open areas.
1. Introduction
Geomorphological studies in urban areas are
difficult to carry out due to dense development and
artificial transformations of natural surfaces
involving, among others, the formation of man-made
ground and modifications of the drainage system
(ROSENBAUM et al. 2003; SZABO 2010). As a result, the
natural land configuration, especially in lowland
areas, is obscured and hard to identify. This often
prevents an unequivocal identification of initial
landforms and the correct analysis of the local
palaeogeographic development. Such difficulties
accompany detailed geomorphological studies
conducted during archaeological works (KVAMME 2006).
These studies are greatly supported by digital
elevation models (DEMs) and geophysical methods of
ground penetration (KAMPKE 1999; CHALLIS 2006;
PAPADOPOULOS et al. 2006; TSOKAS et al. 2011).
Unfortunately, DEM analysis for flat, urbanized areas
causes many errors associated with a models
accuracy, impact of land cover, existence of buildings and
artificial transformations of ground surface (SITHOLE
and VOSSELMAN 2004; BONK 2007; LIU 2008; REUTER
et al. 2009). In addition, the analysis of terrain
morphology in urban areas based on DEMs are rarely
supported by results of other investigations. This
article presents a method to use and link multiple
sources of spatial information for determining
boundaries of natural landform units in relatively flat
(low relief gradients) urban areas, heavily altered by
human activities. The investigation is based on GIS
landform parameterization based on high resolution
DEM, geophysical surveys and geological or
geoarchaeological documentation. The main aim of
the study is to identify to what extent these
complementary sources of data and the proposed
method can be used in such a specific environment
for the reconstruction of natural terrain morphology.
The land-surface parameterization using the
submeter DEM is the first approach of this type in the
study areathe city of Wrocaw. The DEM analysis
draws on the existing knowledge about changes in the
drainage system and information about natural and
man-made sediments collected from various sources
(archaeological excavations, geomorphological and
archaeological literature). Due to the scarcity of
information concerning the spatial variation of
alluvial deposits outside of the city center and the
structure of valley escarpments, geophysical profiling
was conducted using the Two-Dimensional Electrical
Resistivity Tomography method (2D ERT). The
obtained results allowed for the reinterpretation of
previous geomorphological and geological views and
data. Among others, five typical sequences of made
grounds and the range of the main landform units
within the perimeter of the city were identified.
The proposed method is suitable for medium and
large-sized cities of Central Europe, located in valley
floors. Wrocaw, selected as a test area, has a history
closely related to the development tendencies of other
cities of Central Europe (PIEKALSKI 1999) e.g.,
Cracow, Leipzig, Dresden or Frankfurt; hence, it serves
as an example as to how these new data sources add
to the current state of knowledge on the natural
configuration of urban land.
2. Methods
In this paper the combination of
geomorphological research methods was used. Data obtained in the
traditional way (field mapping, analysis of
archaeological outcrops and geological bore holes) were
linked with an analysis of high resolution DEM and
results of geophysical surveys. This comprehensive
aggregation of research methods, rarely seen in the
literature, was attempted for an urban area, where
many factors interfere with the recognition of natural
landforms. The flow chart in Fig. 1 illustrates the
course of investigation.
The basis for this study was the spatial analysis of
the area of Wrocaw, based on DEM provided by the
Municipal Office of Wrocaw. The original resolution
of DEM is 1 9 1 m and it was created based on light
detection and ranging (LiDAR). The airborne
scanning was conducted in May 2006. The scanning point
density was 2 points per sq metre, and the vertical
measurement accuracy amounted to 15 cm. LiDAR
data underwent pre-processing (YOU et al. 2003) by
the supplier: the land surface (bare Earth model) was
extracted from the point cloudinformation about
the natural land cover, buildings and man-made
elements that obstruct the view of waters (bridge
fragments) were removed.
Light detection and ranging (LiDAR) data are one
of the most accurate sources about land configuration,
surpassing in precision global DEMs obtained from
satellites, using radar system (SRTM) or stereo-pair
images (Aster GDEM) and existed models from
digitization of topographic maps contours (DTED)
(GAMBA et al. 2002; HIRANO et al. (...truncated)