DIRECT ELECTION OF THE PRESIDENT BY THE PEOPLE: THE CASE OF TURKEY
2021, Yıl 5, Sayı 16, 19 - 35
DIRECT ELECTION OF THE PRESIDENT BY THE PEOPLE:
THE CASE OF TURKEY
CUMHURBAŞKANINI HALKIN DOĞRUDAN SEÇMESİ:
TÜRKİYE ÖRNEĞİ
DOI: 10.33404/anasay.911100
Çalışma Türü: Araştırma Makalesi / Research Article1*
Hasan YILMAZ**
ABSTRACT
The government of law is defined as the government bound by the rules
of law and provides all kinds of legal guarantees to its citizens. The democratic
government of law, also, is obliged to protect the rights of citizens, especially
fundamental rights and freedoms. The most important trait of democracy is that
the people transfer their sovereignty to a structure, institution or power through
democratic principles. The focus of the conception of democracy in this context
should be to provide, protect and develop fundamental rights and freedoms.
1- Makale Geliş Tarihi: 07. 04. 2021 Makale Kabül Tarihi: 30. 04. 2021
* This study has been produced by modifying the work presented as a paper at the 1st International
Communication and Management Congress on September 26-28, 2019. The article is the revised and
expanded version of the aforementioned paper.
** Asst. Prof., İnönü University Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences Department of
Political Science and Public Administration, , ORCID ID
org/0000-0001-9212-8084
https://orcid.
19
DIRECT ELECTION OF THE PRESIDENT BY THE PEOPLE: THE CASE OF TURKEY
In the regimes in which democracy is practised, each government branch
(power) is been entrusted with specific duty. The members of the parliament are
elected by the people through democratic methods and gathered under the roof
of the parliament. The legislative power regulates the rules of social life in the
context of the concepts of sovereignty and democracy. Executive members are
responsible for implementing the rules and regulations of the legislative body.
The president represents the government and assumes the role of government.
The judiciary has undertaken the duty of enforcing the laws following the codes.
In democracies based on the principle of separation of powers, the limits and
responsibilities of each power mentioned in the Constitution and laws have been
determined together with the executive, judicial and legislative functions.
According to article 8 of the Constitution, the executive power and duty
shall be exercised by the President in accord with the Constitution and the laws.
The twelfth Presidential elections in Turkey in 2014 were of historical importance. Following the 367 crisis in the Turkish Grand National Assembly in 2007,
the referendum for the amendment regulating the direct election of the president
by the people was approved. Thus, for the first time in Turkish democracy people, not the members of the parliament went to the ballot boxes and voted for
the 12th president of Turkey. In this study, systematic review method was used.
It is concluded that the direct election of the President by the people in Turkey
is forward step in terms of democracy.
Keywords: President, Democracy, Legislature, Executive.
ÖZ
Hukuk devleti, hukuk kurallarına bağlı ve vatandaşlarına her türlü hukuki güvenceler sağlayan devlet olarak bilinmektedir. Demokratik hukuk devleti
ise temel hak ve özgürlükler başta olmak üzere vatandaş haklarını korumakla
yükümlüdür. Demokrasinin en önemli özelliği, halkın kendi egemenlik hakkını demokratik ilkeler yoluyla bir yapıya, kuruma veya kuvvete devretmesidir.
Demokrasi anlayışının bu bağlamda odaklandığı alan temel hak ve özgürlükleri
sağlamak, korumak ve geliştirmek olmalıdır.
Demokrasinin uygulandığı rejimlerde kuvvetlere (erk) birer görev yüklenmiştir. Yasama üyeleri olan milletvekilleri halk tarafından demokratik yöntemlerle seçilerek parlamento çatısı altında toplanmaktadır. Yasama kuvveti
egemenlik ve demokrasi kavramları bağlamında halk adına toplumsal yaşamı
düzenleyici kuralları düzenler ve kararlar almaktadır. Yürütme üyeleri ise yasa- 20
Hasan YILMAZ
ma organının oluşturduğu kurallar ve düzenlemeleri uygulamaktan sorumludur.
Yürütmenin başı Cumhurbaşkanı devleti temsil eder ve hükümet etme görevini
üstlenmektedir. Yargı erki ise kanunları hukuka uygun olarak uygulamak görevini üstlenmiştir.
Anayasa’nın 8. Maddesine göre yürütme yetkisi ve görevi, Cumhurbaşkanı tarafından Anayasa ve kanunlara uygun olarak kullanılır ve yerine getirilir. Türkiye’de 2014 yılındaki 12. Cumhurbaşkanlığı seçimleri tarihe geçmiştir.
2007 yılında TBMM’de yaşanan 367 krizi sonrasında yapılan referandum ile
Cumhurbaşkanı’nın doğrudan halk tarafından seçilmesi kabul edilmiştir. Böylelikle 2014 yılında ise bir ilk yaşanmış ve Türkiye Cumhuriyeti’nin 12. Cumhurbaşkanını belirlemek için seçmen sandığa giderek oyunu kullanmış ve ülkesinin Cumhurbaşkanını TBMM’deki temsilcileri yoluyla değil doğrudan kendisi
seçmiştir. Bu çalışmada, sistematik derleme yöntemi kullanılmıştır. Türkiye’de
Cumhurbaşkanını doğrudan halkın seçmesinin demokrasi lehine bir adım olduğu sonucuna varılmıştır.
Anahtar Kelimeler: Cumhurbaşkanı, Demokrasi, Yasama, Yürütme.
1. INTRODUCTION
The government of law is known as the government that is bound by the
rules of law and provides all kinds of legal guarantees to its citizens. The democratic government of law, on the other hand, is obliged to protect the rights
of citizens, especially fundamental rights and freedoms. The most important
feature of democracy is that the people transfer their sovereignty to a structure,
institution or power through democratic principles. The focus of the understanding of democracy in this context is the provision and development of fundamental rights and freedoms.
In regimes where democracy is implemented, powers have been assigned
a specific task. In democracies based on the principle of separation of powers
among the executive, judiciary and legislative bodies, the limits and responsibilities of each power are determined in the Constitution and laws. Deputies
who are members of the legislature are elected by the people through democratic methods and gather under roof of the parliament. Legislative power makes
decisions on behalf of the people in the light of the concepts of sovereignty and
democracy. The executive members are responsible for implementing the rules
and regulations established by the legislature and undertake the government
task. Judicairy is the power which is performed through trials in courts.
21
DIRECT ELECTION OF THE PRESIDENT BY THE PEOPLE: THE CASE OF TURKEY
According to the 7th Article of the Constitution, legislative power belongs
only to the Turkey Grand National Assembly and this power is not transferable.
According to Article 8 of the Constitution, executive power and duty are exercised by the President in accordance with the Constitution and laws. According
to Article 9 of the Constitution, judicial power is exercised by independent and
impartial courts on behalf of the Turkish Nation (T.C. Constitution, 1982). The
deputies elected through the votes of citizens of the Republic of Turkey act as
(...truncated)