A Novel Hybrid Model for Short-Term Wind Speed Forecasting Based on Twice Decomposition, PSR, and IMVO-ELM
Hindawi
Complexity
Volume 2022, Article ID 4014048, 21 pages
https://doi.org/10.1155/2022/4014048
Research Article
A Novel Hybrid Model for Short-Term Wind Speed Forecasting
Based on Twice Decomposition, PSR, and IMVO-ELM
Xin Xia
and Xiaolu Wang
School of Mechanical and Electrical Engineering, Suqian University, Suqian 223800, China
Correspondence should be addressed to Xin Xia;
Received 21 October 2021; Accepted 5 January 2022; Published 19 January 2022
Academic Editor: Lingzhong Guo
Copyright © 2022 Xin Xia and Xiaolu Wang. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution
License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is
properly cited.
Accurate wind speed forecasting is an effective way to improve the safety and stability of power grid. A novel hybrid model based
on twice decomposition, phase space reconstruction (PSR), and an improved multiverse optimizer-extreme learning machine
(IMVO-ELM) is proposed to enhance the performance of short-term wind speed forecasting in this paper. In consideration of the
nonstationarity of the wind speed signal, a twice decomposition based on improved complete ensemble empirical mode decomposition with adaptive noise (ICEEMDAN), fuzzy entropy, and variational mode decomposition (VMD) is proposed to
reduce the nonstationarity of the original signal firstly. Then the PSR based on C-C method is employed to reconstitute the
decomposed signal as the input of the prediction model. Lastly, an improved multiverse optimizer is proposed to improve the
stability and efficiency of ELM which is used as prediction model. Furthermore, two experiments are designed to verify the
performance of the proposed method; the results indicate that (1) the wind speed forecasting with twice decomposition of original
wind speed signal is better than other once-decomposition methods and much better than forecasting without decomposition; (2)
the C-C-PSR method can determine the input dimension of ELM and improve the prediction accuracy of ELM; (3) the IMVO has
improved the stability of ELM, and the optimization efficiency is better than other comparison optimization methods. The results
show that the proposed hybrid approach is a useful tool for short-term wind speed forecasting.
1. Introduction
With exhaustion of fossil energy and increase of requirements of environmental protection, energy supply has become an important problem. Developing clean energy is an
effective way to solve energy problems. Wind energy as a
cheap, recyclable, pollution-free energy has been vigorously
developed by many countries, and the capacity of wind
turbine is increasing rapidly [1]. According to statistics, the
wind-turbine capacity increased from 487 GW in 2016 to
702 GW in 2020 [2].
Wind speed has the characteristics of randomness, intermittence, and fluctuation which makes the output power
of wind turbine unstable. With the grid-connected largescale wind power, the unstable output power brings great
challenge to power grid [3]. Accurate wind speed forecasting
is an effective tool to improve the safety and stability of
power grid [4]. Many of wind speed forecasting methods
have been proposed in the fast few decades. The methods can
be classified into two categories [5]: the physical-driven
methods and the data-driven methods. The physical-driven
methods are usually established with topography, temperature, density, air pressure, and altitude. And the numerical
weather prediction (NWP) is employed for forecasting [6, 7].
With the low resolution of NWP, the physical-driven
methods usually cannot meet the demand of short-term
wind speed forecasting [8].
The data-driven methods just need the history data for
forecasting which is more suitable for short-term wind speed
forecasting. The data-driven methods can be divided into
two categories: statistical algorithms and artificial intelligence algorithms. The statistical algorithms employed for
wind speed forecasting mainly include autoregressive
moving average model (ARMA) and autoregressive integrated moving average model (ARIMA) [9, 10]. The ARMA
model is a linear model which is not very suitable for the
2
Complexity
nonstationary signals [11]. The ARIMA model can convert
nonstationary signals into stationary time series which
improved the prediction accuracy of wind speed [12]. With
the development of computer science, the artificial intelligence algorithms have been widely employed in wind speed
forecasting, such as support vector machine (SVM) [13, 14],
backpropagation (BP) [15], Elman neural network [16, 17],
and extreme learning machine (ELM) [18, 19]. Among these
artificial intelligence algorithms, the ELM has the fastest
calculation speed and stronger generalization ability [20]
which mean it is more suitable for short-term forecasting.
With the nonstationarity of wind speed, data preprocessing can get more useful data features from original
wind speed signal to improve the prediction accuracy
[21, 22]. Data preprocessing methods have been widely used
to reduce the nonstationarity of wind speed signal, such as
wavelet transform (WT) [12], empirical mode decomposition (EMD) [23], ensemble empirical mode decomposition
(EEMD) [24], complete ensemble empirical mode decomposition with adaptive noise (CEEMDAN) [25], improved
complete ensemble empirical mode decomposition with
adaptive noise (ICEEMDAN) [26], and variational mode
decomposition (VMD) [27]. The ICEEMDAN has solved the
modal mixing problem and the residual components in
intrinsic mode function (IMF) are greatly reduced [28, 29].
The VMD can also solve the modal mixing problem by
decomposing signal into band-limited subseries [30, 31].
In this paper, a novel hybrid model for short-term wind
speed forecasting based on twice decomposition, phase
space reconstruction (PSR), and an improved multiverse
optimizer-extreme learning machine (IMVO-ELM) is proposed. The proposed method includes data processing
module, prediction module, and combination of final results
module. A twice-decomposition method based on ICEEMDAN, fuzzy entropy, and VMD is proposed as data
processing module. A prediction model based on C-C-PSR
and IMVO-ELM is proposed as prediction module. The
main contributions of this paper are illustrated as follows:
is described in Section 2. In Section 3, the proposed hybrid
model and the methodology of the article are described
detailedly. Experiments are conducted and the results are
analyzed in Section 4. Conclusions are given in Section 5.
2. Theoretical Background
The theoretical backgrounds related to the proposed method
of this paper are briefly reviewed in this section, including
ICEEMDAN, VMD, fuzzy entropy, PSR based on C-C, and
ELM.
2.1. ICEEMDAN. ICEEMDAN is proposed by Colominas
based on CEEMDAN which is recognized as the important
improvement of EEMD [32]. The ICEEMDAN adds the
mode of white noise to original signal instead of white noise
which greatly reduc (...truncated)