Data analysis and prediction of the COVID-19 outbreak in the first and second waves for top 5 affected countries in the world
Nonlinear Dyn
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11071-022-07473-9
(0123456789().,-volV)
( 01234567
89().,-volV)
ORIGINAL PAPER
Data analysis and prediction of the COVID-19 outbreak
in the first and second waves for top 5 affected countries
in the world
Ashabul Hoque . Abdul Malek . K. M. Rukhsad Asif Zaman
Received: 6 November 2021 / Accepted: 20 April 2022
Ó The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer Nature B.V. 2022
Abstract In this paper, we introduce a SEIATR
compartmental model to analyze and predict the
COVID-19 outbreak in the Top 5 affected countries
in the world, namely the USA, India, Brazil, France,
and Russia. The officially confirmed cases and death
due to COVID-19 from the day of the official
confirmation to June 30, 2021 are considered for each
country. Primarily, we use the data to make a
comparison between the cumulative cases and deaths
due to COVID-19 among these five different countries. This analysis allows us to infer the key parameters associated with the dynamics of the disease for
these five different countries. For example, the analysis reveals that the infection rate is much higher in the
USA, Brazil, and France compared to that of India and
Russia, while the recovery rate is found almost the
same for these countries. Further, the death rate is
measured higher in Brazil as opposed to India, where it
is found much lower among the remaining countries.
We then use the SEIART compartmental model to
characterize the first and second waves of these
countries, as well as to investigate and identify the
influential model parameters and nature of the virus
transmissibility in respective countries. Besides estimating the time-dependent reproduction number (Rt)
for these countries, we also use the model to predict
the peak size and the time occurring peak in respective
countries. The analysis demonstrates that COVID-19
was observed to be much more infectious in the second
wave than the first wave in all countries except France.
The results also demonstrate that the epidemic took off
very quickly in the USA, India, and Brazil compared
to two other countries considered in this study.
Furthermore, the prediction of the epidemic peak size
and time produced by our model provides a very good
agreement with the officially confirmed cases data for
all countries expect Brazil.
Keywords COVID-19 SEIATR model
Reproduction number Second wave Peak period
Epidemic evolution
A. Hoque (&) A. Malek
Department of Mathematics, University of Rajshahi,
Rajshahi 6205, Bangladesh
e-mail:
1 Introduction
A. Malek
e-mail:
1.1 COVID-19 and its characteristics
K. M. R. A. Zaman
Department of Public Health, North South University,
Dhaka, Bangladesh
e-mail:
The coronavirus disease (COVID-19) from China has
spread globally since January 2020 and has become a
pandemic. Currently, there are around 222 countries
123
A. Hoque et al.
that report laboratory-confirmed cases across the
World (WHO). Cumulative data of confirmed cases
(182,688,695), recovered (167,288,083), and deaths
(3,956,008) are taken from the beginning to June 30,
2021 (Johns Hopkins University). An infectious
disease is the episode of an illness that is not generally
expected in a particular group of people, geographical
region, or time. Due to the relatively new nature of this
disease, proper control measures and therapeutic
interventions are still under development, which in
turn is creating tremendous tension and panic around
the World. Not only is the COVID-19 pandemic
threatening our social and personal life and the broader
aspects, such as our economy, health, and development in both the national and global sense. Due to
uncertainties of the disease, investigators have used
several models to forecast the characteristics of
transmission parameters, primary reproduction number (R0), time-depended reproduction number (Rt), the
time of peak (tp), etc.
1.2 Related works
The researches on mathematical modeling are playing
a key role in understanding the epidemics, and it may
help to predict the intensity of pandemics in the early
stages. This also demonstrates a significant role in
making the right decision during outbreak control [1].
In this regard, several researchers have developed
mathematical models for the COVID-19 epidemic
[2–13]. Very recently, Kuddus and Rahman [2] have
used the improved SLIR model with nonlinear incidence, and they have observed that the transmission
rate of each parameter had a significant impact on
COVID-19. Lobato et al. [3] proposed a dynamic data
segmentation approach to provide reasonable estimates for all parameters. A three-party differential
game model including epidemic prevention and risk
coefficient was proposed by [14], and results were
presented based on theoretical and numerical analysis.
Toda [4] estimated the COVID-19 transmission rates
for several countries based on the SIR model for
regular data of confirmed cases. Tang et al. [15]
proposed a compartmental model with a clinical
progress compartment and epidemiological compartment, and they showed that the isolation compartment
could successfully reduce the transmission hazard.
Biswas et al. [16] formulated a deterministic compartmental model to estimate the model parameters
123
and compared these against the reported data. Wu
et al. [5] used a four-compartment (SEIR) model to
explain the transmission rates and forecast the countrywide and worldwide feast of the COVID-19
epidemic based on published data from December
31, 2019, to January 28, 2020. They also determined
the basic reproduction number for COVID-19, and it
was nearly 2.68 for China. COVID-19 outbreaks on
human-to-human transmission based on the computational modeling of probable epidemic trajectories
were estimated by Imai et al. [17]. They focused that
the control actions needed to block over 60% of
transmission to control the outbreak effectively.
Ahmed et al. [18] developed a SEIR time-fractional
model to investigate the nature of coronavirus in
Pakistan and discussed the stability analysis. Pedersen
et al. [19] proposed the SIQR model to discuss the
dynamics of COVID-19 in Italy. Hoertel et al. [20]
represented a stochastic agent-based microsimulation
model of COVID-19 to examine the impact of maskwearing, physical distancing, and shielding individuals and showed that those were slowing the spread of
the epidemic and reducing the mortality rate.
In epidemiology, the average basic reproduction
number (R0) is defined as the average number of
secondary cases that would be generated by a primary
infectious disease in a susceptible population [21].
Determining R0 is often stimulating for the involvement of numerous factors and a deficiency of unbiased
data. In most cases, secondary infections cannot be
estimated precisely, particularly for COVID-19,
where asymptomatic patients are barely recognized.
There are many techniques to calculate R0 [22], some
of them agree with each other, and some are developed
based on the secondary infe (...truncated)