Editorial: Diversity is Our Heritage and Our Future
Editorial: Diversity is Our Heritage
and Our Future
Kathryn Weedman Arthur, University of South Florida, Saint Petersburg, USA
E-mail:
EDITORIAL
Archaeologies: Journal of the World Archaeological Congress ( 2023)
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11759-023-09483-4
John Carman, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK
E-mail:
Teaching is itself an ethnographic enterprise; if we fail to take an anthropological approach to our students, if we fail to accept that teaching is not just
performance, but a scholarly activity based on research with an evolving
methodology, then chances are our students are not learning what we think
we are teaching (p. 3). … Intellectual freedom is not freedom from ethical
responsibility, either to the people whose voices can only be heard through
their surviving material culture, or to the people whose voices can only be
heard if we listen carefully, and we must use our expertise to teach others to
listen (Pyburn, Archaeologies 1 (3): 2005:4).
The sentiments above were written in the first issues of Archaeologies by
co-editors, Nick Shepard and K. Anne Pyburn, and strongly resonate with
our continued commitment to be a journal dedicated to multivocality,
2023 World Archaeological Congress
ARCHAEOLOGIES
There are three aspects that make it [Archaeologies] a significant and new
addition to the available journal literature, and that underline its mission
and function in our own minds. The first is in providing a platform for the
concerns and interests of Indigenous people and archaeologists, on a basis of
mutual respect. The second is in acting as a forum for a set of discussions
and dialogues linking up archaeologists identified with the North and South,
East and West, West and non-West, First and Third Worlds, developed and
underdeveloped contexts, and dominant and subaltern nations, groupings,
and individuals. The third is in the explicit recognition that this multivocality
is structured by relations of power and privilege, by different access to
resources, and by different bodies of memory and historical experience. …it
is the third aspect in particular that moves us beyond the politics of representation to something new and potentially more challenging. It involves
acknowledging diversity, multiplicity, and difference, even as we recognise
the ties that bind, the ways in which we remain enmeshed in ever more complex networks, relations, and reciprocities. It means recognising the full complexity of contemporary circumstances (Shepard, Archaeologies 1 (1):
2005:3).
K. W. ARTHUR, J. CARMAN
diversity, and inclusion as expressed in our current mission. We begin this
issue with deep gratitude to previous editors—including the journal founders, authors, and reviewers who generously contributed to Archaeologies
making it a quality peer-reviewed journal.
Our new cover for Archaeologies was inspired by our mission to be the
archaeology and heritage journal that includes scholarly research from every
country in the world. In its first year, Archaeologies published 26 articles in
two issues (August and December) written by authors from 9 countries. By
2007, the demand to publish in the journal had grown to an extent that a
3rd issue in April became the standard.
In 2022, we published 25 articles from scholars in 13 countries, Australia, Chile, China, Czech Republic, Finland, India, Iran, Italy, South
Africa, Turkey, Uganda, Ukraine, and United States.
Since 2005, researchers from 62 countries have submitted articles to
Archaeologies (Fig. 1). Not unexpectedly, the highest number of submissions derive from countries, where English is either the national language
or widely spoken, such as the United States, United Kingdom, Australia,
India, and South Africa. Authors from Iran, China, Japan, Jordan, Sweden,
Brazil, and Argentina, constitute another 23 percent of submissions.
Over the course of 19 years, editors of Archaeologies sent 1779 reviewer
requests to 467 persons living in 56 countries. We would particularly like
to extend our deep gratitude for the generous support of Hearther Burke,
Claire Smith, Reinhard Bernbeck, Arek Marciniak, Jordan Ralph, Jamie
Almansa Sánchez, and Marcia Bezerra for their dedication reviewing 10–17
articles each! Twenty-two reviewers were board members, who completed
nearly 15% of requested reviews. We have most heavily depended on
reviewers from the United States (36%), United Kingdom (11%), and Australia (10%), followed by reviewers in Canada, Spain, Iran, Germany,
Argentina, Brazil, Sweden, and Mexico.
Since 2005, Archaeologies has published articles with authors from 48
countries. Scholars from the United States, UK, Australia, Canada, South
Africa, Argentina, and Brazil garnered the majority of publications in
Archaeologies (Fig. 1). Publications from authors originating in Asia: China,
India, Iran; Europe: Sweden and Spain; and South America: Brazil and
Argentina also have been strong (Fig. 2).
Archaeologies aims to continue growth in our submissions, reviewer
base, board, and accepted articles with our mission statement in mind:
Archaeologies aims to attract submissions that seek to recenter (or decenter)
archaeology, and that challenge local and global power geometries. Areas of
interest include ethics and archaeology; public archaeology; legacies of colonialism and nationalism within the discipline; the interplay of local and global archaeological traditions; theory and archaeology; the discipline’s
Fig. 1. Comparison of articles submitted and accepted between 2005 and 2023 and the geographical origin of authors (Images created by
Kathryn W. Arthur, data generated in Editorial Manager 2023)
Editorial: Diversity is Our Heritage and Our Future
K. W. ARTHUR, J. CARMAN
Fig. 2. Graph illustrating the acceptance of articles between 2005 and 2023 according to continent of the authors. This graph does not include authors from the United
States, UK, Australia, Canada, South Africa, Argentina, and Brazil
involvement in projects of memory, identity, and restitution; and rights and
ethics relating to cultural property, issues of acquisition, custodianship, conservation, and display. Recognizing the importance of non-Western epistemologies and intellectual traditions, the journal publishes some material in
nonstandard format, including dialogues; annotated photographic essays;
transcripts of public events; and statements from elders, custodians, descent
groups and individual.
Archaeologies historically has published research articles, debate forums,
and special issues that strongly reflect our mission. A purview of published
articles demonstrate emphasis on Education (Public, Teaching, and Student), Heritage Politics (Power, Engagement, Collaboration, Conflict),
Subaltern Identities (Indigenous, descendant, race, ethnicity, gender and
sexuality), and Theory (Feminist, Intersectionality, and Postcolonial).
Recent articles also suggest a strong trend towards understanding the contributions and pitfalls for inclus (...truncated)