The Optimum Vibration of the Compressive Strength of Concrete Specimen
E-ISSN: 2528-388X
P-ISSN: 0213-762X
INERSIA
Vol.18, No.2, December, 2022
The Optimum Vibration of the Compressive Strength of Concrete
Specimen
Dwifi Aprillia Karismaa*, Agata Iwan Candraa, Mahardi Kamalika Khusna Alia, Tiara Sherlyta Saria, Sheila
Ananda Putri Pertiwia
a
Study Program of Civil Engineering, Faculty of Engineering Kadiri University, Kediri, 64115, Indonesia
ABSTRACT
Keywords:
Compressive Strength
Concrete Vibration
Vibrating Table
Concrete is the primary material in construction, so it needs further research to get good quality
concrete. The quality and durability of concrete are influenced by the amount and shape of the
air cavity inside the concrete. With vibrating, the air that is inside the concrete will be lost. The
benefits of vibration will only be achieved if planned and implemented with a suitable method.
With proper vibration, the air in the concrete will come out and make porous concrete.
Reduction or removal of air cavities will make concrete mixes strong with low permeability,
increasing the durability of concrete. This study aims to determine the optimum strong vibrating
on the compressive strength of Fc’ 21,7 Mpa concrete. Vibrating will be performed on cylinder
concrete samples with a duration time of 3 minutes and with different variations in acceleration
160 m/s2, 170 m/s2, 180 m/s2, 190 m/s2, 200 m/s2, variation velocity 140 mm/s, 150 mm/s, 160
mm/s, 170 mm/s, 180 mm/s, displacement variation 600 mm, 800 mm, 1000 mm, 1200 mm,
1500 mm. Each variation consists of 7 concrete samples. These tests were performed with
methods of external vibrating by using MBT Vibrating table CO-410 in fresh concrete.
Compressive strength testing is carried out at 28 days. This study shows that the optimum strong
vibrating with acceleration 180 m/s2, velocity 160 mm/s, and displacement 1000 mm with the
resulting compressive strength is Fc’ 23.06 MPa. So that knowing the optimum vibration
strength can be the basis for the implementation of vibration to get the planned concrete quality.
`
This is an open access article under the CC–BY license.
1. Introductions
The construction industry is one of the industries with a
high potential to improve the economy. Construction
materials must be used properly and adapted to the needs.
Concrete is one of the dominant materials in construction.
[1] Development in construction, such as buildings,
bridges, and roads, is growing rapidly, resulting in
increased demand for concrete [2][3]. Concrete becomes
a material in construction that is widely used because of
the ease of maintaining concrete and also the concrete
constituent material that is easily obtained. Concrete
consists of cement, aggregate, and water. Sometimes
admixture is added to or improves concrete requirements
[4]. In addition to admixture, air voids in the concrete
affect its quality and durability [5]-[7]. Vibration is an
important casting process to ensure proper concrete
consolidation. [8] Consolidation is the distribution of
concrete composition materials evenly in the mixture.
*Corresponding author.
E-mail:
https://doi.org/10.21831/inersia.v18i2.54522
Received 14 November 2022; Revised 29 December 2022; Accepted 31 December 2022
Available online 31 December 2022
Consolidation in fresh concrete is important because of its
effect on compressive strength [9]. Vibration can reduce
the air cavity [10], so filling that space with cement or
aggregating with that concrete will be high quality. [11] A
1% air cavity in concrete will reduce 6% concrete
strength. [12] Reduction or removal of air cavities will
make concrete mixes strong with low permeability,
increasing the durability of concrete [13]. In addition to
compressive strength and durability, concrete with a
vibrator will increase workability compared to concrete
that does not use a vibrator.[14] With proper vibration, the
concrete's air will come out and make porous concrete
[15].
In general, vibration is a repetitive motion over some time,
with the related parameters of acceleration, velocity, and
displacement [16]. For good-quality concrete, the
vibration must be done properly. [17] The benefits of
vibration will only be achieved if planned and
implemented with the right method. One of them is about
Dwifi Aprillia Karisma, et. al.
INERSIA, Vol. 18, No. 2, December 2022
time and frequency. Concrete compressive strength will
increase with increasing strong vibration and time
vibration, but a vibration that exceeds the optimum time
will make the concrete segregation. [18] in concrete,
segregation or separation of aggregates must be controlled
and even avoided because it will affect the strength and
durability of concrete. [19] Compressive strength
becomes a parameter to determine the strength or quality
of concrete [20].
2. Method
The research is based on experimentally making test
objects in the laboratory. The purpose of this experimental
study is to examine how the strong influence of concrete
compaction.
2.1 Material
Concrete material must meet the material requirements to
achieve the planned quality. The concrete must be tested
in civil engineering laboratories to meet the material
requirements.
In general, the use of vibrators for compaction is often
used for the production of cast or precast concrete [21].
Vibration methods on concrete used in the precast industry
are; Internal vibration, External vibration, tamping,
vacuum, and pressure. The internal vibrator produces
compression waves that are repeated quickly and show the
best performance at high amplitude [22]. External
vibration will produce concrete with a better surface
because, in its implementation, vibrations are not given
directly to fresh concrete but to concrete formwork [23].
A table vibrator is one of the external vibrators widely
used in the precast industry. The vibration is given to the
concrete and placed under the table plate so there is no
internal friction in the concrete [25]. Several studies have
investigated the behavior of concrete caused by concrete
vibration. However, not much has been discussed how
strong it is needed to achieve optimum compressive
strength.
a) Cement
Cement in the concrete mixture serves as a binder for
aggregate materials. The adhesive used is (PCC type I
refresh to ASTM C150 [25].
b) Aggregate
Fillers in concrete mixes derived from natural materials
are called aggregates which refer to ASTM C33 [26].
Approximately aggregate occupies 70% of the volume of
concrete [27]. The aggregates used in this study are coral
and sand [28] The coarse aggregate, taken from the village
of Kedak Kediri in East Java with a maximum size 20 mm,
with the amount of mud in coarse aggregate as much as
1.41%. In the coarse leaching aggregate, remove fine
aggregate particles, which can affect the concrete
properties [29]. The fine aggregate is taken from the
Brantas River in Kediri, East Java, with a maximum size
2 mm with an amount of mud in fine aggregate of 4.3%.
All aggregate is free from organic substanc (...truncated)