Economic Challenges on Motherhood and Womanhood and the Issue of Gender-Based Violence (GBV) in the South African Society
“Ovidius” University Annals, Economic Sciences Series
Volume XXIII, Issue 2 /2023
Economic Challenges on Motherhood and Womanhood and the Issue of
Gender-Based Violence (GBV) in the South African Society
Fazel Ebrihiam Freeks
North-West University, Faculty of Theology, South Africa
Dikeledi Jacobeth Warlimont
Mzansi Youth leadership Academy NPO|NGO, South Africa, SADC & AU
Pius-Shaun Warlimont
Mzansi Youth Leadership Academy NPO|NGO, South Africa
Abstract
This paper illustrates economic challenges on motherhood, womanhood, children, and the issue
of GBV. It has become evident in numerous families that societal role of mothers has shifted
immensely. As a result, many scholars decided to study the various components of motherhood.
Hence, the objective of this paper is to comprehend motherhood in society and its acceptance in the
domestic domain. Becoming a mother was not the mother’s decision, it was a response to
sociocultural pressure that held women accountable pertaining to children. Women had distinct
motherhood experiences, but it is kept secret from the family and society. The issue of GBV cause
mothers to face immense pressure in a morally acceptable motherhood society. Therefore, mothers
have a very negative perception of motherhood, particularly in a highly demanding patriarchal
society.
Key words: motherhood, womanhood, gender-based violence
J.E.L classification: A12, B55, I24, J12, J13, J17
1. Introduction
This paper is a meta-theory analysis or literature review on motherhood, womanhood and GBV.
In our current era, one of the most prevalent human rights violations is violence against women,
many of whom are mothers. The effects of this abuse and brutality are extensive, negatively
impacting the lives of women and girls, as well as their families, communities, and society at large.
The elimination and prevention of violence and abuse against women should be a top objective in all
communities. Therefore, the two main objectives of this paper are, to describe the adverse
consequences of gender-based violence (GBV) as destructive social ills in society. The first objective
is to understand the value and significance of women and mothers in society, the second objective is
suggesting practical theological ways to address and curb gender-based violence as a destructive
form of warfare against women. Studies repeatedly demonstrate the enormous benefits for children
of having a mother who is present, nurturing, involved, and concerned. However, many activist
organisations disagree with the importance of mothers and women to children and society. Mothers'
notable and influential traits, as well as the crucial role they play in the family and society, are often
contested. Moreover, motherhood still presents significant and potentially fatal difficulties for
women today. One of the most common violations of human rights in our time involves violence and
abuse against women, many of whom are mothers. These harmful factors have far-reaching effects,
endangering the lives of women, mothers, and girls, as well as their families and societies. The
prohibition and prevention of this violent nature and abuse against women and mothers should be a
top concern in every family and community.
80
“Ovidius” University Annals, Economic Sciences Series
Volume XXIII, Issue 2 /2023
The family holds great importance in both the church and broader society. The family is seen as
having a covenantal nature and plays a significant role in caring for individuals (eds. Botha et al.
n.d.:84). This article, however, acknowledges the importance of motherhood and the role mothers
play in families and society. Also, this article recognises the mother-child bond, which is crucial for
a child's healthy development since it serves as a strong force for social interaction and cohesion.
2. Literature review
The literature review in this paper is a met-theory analysis on motherhood, womanhood, children
included and the issue of gender-based violence (GBV).
2.1. The concept of “motherhood” and meta-studies regarding to motherhood
Motherhood is a fascinating scholarly and academic topic, according to Huopalainen and Satama
(2019:102), with connections to an embodiment, the performance of gender, materiality, affectivity,
femininity, and sexuality, as well as power, structural problems, and patriarchal oppression, and
specifically a dense bodily experience that engages the senses (Huopalainen & Satama 2019:99).
Patriarchal societies disadvantage women because social duties are gendered, harmful, and risky to
women. Hence, the risk of reducing the experience of motherhood to a patriarchal institution and
motherhood as a role forced on women is raised by some authors and scholars who claim that the
discourse of motherhood is exclusively focused on. The original meaning is lost if one concentrates
too much on the influence of prevalent ideas of motherhood (Frizelle & Kell 2010:27).
In the studies of Miller-McLemore (1994:20), motherhood can be defined as mothers performing
quite a few types of indispensable caring, and who must support one another. Hence, every child's
fundamental need is fulfilled by the term mother, which conjures up those feelings of joyful,
unconditional love and care. Motherhood is further an intentional action that cultivates a selfobservance practice that leads to maternal thought (Rose 2015:11). Therefore, the act of motherhood
is special and mostly an "untapped resource of theological reflection" (Miller-McLemore 1994:21).
Interestingly and appropriately, especially in the context of this article, is that Miller-McLemore
indicated in her book, ‘Also a Mother: Work and Family as Theological Dilemma’, that she faced
life's challenges while being pregnant and on the verge of becoming a mother (Miller-McLemore
1994:21). Working full-time to support families presents innumerable challenges for mothers
(Miller-McLemore 1994:21). Hence, the responsibilities placed upon women, especially as mothers,
are considerably heightened due to the daily obligations and sacrifices that come with parenting.
Finding a harmonious balance and sense of purpose in life, while juggling familial responsibilities,
proves to be much more challenging and intricate than managing a traditional nine-to-five job and
caring for one's family.
In conclusion, it is very significant in the context of this paper when Miller-McLemore asserts
that ample theologians are mother figures but only a few have studied the intersection of motherhood
and theology (1999:287).
2.2. The gender-based violence (GBV) issue in society and its adverse effects on mothers and
women in the South African Society: definition and statistics
Reflecting on the wording used by the United Nations General Assembly meeting conducted in
1993, Finchilescu and Dugard (2018:3) define ‘gender-based violence’ as "violence against women
(mothers) means any act of gender-based violence that results in, or is likely to result in, physical,
sexual, or psy (...truncated)