The Effect of Cognitive Puzzle Therapy on the Independence Level of Elderly with Dementia in Nursing Home East Jakarta
ISSN 2354-8428
e-ISSN 2598-8727
JURNAL KEPERAWATAN
KOMprEhEnsIF
COMPREHENSIVE NURSING JOURNAL
Vol. 10 No. 2, April 2024
Published by :
Sekolah Tinggi Ilmu Keperawatan
PPNI Jawa Barat
JURNAL KEPERAWATAN
KOMPREHENSIF
VOL. 10
NO. 2
Bandung
April
2024
ISSN
2354-8428
e-ISSN
2598-8727
315
p-ISSN : 2354 8428 | e-ISSN: 2598 8727
Jurnal Keperawatan Komprehensif
Volume 10 Issue 2 April 2024
Research Article
The Effect of Cognitive Puzzle Therapy on the Independence Level of
Elderly with Dementia in Nursing Home East Jakarta
Dheni Wahyudi1* │ Syamsul Anwar2 │
1,2,3Faculty
of Nursing,
Universitas Muhammadiyah
Jakarta 10510, Indonesia
*contact
Received : 29/09/2023
Revised : 18/04/2024
Accepted : 28/04/2024
Online : 30/04/2024
Published : 30/04/2024
Lily Herlinah3
Abstract
Aims: This study aims to identify the effect of puzzle cognitive therapy
on the level of independence of elderly people with dementia in
nursing homes.
Method : the research used a quasi-experimental pre-post design with
control group design. Sampling was taken using a total sampling
technique, 24 respondents in the intervention group and 24 in the
control group. Puzzle therapy was carried out for 9 sessions.
Measurement of independence used the MMSE (Mini mental status
examination) questionnaire and the Katz Index. Analysis with
dependent t-test at significance 0.05 (CI 95%) and GLM-RM (General
Linear Model Repeated Measure).
Results: The results of the paired T test in the intervention group
produced a p-value of 0.000, while the control group had a p-value of
0.043. dependent T test and Greenhouse-Geisser (sig) with p value
0.00. Elderly people who are given puzzle activities improve the health
and well-being of elderly people with cognitive decline
Conclusion: puzzle therapy can improve increasing independence in
elderly people with dementia.
Keywords:
Elderly, Independence, Puzzle Cognitive Therapy
INTRODUCTION
The elderly population is growing as
medical facilities and services are improved,
birth rates are regulated, life expectancies
rise, and mortality rates fall. Extended life
expectancy in the elderly does not eliminate
the issue of declining body function, which
affects the elderly's independence in
performing daily activities. The structure
and function of our cells, tissues, and organ
systems deteriorate with grow older, which
has a negative impact on our physical and
mental health. This, in turn, affects how our
family, socioeconomic status, and social
roles change, which makes it more difficult
to adapt to new situations and engage in
social interactions (1).
https://doi.org/10.33755/jkk
The elderly's physical changes in the
nervous system occur with impaired
memory,
thinking,
comprehension,
orientation, arithmetic, language and value
functions as a result of impaired brain
function, experiencing a decline in the body
system which includes physical, mental and
psychosocial changes (2)
Dementia is a syndrome of decreased
cognitve function which results in
disruption of daily activities and is
accompanied by behavioral disorders
without delirium or major psychiatric
disorders (3). The elderly often suffer from
Alzheimer's dementia, which is a
degenerative disease that occurs due to a
decrease in brain function which affects
emotions, memory, decision making,
This is an open access article under the CC BY-SA license
316
p-ISSN : 2354 8428 | e-ISSN: 2598 8727
Jurnal Keperawatan Komprehensif
Volume 10 Issue 2 April 2024
behavior and other brain functions, thereby
interfering with activities in daily life, (4).
images or information absorbed, and
retaining the information obtained (7).
Health problems in the cognitive function of
the elderly are very important for the wellbeing of the elderly. Cognitive activities
carried out regularly are thought to be able
to maintain excellent cognitive function in
the elderly. This needs to be proven by
examining differences in cognitive function
in groups of elderly who carry out cognitive
activities regularly and non-routinely. It is
believed that frequent cognitive exercises
might help the elderly maintain outstanding
cognitive function. This has to be
demonstrated by comparing cognitive
performance between groups of older
people who engage in cognitive activities
frequently and irregularly (5).
METHODS
Puzzle Therapy is a non-pharmacological
therapy to prevent decline in cognitive
function (6). The elderly can engage in
brain-training exercises with puzzle
therapy, which reassembles pictures that
have been broken into pieces, to improve
their capacity to think critically, develop
patience, and become accustomed to
sharing. Puzzle therapy is a cognitive
exercise that stimulates the brain by
providing adequate stimulation to maintain
and improve the brain's remaining
cognitive functions. The brain will work
when taking, processing, interpreting
The research design used a quasiexperimental design with a two-group
pre-test-post-test control group design
carried out for 3 weeks at Nursing Home
East Jakarta. Sample collection was based
on inclusion criteria. The elderly were
required to be conscious and peaceful, to
have mild to severe dementia, and to not be
receiving medical treatment., do not have
any hearing, vision, or communication
issues. The sample size used in this research
using the Lameshow formula obtained 24
respondents in each group. The sampling
technique used is a non-probability sample
using the sampling technique method in
this research using purposive sampling. In
this study, MMSE (Mini mental status
examination) questionnaire and Katz index
are used to assess elderly independence.
The intervention group had 9 sessions of
puzzle therapy over a three-week period,
with each session involving a re-assessment
of independence using the Katz index.
Frequency distributions and percentages
are used in univariate analysis, the tdependent test with a level of significance of
0.05 (CI 95%) is used in bivariate analysis,
and the Generalized Linear Model (GLM) is
used in multivariate analysis.
RESULT
Characteristics Of Respondents
The results of the research on the characteristics of respondents include age, gender and
independence of the elderly
Table 1. Distribution of respondent characteristics by age, gender, and level of
independence
Variable
Age
Gender
elderly
old age elderly
very old
females
male
https://doi.org/10.33755/jkk
Intervention f (%)
18 (75.0%)
6 (25,0%)
11 (45,8%)
13 (54.2%)
Control f (%)
14 (58.3%)
8(33.3%)
2 (8.3%)
12 (50%)
12 (50%)
This is an open access article under the CC BY-SA license
317
p-ISSN : 2354 8428 | e-ISSN: 2598 8727
Independence
Jurnal Keperawatan Komprehensif
Volume 10 Issue 2 April 2024
Full function
Moderate impairment
Severe functional
impairment
1 (4.2%)
20 (83.3%)
3 (12.5%)
1 (4.2%)
18 (75.0%)
5 (20.8%)
According to the table above, respondents in both the intervention group (75.0%) and the
control group (58.3%) had a majority of elderly. Males made up the majority (54.2%) o (...truncated)