Ecology and Conservation of Mountain Birds
Ornithology, 2024, 141, 1–2
https://doi.org/10.1093/ornithology/ukae017
Advance access publication 28 May 2024
Book Review
Book Review
Ecology and Conservation of Mountain Birds
Ecology and Conservation of Mountain Birds provides a comprehensive account of the research on our world’s montane
avifauna. The editors, Dan Chamberlain, Aleksi Lehikoinen,
and Kathy Martin, with a whopping 7 decades of combined
experience studying alpine birds, provide not only detailed
descriptions of mountain bird biology, but also present a
robust roadmap for future research on their ecology and
conservation. An impressive 52 authors from 24 countries
have contributed the 10 chapters in this book. Ecology and
Conservation of Mountain Birds is a definitive guide and essential starting point for anyone interested in birds on mountains.
In chapter 1, the editors, along with Davide Scridel, discuss
the foundational questions of what are mountains and what
are mountain birds? The editors largely focus on the biology
of birds that live at or above the treeline, but also acknowledge that most birds that live on mountains occur below the
treeline. Martin et al. then follow this chapter with an examination of the abiotic challenges species face at high elevations
and the adaptations birds possess to overcome them. We particularly enjoyed the extensive examples of adaptations from
species of various realms and habitats, such as box 2.2, which
highlights the largely underappreciated and under-studied
challenge of egg-shell morphology and embryonic development at high elevations. de Zwaan et al. then describe and
compare alpine habitats across the world (12 major regions)
in chapter 3. This chapter highlights that tropical mountains
are expectedly hyperdiverse, but temperate mountains, while
being species poor, do support substantial functional diversity. In chapter 4, Chamberlain et al. provide a convincing
account of the importance to treeline and alpine habitats.
Outside of the Andes the treeline ecotone is probably too
narrow for specialization and therefore these communities
seem to be intermediate between montane and alpine communities based on local conditions. Largely uncelebrated in montane bird research, the chapter’s emphasis on treeline ecotone
habitats is especially pertinent in this time of global change.
In chapter 5, Lehikoinen et al. use robust meta-analyses to
highlight population trends of mountain birds. While the best
information is provided from studies in Europe and North
America, table 5.2 provides an excellent resource that lists all
known long-term studies globally including those in South
America, Asia, and Africa.
James W. Pearce-Higgins and Kathy Martin next review
the literature that has considered how climate change is likely
to impact mountain birds at various spatio-temporal scales.
Given the speed at which climate change research is being
published, the authors have done a commendable job of
incorporating recent research. The authors also nicely highlight the context dependence that is important for predicting
the impact of climate change on birds. For example, how the
shape of the mountain may affect avian response to climate
change. In the following chapter, Caprio et al. systematically
Copyright © American Ornithological Society 2024. All rights reserved. For commercial re-use, please contact for reprints and
translation rights for reprints. All other permissions can be obtained through our RightsLink service via the Permissions link on the article page on our
site—for further information please contact .
by Dan Chamberlain, Aleksi Lehikoinen, and Kathy Martin, Editors. 2023. Cambridge University
Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom. 450 pp. $120.00 (hardcover). ISBN 9781108837194. $44.99
(paperback). ISBN 9781108940429. $44.99 (eBook). ISBN 9781108945684.
Book Reviews
2
From the natural history focused boxes in chapters 1 and 2 to
boxes that describe more complex concepts in later chapters,
like box 9.1 and figure B9.1, are striking examples of how
these boxes add tremendous value to each chapter and enhance the reading experience. There are also some very useful
tables with information that every mountain bird ecologist
seeks. Good examples are table 3.1, which highlights mountain bird diversity across the world broken up by geographic
region, and table 6.1, which synthesizes climate change driven
elevational range shifts documented from mountains across
the world. The figures are also informative and well-made especially working against the constraint of being in grayscale.
Each chapter covers a unique perspective and is a comprehensive review of the available literature. We feel this book is a
must-read for early-career researchers interested in mountain
birds. It will help situate their research within a broader perspective and will be an excellent source of new research ideas
and future directions.
Reviewed by Sahas Barve
and Tarun Menon
Sahas Barve
Avian Ecology Program, Archbold Biological Station,
Venus, Florida, USA
Tarun Menon
Centre for Ecological Sciences, Indian Institute for
Science, Bengaluru, India
Book Review Editor: Jay Mager,
review the anthropogenic threats that assail mountain birds.
A common pattern in mountain systems world over is the
movement away from agriculture and towards tourism resulting in a visible change in demography and land use. The
chapter discusses literature on a wide range of human impacts
including skiing, hiking, renewable energy, and the overall
build-up of tourist infrastructure. These two chapters are
particularly crucial in that they highlight the vulnerability of
mountain systems and the actions required to conserve them.
With improving computing power, species distribution models
(SDMs) have become a popular analytical tool for conservation scientists, and Brambilla et al. review the various biotic
and abiotic factors, and their interactions, which drive species distributions on topographically complex mountainous
landscapes in chapter 8. Jon Fjeldså and colleagues next delve
into descriptions of the phenomenal diversity and endemism
seen on tropical (and sub-tropical) mountains. In this chapter,
they examine how biogeography and evolutionary processes
have driven high rates of diversification in tropical mountains
leading to them being termed as cradles of biodiversity. With
the final chapter, the editors synthesize the knowledge from
the previous 9 chapters to produce 10 Knowledge Gaps and 7
Research Priorities that will help gain a more complete understanding of mountain bird biology and ensure their conservation. From this chapter, it becomes amply clear that a lot
more work needs to be done in simply documenting species
and their life histories from tropical mountains in the global
south. In addition, long-term monitoring programs and adaptive protected area networks come across as the underlying
need of the hour.
Overall, the book is an enjoyable read with notably accessible language. We esp (...truncated)