Boston children’s hospital and the origin of pediatric neurosurgery
Childs Nerv Syst
Boston children's hospital and the origin of pediatric neurosurgery
Alan R. Cohen
0 ) Department of Neurosurgery, Boston Children's Hospital, Franc D. Ingraham Professor of Neurosurgery, Harvard Medical School , 300 Longwood Avenue, Boston, MA 02115 , USA
The Department of Neurosurgery at Boston Children's Hospital (BCH) has had a rich and sustained tradition of excellence over the years. This review traces the history of neurosurgery at BCH and the seminal role the department has played in advancing the field of pediatric neurosurgery worldwide (Fig. 1).
-
The Peter Bent Brigham Hospital (PBBH) opened its doors in
1913. Peter Bent Brigham, a self-made millionaire,
restaurateur, railroad executive, and philanthropist, had left a $1.3
million bequest to establish a hospital to provide care for the
sick and indigent population of Suffolk County. The funds
were not to be used for 25 years after his death, and ultimately
went to the purchase of the Ebeneezer Francis estate, which
became the site not only of PBBH, but also Boston Childrens
Hospital (BCH) and Harvard Medical School (HMS),
institutions that have maintained their close geographic and medical
alliance to this day.
PBBH recruited Harvey Cushing, a young 44-year-old
graduate of Yale College and HMS who was working at Johns
Hopkins Hospital at the time, to be its inaugural
Surgeon-inChief. Cushing was also named the Moseley Professor of
Surgery at HMS. The opening of the Brigham was an historic
event, and Cushings friend and mentor from Hopkins, Sir
William Osler, traveled to Boston to join him for the
celebration.
Cushing had served his residency training at Hopkins
under William Stewart Halsted and remained on the faculty
there, where he focused on surgery of the central nervous
system and laid the foundation for the practice of neurological
surgery as we know it today. By the time Cushing was 32 years
old, he held the rank of Associate Professor of Surgery at
Hopkins.
When Cushing came to PBBH in 1913, he began operating
on children with neurosurgical disorders. The children would
come from BCH over to PBBH where Cushing would carry
out the surgery, and then be transferred back to BCH for their
postoperative care. By 1926, Cushing had operated on over
1,000 brain tumor patients, and more than 150 of them were
children under the age of 15. With great vision, he recognized
the need for a dedicated service to care for children with
surgical disorders of the nervous system.
In 1929, Cushing directed his disciple, Franc D. Ingraham, to
begin a Department of Neurosurgery at BCH. Thus began the
first pediatric neurosurgical service in the world.
Ingraham was a gifted technical surgeon and a shy, humble
man. He was born in Minneapolis, Minnesota in 1898 and
received his undergraduate training at Harvard, initially
showing an interest in philosophy and music. He went on to
graduate from HMS, where he had developed a fascination
with surgery of the central nervous system. Ingraham served
his surgical residency at PBBH, where he came under the
influence of Cushing. After spending a year with Cushing,
Ingraham went to Hopkins to work with Walter Dandy.
Cushing, who himself had spent a year studying in Europe before
joining the faculty at Hopkins, was a strong advocate for the
Wanderjahr, the precursor of todays traveling fellowship.
But Ingrahams trip to Baltimore was aborted early,
because Dandy and Cushing were at odds and Dandy would not
Fig. 1 (Figure 1 is also the cover illustration): Watercolor of the
Hunnewell Building, Boston Childrens Hospital, which opened in
1914 and still stands today. Artist: Mark Waitkus, commissioned by
Boston Childrens Hospital, 2006. Courtesy of the Archives Department,
Boston Childrens Hospital. On the cover (same illustration as Figure 1):
Watercolor of the Hunnewell Building, Boston Childrens Hospital,
which opened in 1914 and still stands today. The Department of
Neurosurgery is situated on the second floor of this building
allow Ingraham in the operating room. So Ingraham
subsequently went to Oxford as a Brigham Traveling Fellow to
work in the physiology laboratory of Sir Charles Sherrington.
In Sherringtons lab, he collaborated with John Farquhar
Fulton, who would later become the Sterling Professor of
Physiology at Yale, Cushings biographer and Ingrahams
brother-in-law through marriage to Lucia Wheatland, the
sister of Martha Wheatland, Ingrahams wife. Sherrington
commented that Ingraham was the finest technical surgeon
ever to work in his lab.
It was on his return to Boston from Oxford that Ingraham
founded the neurosurgery service at BCH, which quickly
gained respect nationally and internationally. Ingraham was
able to attract an assembly of talented neurosurgeons to train
with him, including Donald Matson, Eben Alexander, Edgar
Bering, Robert McLaurin, Bruce Hendrick, John Shillito,
Ernest Matthews, and Larry Page. Ingraham made substantial
contributions to pediatric neurosurgery with publications on
infantile subdural hematoma, craniosynostosis,
hydrocephalus, spina bifida, and brain tumors. In 1954, he and his
protg, Donald Darrow Matson, published the Neurosurgery
of Infancy and Childhood, which became the first pediatric
neurosurgery textbook in the world.
Although he shunned the spotlight, Ingraham served in
numerous leadership capacities throughout his career. From
1944 until his retirement in 1964, he was Chief of
Neurosurgery at Childrens and also Chief of the Adult Neurosurgical
Service at PBBH. He was a charter member of the Harvey
Cushing Society (later renamed the American Association of
Neurological Surgeons) and served as its president from
19441946. He was a director of the American Board of
Neurological Surgery and served on the Study Section of the
National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Blindness.
He was a member of the editorial board of the Journal of
Neurosurgery for 9 years.
On a personal note, Ingraham was an avid athlete who
enjoyed figure skating, horseback riding, and tennis. He loved
sailing and was often out at sea with family and friends,
including the Nobel laureate John Enders. Ingraham
frequently sailed with his neighbor, General George S. Patton, who
served as commander of the Seventh United States Army and
the Third United States Army in the European Theater during
World War II.
Ingraham suffered from serious illness throughout his life.
He developed severe bronchial asthma as a child and
underwent a radical paranasal sinus exenteration in Baltimore
in the early 1930s, just after beginning his academic career.
Because of this illness, he subsequently did no academic work
for 9 years. He also suffered from chronic recurrent back pain
related to a gymnastics injury as an undergraduate at Harvard
with an exacerbation years later when he fell off a horse.
Ingraham suffered a serious myocardial infarction in 1962
and retired in 1964. He died of a second myocardial infarction
in 1965 at the age of 67 years [1, 2 (...truncated)