Comparative transcript profiling of gene expression between seedless Ponkan mandarin and its seedy wild type during floral organ development by suppression subtractive hybridization and cDNA microarray

BMC Genomics Comparative transcript profiling of gene expression between seedless Ponkan mandarin and its seedy wild type during floral organ development by suppression subtractive hybridization and cDNA microarray Wen-Ming Qiu 0 An-Dan Zhu 0 Yao Wang 0 Li-Jun Chai 0 Xiao-Xia Ge 0 Xiu-Xin Deng 0 Wen-Wu Guo 0 0 Key Laboratory of Horticultural Plant Biology (Ministry of Education); National Key Laboratory of Crop Genetic Improvement, Huazhong Agricultural University , Wuhan 430070 , China Background: Seedlessness is an important agronomic trait for citrus, and male sterility (MS) is one main cause of seedless citrus fruit. However, the molecular mechanism of citrus seedlessness remained not well explored. Results: An integrative strategy combining suppression subtractive hybridization (SSH) library with cDNA microarray was employed to study the underlying mechanism of seedlessness of a Ponkan mandarin seedless mutant (Citrus reticulata Blanco). Screening with custom microarray, a total of 279 differentially expressed clones were identified, and 133 unigenes (43 contigs and 90 singletons) were obtained after sequencing. Gene Ontology (GO) distribution based on biological process suggested that the majority of differential genes are involved in metabolic process and respond to stimulus and regulation of biology process; based on molecular function they function as DNA/RNA binding or have catalytic activity and oxidoreductase activity. A gene encoding male sterility-like protein was highly up-regulated in the seedless mutant compared with the wild type, while several transcription factors (TFs) such as AP2/EREBP, MYB, WRKY, NAC and C2C2-GATA zinc-finger domain TFs were down-regulated. Conclusion: Our research highlighted some candidate pathways that participated in the citrus male gametophyte development and could be beneficial for seedless citrus breeding in the future. Citrus; cDNA microarray; Differential transcript; Male sterility-like protein; Seedlessness - Background Seedlessness is a desired fruit trait for consumers, and a fruit is considered to be seedless if it produces no seeds, traces of abortion seeds, or significant reduced-number of seeds [1]. Some plants can set seeds asexually through apomixis. However, in most flowering plants, seed initiation requires signals activated by the double fertilization event that occurs in the embryo sac, and seed is produced sexually from the fertilized ovule [2,3]. Various phytohormones such as gibberellins (GAs), auxins and cytokinins are involved in this signaling process [4-6]. GAs and jasmonic acid/jasmonate derivatives (JAs) were found to play crucial roles in plant reproductive development [7,8]. Citrus is one of the most important fruit crops with great economic and health value around the world [9]. However, some citrus varieties are seedy, and seedy fruits have constrained the development of fresh citrus market. Therefore, breeding seedless citrus varieties is a long-term pursuit for citrus breeders worldwide [10,11]. Nowadays, Satsuma mandarin and navel orange are two of the most famous and widely grown citrus varieties, mainly due to their seedless trait. For decades, great progress on seedless citrus breeding was made by traditional approaches such as sexual hybridization, seedling and bud sport mutation. However, due to the peculiarities of citrus reproductive biology such as long juvenile period and nucellar polyembryony, traditional breeding is inefficient and costly [12]. Modern biotechnological approaches (e.g. somatic hybridization) have potential to effectively expedite breeding process of citrus [13-15]. As most citrus varieties can produce fruits parthenocarpically [16], male or female sterility, embryo sac abortion, self-incompatibility, polyploidy and even environmental stress can result in seedless citrus fruits [17,18]. Actually there were some successful reports about seedless fruit production by genetic transformation. Ectopic expression of iaaH gene with DefH9 as promoter to elevate auxin levels in placenta or ovules resulted in seedless fruits [19,20]. Another effective strategy was by specific expression of toxin proteins during early development of plant reproductive organs. Typical cases were the ectopic transformation of the Barnase gene from Bacillus amyloliquefaciens [21,22]. Potential cases were by specific expression of enzymes such as chloroplast Chaperonin 21 and ubiquitin extension protein S27a to induce cell disruption of seed tissues for parthenocarpic plants [11,23,24]. And in our laboratory, the Arabidopsis thaliana MAC12.2 gene had been introduced into precocious trifoliate orange (Poncirus trifoliata [L.] Raf ) for production of potential seedless fruits [25]. Male sterility (MS) is one of the main causes for seedless fruit production in citrus. In recent years, great progress on MS was made with annual plants especially rice [26,27], Arabidopsis [28] and oil-rape [29], and a serial of genes regulated tapetum, anther and pollen development were identified. However, there remained very limited information on MS of perennial woody plants such as citrus. Ponkan mandarin (Citrus reticulata Blanco) is a widely grown citrus variety in China. Within this variety, many variants were derived through sexual hybridization and mutation such as bud sport mutation. Qianyang seedless Ponkan mandarin (QS) is an elite seedless variant selected from bud sport mutation of a common seedy Ponkan mandarin, and it can set fruits with no seeds (even no seed rudiments) in open orchard [30,31]. In this article, QS and a common seedy Ponkan mandarin Egan NO.1 (EG) were used for comparative study. These two mandarins shared highly close genetic relationship based on molecular marker analysis and showed no distinctly morphological differences except that QS was completely male sterile while Egan No 1 has normal flower. In order to gain general understanding on genes involved in this MS mutation, suppression subtractive hybridization (SSH) [32] combining with cDNA microarray was performed to detect differentially expressed genes. Several candidate genes and related pathways were focused in particular. Our research identified some useful genes which could be beneficial to citrus seedless breeding. The results could help to reveal the molecular mechanism of male sterility of Ponkan mandarin and shed light on seedless trait formation of other perennial woody plant at the gene expression level. Results Phenotype analysis of the floral organs of QS Previous studies suggested that the floral organs (actually the whole plant) of QS had no morphological difference from the wild type. To further validate the phenotype of this seedless Ponkan mandarin, we measured the length of filament and pistil, and the average ratio of filament to pistil (filament length/pistil length) was 0.83 0.01 for EG and 0.79 0.01 for QS. And for EG, the pistil was 0.155 0.01 cm longer than filament while for QS, the pistil was 0 (...truncated)