Probability of Error of Linearly Modulated Signals with Gaussian Cochannel Interference in Maximally Correlated Rayleigh Fading Channels
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
EURASIP Journal on Wireless Communications and Networking
Volume 2010, Article ID 193183, 13 pages
doi:10.1155/2010/193183
Research Article
Probability of Error of Linearly Modulated Signals with
Gaussian Cochannel Interference in Maximally Correlated
Rayleigh Fading Channels
Luca Rugini and Paolo Banelli
Department of Electronic and Information Engineering, University of Perugia, Via G. Duranti 93, 06125 Perugia, Italy
Correspondence should be addressed to Luca Rugini,
Received 30 November 2009; Revised 12 May 2010; Accepted 30 June 2010
Academic Editor: Guosen Yue
Copyright © 2010 L. Rugini and P. Banelli. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution
License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly
cited.
We evaluate the probability of error of linearly modulated signals, such as phase-shift keying (PSK) and quadrature amplitude
modulation (QAM), in the presence of Gaussian cochannel interference (CCI) and Rayleigh fading channels. Specifically, we
assume that the fading channel of the CCI is maximally correlated with the fading channel of the signal of interest (SOI). In
practical applications, the maximal correlation of the CCI channel with the SOI channel occurs when the CCI is generated at the
transmitter, such as the multiuser interference in downlink systems, or when a transparent repeater relays some thermal noise
together with the SOI. We analytically evaluate the error probability by using a series expansion of generalized hypergeometric
functions. A convenient truncation criterion is also discussed. The proposed theoretical approach favorably compares with
alternative approaches, such as numerical integration and Monte Carlo estimation. Among the various applications of the
proposed analysis, we illustrate the effect of nonlinear amplifiers in orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing (OFDM)
systems, the downlink reception of code-division multiple-access (CDMA) signals, and the outdoor-to-indoor relaying of Global
Positioning System (GPS) signals.
1. Introduction
Thermal noise, fading channels, and cochannel interference
(CCI) are among the main sources of performance degradation in wireless communication systems. For fading channels, the theoretical evaluation of the system performance
has been extensively explored in the technical literature
(see [1, 2], and the references therein), mainly in terms
of symbol-error probability, equivalently known as symbolerror rate (SER), and of bit-error probability, also called
bit-error rate (BER). In the last decades, the BER analysis
has been extended to include the presence of faded CCI.
Krishnamurthi and Gupta have investigated the BER of
QPSK and 8-PSK when the signal of interest (SOI) and a
single interferer are affected by independent Rayleigh fading
channels [3]. Beaulieu and Abu-Dayya have evaluated the
BER of QPSK when the SOI is subject to Nakagami fading
and the interferer is affected by Rayleigh fading [4]. The BER
analysis in Nakagami fading channels has been subsequently
extended by Aalo and Zhang to multiple interferers, whose
CCI can be modeled as Gaussian, under the assumption that
the SOI employs differential PSK [5]. The BER of BPSKmodulated SOI with multiple CCI subject to Rayleigh fading
has been studied also in the presence of multiple receive
antennas [6–8].
The common feature of all the mentioned research studies is that the fading experienced by the CCI is independent
of the fading experienced by the SOI. However, in many
practical scenarios, the fading channel of the CCI and the
fading channel of the SOI are highly correlated [9, 10].
In some important cases, this correlation is at maximum
level, for example, when both the SOI and the CCI are
subject to the same fading channel. For instance, this scenario
happens when the CCI is generated at the transmitter,
such as the multiuser interference in code-division multipleaccess (CDMA) downlink systems [11]. Other examples of
2
EURASIP Journal on Wireless Communications and Networking
transmitter-generated CCI include the nonlinear distortion
caused by the high-power amplifier in orthogonal frequencydivision multiplexing (OFDM) systems [12, 13], and the
thermal noise produced by the front-end of a transparent
transponder that relays Global Positioning System (GPS)
signals from outdoor to an indoor receiver [14]. In all these
scenarios, the CCI is well modeled by a Gaussian random
variable. Despite the nonnegligible number of scenarios of
interest, there have been few theoretical studies about the
BER performance in the presence of CCI that is subject to the
same fading channel of the SOI. Recently, Beaulieu and his
coworkers have analyzed the BER performance when the SOI
and the CCI experience correlated Rayleigh fading, assuming
multiple receive antennas and maximal ratio combining [15,
16]. However, the analysis of [15, 16] is valid only for BPSKmodulated SOI, and for multiple interferers that use BPSK;
therefore, the obtained results are not valid when the CCI is
Gaussian.
In this paper, we develop a SER analysis for linear
modulations in Rayleigh fading channels, when the CCI
is modeled as Gaussian at the decision variable. The
proposed analysis can be employed in order to predict the
maximum amount of interference that can be tolerated
at the receiver, given a fixed performance requirement.
We focus on maximally correlated fading channels, that
is, we assume that the CCI is subject to the same fading
channel that affects the SOI. Specifically, we analytically
assess the error probability by using a series expansion of
generalized hypergeometric functions [17]. Different aspects
of the proposed formula are considered, such as, alternative
expressions, series truncation criterion, BER with Gray
coding, and effect of phase errors. We compare the proposed
analysis with two alternative approaches, that is, numerical
and statistical. The numerical approach uses Laguerre-Gauss
quadrature [18] to evaluate the SER expressed as a single
integral of a real variable. The statistical approach estimates
the SER by means of a Monte Carlo method that shares many
similarities with semianalytic evaluation [19]. We show that
the proposed theoretical method enjoys a better accuracy
with respect to both numerical and statistical methods, and
that our theoretical results can accurately predict the SER
performance in many different scenarios. Specifically, we
focus on three applications: OFDM systems subject to highpower amplifier nonlinearities, CDMA detectors impaired
by multiuser interference in downlink transmissions, and
GPS receivers aided by outdoor-to-indoor relays. However,
our analysis is quite general, since it can be applied to any
communication system that is impaired by Gaussian CCI
generated at the transmitter, when the channel experiences
Rayleigh fading. Note that for some particular cases, the CCI
gene (...truncated)