Novel Precoded Relay-Assisted Algorithm for Cellular Systems
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
EURASIP Journal on Wireless Communications and Networking
Volume 2010, Article ID 414657, 10 pages
doi:10.1155/2010/414657
Research Article
Novel Precoded Relay-Assisted Algorithm for Cellular Systems
Sara Teodoro, Adão Silva, João M. Gil, and Atı́lio Gameiro
Instituto de Telecomunicações, Universidade de Aveiro, 3810-193 Aveiro, Portugal
Correspondence should be addressed to Sara Teodoro,
Received 14 July 2010; Accepted 11 November 2010
Academic Editor: Richard Kozick
Copyright © 2010 Sara Teodoro et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License,
which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Cooperative schemes are promising solutions for cellular wireless systems to improve system fairness, extend coverage and increase
capacity. The use of relays is of significant interest to allow radio access in situations where a direct path is not available or has poor
quality. A data precoded relay-assisted scheme is proposed for a system cooperating with 2 relays, each equipped with either a
single antenna or 2-antenna array. However, because of the half-duplex constraint at the relays, relaying-assisted transmission
would require the use of a higher order constellation than in the case when a continuous link is available from the BS to the UT.
This would imply a penalty in the power efficiency. The simple precoding scheme proposed exploits the relation between QPSK
and 16-QAM, by alternately transmitting through the 2 relays, achieving full diversity, while significantly reducing power penalty.
Analysis of the pairwise error probability of the proposed algorithm with a single antenna in each relay is derived and confirmed
with numerical results. We show the performance improvements of the precoded scheme, relatively to equivalent distributed SFBC
scheme employing 16-QAM, for several channel quality scenarios.
1. Introduction
Multiple-input, multiple-output (MIMO) wireless communications are effective in mitigating channel fading, thus
improving the cellular system capacity [1]. However, there
is significant correlation between channels in some environments, and using an antenna array at the user terminal
(UT) may not be feasible due to size, cost, and hardware
limitations. Cooperative systems are promising solutions for
wireless systems to overcome such limitations, when the
direct link does not have good transmission conditions [2].
It can be achieved through cooperation of terminals (either
dedicated or user terminals acting as relays), which share
their antennas and thereby create a virtual antenna array
(VAA) or a virtual MIMO (VMIMO) system [3]. These
allow single antenna devices to benefit from spatial diversity
without the need for colocated additional physical antenna
arrays.
Several cooperative diversity protocols have been proposed and analysed to demonstrate the potential benefits of cooperation [4, 5]. In [6], a theoretical diversitymultiplexing trade-off study is presented regarding a cooperative system with 1 and 2 antennas in a single-relay
scheme. Furthermore, in [7] the Rayleigh performance of
a single-relay cooperative scenario with multiple-antenna
nodes is investigated, deriving pairwise error probability
(PEP) expressions. In order to get higher diversity orders,
one can also consider the use of multiple-relay nodes
[8]. However, increasing the number of relays reduces the
bandwidth efficiency of the system, as the source uses only a
fraction of the total available degrees of freedom to transmit
the information.
In [9], the idea of space-time coding devised for pointto-point colocated multiple antenna systems is applied
for a wireless relay network with single antenna nodes
and PEP of such a scheme is derived. The authors show
that in a relay network with a single source, a single
destination with R single antenna relays, distributed spacetime coding (DSTC) asymptotically approaches the diversity
of a colocated multiple antenna system with R transmit
antennas and one receiving antenna. More recently, in [10],
distributed orthogonal space-time block codes (DOSTBCs)
achieving single-symbol decodability have been introduced
for cooperative networks. The authors considered a special
class of these codes (row monomial DOSTBCs), deriving
upper-bounds on the maximum symbol-rate. In [11], singlesymbol decodable (SSD) DSTBCs have been studied when
the relay nodes are assumed to know the corresponding
2
EURASIP Journal on Wireless Communications and Networking
channel phase information. An upper bound on the symbol
rate for such a set up is shown to be one half of the rate
of the direct link transmission when this link is available,
which is independent of the number of relays. In [12], a
semi-orthogonal precoded DSTBC was proposed, wherein
the source performs precoding on the information symbols
before transmitting it to all the relays. Several relays are
considered all equipped with a single antenna. A systematic
construction of these codes is presented for more than 3
relays and the constructed codes are shown to have higher
rates than those of DOSTBCs. Although achieving full
diversity, these distributed orthogonal algorithms cannot
achieve full spectral efficiency, since they use 2 phases for
transmission. For this reason, these cooperative systems
achieve half of the bandwidth efficiency of the equivalent
non-cooperative systems.
Other works were developed with the objective of
increasing capacity or diversity order of cooperative systems,
using non-orthogonal protocols for cooperative systems with
2 or more relays, as in [13, 14]. In [13] a generalised
non-orthogonal amplify-and-forward protocol is proposed
with a low decoder complexity, achieving better error
performances than in [9], depending on the coding. In [14]
coding strategies are studied for non-orthogonal cooperative
channels, using one or more designed space-time precoders,
in a protocol where inter-relay communication is allowed,
but again having no full spectral efficiency. In these nonorthogonal algorithms, transmission via an existing direct
path is required. Thus, in situations with poor direct link
conditions, performance is significantly degraded and in case
of outage of one relay some information can be lost.
Further along the development of cooperative systems,
some relay precoder designs were also proposed, however
with different goals [15, 16]. In [15], the precoder maximizes
the capacity between the source and destination nodes in
a non-regenerative relay system, with a single relay node,
considering all the nodes with multiple antennas. In [16],
MIMO relay provides robustness against imperfect channel
state information (CSI), for a multipoint-to-multipoint
communication through the use of a relay precoder design.
Our previous work included a distributed spacefrequency block coding (SFBC) scheme, designed for orthogonal frequency-d (...truncated)