Topological insights in polynuclear Ni/Na coordination clusters derived from a schiff base ligand
Struct Chem (2016) 27:1703–1714
DOI 10.1007/s11224-016-0797-7
ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Topological insights in polynuclear Ni/Na coordination clusters
derived from a schiff base ligand
Kieran Griffiths1 • Albert Escuer2
•
George E. Kostakis1,3
Received: 30 April 2016 / Accepted: 9 June 2016 / Published online: 9 August 2016
Ó The Author(s) 2016. This article is published with open access at Springerlink.com
Abstract This article presents the syntheses, crystal
structures, topological features and magnetic properties of
two NiII/NaI coordination clusters formulated [NiII3
Na(L1)3(HL1)(MeOH)2] (1) and [NiII6 Na(L1)5(CO3)(MeO)
(MeOH)3(H2O)3]4(MeOH) 2(H2O) [2 4(MeOH) 2(H2O)]
where H2L1 is the semi-rigid Schiff base ligand (E)-2(2-hydroxy-3-methoxybenzylideneamino)-phenol). Compound
1 possesses a rare NiII3 NaI cubane (3M4-1) topology, and
compound 2 is the first example in polynuclear Ni/Na
chemistry that exhibits a 2,3,4M7-1 topology.
Keywords Coordination cluster Nickel Sodium
Topology Schiff base Ferromagnetism Carbonate ion
This work is dedicated to Prof Vladimir Ya. Shevcehnko on the
occasion of his 75th birthday.
Electronic supplementary material The online version of this
article (doi:10.1007/s11224-016-0797-7) contains supplementary
material, which is available to authorized users.
& George E. Kostakis
Albert Escuer
1
Department of Chemistry School of Life Sciences, University
of Sussex, Brighton BN1 9QJ, UK
2
Departament de Quı́mica Inorgànica i Orgànica Secció de
Quı́mica Inorgànica and Institut de Nanociència i
Nanotecnologia (IN2UB), Universitat de Barcelona Martı́ i
Franquès 1-11, 08028 Barcelona, Spain
3
Science and Educational Center of Physics of
Noneqiliubrium Open Systems, Samara, National Research
University, Moskovskoye Shosse 34, Samara 443086, Russia
Introduction and review
One of the most complex categories of coordination compounds are polynuclear coordination clusters (CCs) that
incorporate multiple metal ions into a single molecular
entity and are linked by bridging ligands [1]. These entities
are of great interest for their aesthetically beautiful structures [2–4], unexpected transformations [5–7] and potential
applications in magnetism [8–10], luminescence [11–15],
catalysis [16–18], etc. Paramagnetic transition metal CCs
are of intense interest and have attracted a vast amount of
attention since the discovery that some CCs behave as
single-molecule magnets (SMMs) [19–21]. The NiII (d8)
ion has second-order orbital angular momentum, and zerofield splitting (ZFS) which can result in significant singleion anisotropy and potentially in molecules exhibiting
interesting magnetic properties [22, 23]. The interest in
polynuclear Ni(II) coordination chemistry was first captured when the first Ni(II)-based SMM, a Ni12 complex,
was reported in 2001 by Cadiou et al. [24]. Ever since,
there have been a number of homometallic polynuclear NiII
CCs with high nuclearities including, Ni5 [7, 25], Ni6 [26],
Ni7 [27, 28], Ni8 [29–32], Ni9 [33, 34], Ni11 [35], Ni12 [7],
Ni13 [36], Ni14 [37], Ni20 [38], Ni21 [39], Ni24 [40] and Ni26
[41], and many of these display interesting magnetic
properties including ferromagnetic, ferrimagnetic coupling,
diamagnetism and SMM behaviour.
Clusters of this size incorporate simple modified ligands
with a wide variety of coordination modes for bridging,
such as diethanolamine [42], Schiff base [43], carbide
[44, 45] and carboxylate [46]. The introduction of bridging
groups can increase the nuclearity of a CC. Carbonate
anions offer a diverse range of bridging modes within
cluster type molecules. A number of high-nuclearity CCs
have been based on carbonate moieties [47, 48]. While
123
1704
Ni(II) CCs with bridging carbonate ligands are known,
structural factors and magnetic exchange within these
clusters greatly vary due to the large number of coordination modes of the CO32- anion [39, 49, 50]. Some interesting examples include, a Ni6 containing a carbonato
bridge [51] and an Ni12 where four Ni4O4 units are templated around a central CO32- anion core [52]. On the
other hand, the first reported mixed NiII/NaII CC was
reported in 1976 by Jonas for potential small-molecule
activation [53]. Since then, a number of NiII/NaII CCs have
been reported, targeting for high-nuclearity clusters and
interesting magnetic properties: Ni4Na2 [54], Ni4Na5 [55],
Ni4Na3 [56], Ni4Na4 [57, 58] and others [59–62]. However,
since 2007, NiII/NaI CCs with nuclearity over 10 have been
reported far more frequently. The highest reported of these
is a Ni18Na6 cluster [63] and the second Ni16Na4 [64], both
synthesised by calix [4] arene-type ligands and the third is
a Ni16Na2 cluster. In addition, two Ni12Na2 clusters were
reported by Christou et al. [37, 65]. In all cases, similar
anti-ferromagnetic behaviour was observed.
The diprotic Schiff base ligand (E)-2-(2-hydroxy-3methoxybenzylideneamino)-phenol (H2L1, Scheme 1) initially reported in 1971 to capturing UO2 [66] can be synthesised in almost quantitative yields [67] and has two
pockets that can coordinate to metal centres. Previously,
this ligand has been involved in the synthesis of
homometallic [68–71] and heterometallic CCs [72–75]. We
recently employed this ligand in 3d/4f chemistry to synthesise a family of homogeneous efficient catalysts towards
a domino reaction [76]. Interestingly, when H2L1 was
employed in Ni(II) chemistry, a tetranuclear Ni4 CC
exhibiting ferromagnetic interactions at low temperatures
was isolated. [71] With the interest of introducing carbonate anions into a system, there are three key methods:
direct addition of carbonate or bicarbonate [14], atmospheric fixation of carbon dioxide [77] and in situ
decomposition of ligands [78].
Having all these in mind, in this article, we study the
influence of the presence of Na cations and CO32- anions on
the nuclearity of the given chemical system Ni(II)/H2L1 and
we report two compounds formulated [NiII3 Na(L1)3(HL1)(MeOH)2] (1) and [NiII6 NaI(L1)5(CO3)(MeO)(MeOH)3
Struct Chem (2016) 27:1703–1714
(H2O)3]4(MeOH) 2(H2O) [2 4(MeOH) 2(H2O)]. Topological
aspects and magnetic properties of these compounds are further discussed.
Experimental
Materials
Chemicals (reagent grade) were purchased from SigmaAldrich and Alfa Aesar. All experiments were performed
under aerobic conditions using materials and solvents as
received.
Instrumentation
IR spectra of the samples were recorded over the range of
4000–650 cm-1 on a Perkin-Elmer Spectrum One FT-IR
spectrometer fitted with a UATR polarization accessory.
X-ray diffraction
Crystallography
Data for 1 and 24(MeOH) were collected at the National
Crystallography Service, University of Southampton [79]
using a Rigaku Saturn 724? area detector mounted at the
window of an FR-E? rotating anode generator with a Mo
anode (k = 0.71075 Å) under a flow of nitrogen gas at
150(2) K for 1 and 100(2) K for 24(MeOH). Both
structures were determined using Olex2 [80], solved using
eithe (...truncated)