Advances in Clinical Neuroimaging
Advances in Clinical Neuroimaging
Joseph I. Tracy1, PhD, ABPP/CN; Gaelle Doucet2, PhD; Xaiosong He2, PhD;
Dorian Pustina2, PhD; Karol Osipowicz2, PhD
1
Department of Radiology, Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia PA
Department of Neurology, Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia PA
1,2
A paradigm shift has occurred in Neuroscience, with most brain diseases, even those
considered focal, now viewed as having repercussions throughout the whole brain. As one
might suspect these brain networks effects are quite complex, so multiple neuroimaging
techniques are needed to view them.
Structural magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is used to determine the health of brain
tissue, particularly in the cortex. Resting-state functional connectivity (rs-fMRI) is used to
identify cortical regions communicating with each other. Diffusion imaging can verify that
any two regions are, indeed, anatomically connected through white mater fibers. Lastly,
functional MRI can be used to define the specific cognitive information and processes
the regions and networks may be communicating about. Data from all four imaging
technologies can be gathered during one MRI scanning session with a minimal increase
in scanning time and no increase in patient discomfort.
A key goal of our laboratory has been to create individual brain maps of cognitive functions
that may be negatively affected by invasive brain treatments such as thermal ablation, brain
stimulation, or resective brain surgery. Neurologic disease often leads to alterations in how
and where the brain stores cognitive skills and behaviors. In some cases, changes in how
the brain stores information can be so complete that the regional network implementing
a function (e.g., expressive language) can be entirely discordant with established theories
about the brain localization of function (e.g., Broca’s, Wernicke’s in the right not the left
hemisphere; see Figure 1b). An accurate map of where in the brain key cognitive functions
are located can help avoid removal of intact, functional tissue, and guide access routes
so the surgeon can reach and remove the pathology. Such brain maps also save the
neurosurgeon time because they can more rapidly identify the location of functional areas
near the diseased or pathologic tissue that needs to be removed.
The important functions frequently mapped out include speech, receptive language,
primary motor and sensory regions (Figures 2 and 3), and memory functions (Figure 4).
Techniques, however, are being developed to map out emotion processing, problem
solving, abstract thinking, planning/organization and behavioral control. Since the pathways connecting brain regions are as important to successful cognition as the regions
themselves, diffusion tensor imaging provides a crucial roadmap of pathways to avoid
during brain surgery, if at all possible. For instance, Figure 5 shows a diffusion image
constructed to help avoid visual pathways in an epilepsy patient undergoing surgery for
an epileptic region near the brain centers for vision. Likewise, Figure 6 shows the white
matter pathways that help perform voluntary movements in a patient with a frontal tumor
near the brain areas for movement. Lastly, Figure 7 shows the white matter tract (green) in
an epilepsy patient connecting the two key brain areas involved in language.
Our laboratory has led advances in brain mapping, particularly in the area of resting state
functional connectivity as applied to epilepsy (Tracy and Doucet, 2015; Tracy, 2015).
Techniques such as rs-fMRI can be particularly useful in mapping out function in patients
who may not be able to understand or cooperate with the instructions or demands of
a standard fMRI task. Figure 8 displays the results of the first study to utilize functional
connectivity to develop a method for identifying which hemisphere is most important for
language, a method that does not require the patient to actually complete a language task
(Doucet at al., 2014). We also produced the first resting state study to show that connections from the ictal (seizure) to the non-ictal (healthy) hemisphere work to control and
44
JHN JOURNAL
confine seizures to a more limited region in
the brain through inhibitory mechanisms
generated by the healthy hemisphere (see
Figure 9; Tracy et al., 2014).
An important clinical goal is the development of imaging tests that might tell us
whether an individual is at risk for disease,
or if a patient about to undergo surgery is
likely to experience a good outcome. This
predictive ability will require, however,
an understanding of the principles that
govern adaptive responses in the brain
and lead to the restoring of lost cognitive
functions. With this in mind, we developed
a conceptual framework for integrating
multiple imaging modalities toward the
goal of identifying the brain regions
involved in change (neuroplasticity) and
network reorganization following brain
injury (Figure 10; Tracy & Osipowicz,
2011). The combined power of several
imaging modalities can be used to predict
outcomes prior to undergoing procedures
such as brain surgery for epilepsy. For
instance, Figure 11 shows how the combination of multiple imaging modalities
was able to distinguish poor versus good
outcome patients (i.e., those achieving
seizure freedom), with diffusion tensor
imaging serving as the best predictor
(see Figure 11; Osipowicz et al., 2015).
Currently, our lab is developing quantitative imaging algorithms for predicting such
important clinical outcomes. As a start, we
completed a recent study demonstrating
the utility of a quantitative algorithm for
determining from which side of the brain
(hemisphere) an epilepsy patient’s seizures
might be coming (Pustina et al., 2015).
This work has the potential to alter clinical
practice by providing justification for
including multiple imaging methods into
decision-making algorithms for brain
surgery. The hope is to eventually develop
imaging tests (biomarkers) that will be
available on a presurgical basis to help
predict the probability of surgical success,
which will help both patients and their
treating doctors decide on the appropriateness and risk of brain surgery.
Clinical Neuroimaging
A
Figure 1
A. FMRI activation sites
for a verb generation and sentence
completion task in an
epilepsy patient with
intractable temporal
lobe epilepsy. The
pattern of activation in
the left hemisphere (see
arrows pointing to key
language sites, Broca’s
and Wernicke’s areas)
reflects left hemisphere
language dominance.
B. Activation for the
same two tasks, in a
different temporal lobe
epilepsy patient. This
pattern reveals atypical
regions of activation,
reflecting right hemisphere dominance for
language.B
B
Verb Generation
Sentence Completion
Left Hand Motor
Right Hand Motor
Figure 2
FMRI activation in the normal brain locations associated with left and right hand motor movements.
JHN JOURNAL
45
VisualSpatial
SpatialMemory
Memory
Visual
Figure 4
FMRI activat (...truncated)