This House which I have built: The Foundation of the Brattle Street Church in Boston and Transformations in Colonial Congregationalism

Volume 10 Article 4 2011 This House which I have built: The Foundation of the Brattle Street Church in Boston and Transformations in Colonial Congregationalism Cara Elliott Gettysburg College Class of 2011 Follow this and additional works at: https://cupola.gettysburg.edu/ghj Part of the American Studies Commons, History Commons, and the Religion Commons Share feedback about the accessibility of this item. Elliott, Cara (2011) "This House which I have built: The Foundation of the Brattle Street Church in Boston and Transformations in Colonial Congregationalism," The Gettysburg Historical Journal: Vol. 10 , Article 4. Available at: https://cupola.gettysburg.edu/ghj/vol10/iss1/4 This open access article is brought to you by The Cupola: Scholarship at Gettysburg College. It has been accepted for inclusion by an authorized administrator of The Cupola. For more information, please contact . This House which I have built: The Foundation of the Brattle Street Church in Boston and Transformations in Colonial Congregationalism Abstract On December 24, 1699, a small gathering of men and women met "for public Worship in [their] pleasant newbuilt house," a simple wooden structure in Brattle Close, a section of Boston near the town dock. The newly appointed Reverend Benjamin Colman preached from Chronicles 2, chapter vi, verse 18, "But will God in very deed dwell with men on the earth? Behold, heaven, and the heaven of heavens, cannot contain thee; how much less this house which I have built." This first public meeting of the Brattle Street Church occurred amidst a heated theological debate among New England Congregational clergymen, which began a year earlier when the foundation of the church had first been conceived. Brattle Street‘s foundation was in reaction to theological, political, and cultural transformations that affected the whole of New England in the latter half of the seventeenth century, all of which converged in the 1690s. While the foundation of Brattle Street Church did not make any radical departures from contemporary theological consensus, its foundation did represent the first concrete fragmentation of a theretofore unified New England Congregational community. In this sense, the foundation of the Brattle Street Church is representative of a radical development in the evolution of colonial Congregationalism. Keywords Boston, Brattle Street Church, colonial congregationalism This article is available in The Gettysburg Historical Journal: https://cupola.gettysburg.edu/ghj/vol10/iss1/4 This House which I have built: The Foundation of the Brattle Street Church in Boston and Transformations in Colonial Congregationalism Cara Elliott ―Their high object was to found a new Christian Congregational church, upon the broad, catholic, but conservative principles of Congregationalism – a church in which a just liberty and privilege should be allowed to all, and nothing imposed on any individual.‖ 1 On December 24, 1699, a small gathering of men and women met ―for public Worship in [their] pleasant new-built house,‖ a simple wooden structure in Brattle Close, a section of Boston near the town dock.2 The newly appointed Reverend 1 Samuel Kirkland Lothrop, ―Sermon One, December 30, 1849,‖ A History of the Church in Brattle Street, Boston (Boston: WM. Crosby and H.P. Nichols, 1851), 16. 2 Benjamin Colman, ―Records of the Church in Brattle Square: Dr. Colman‘s Ministry, Lord‘s day, Decem. 24,‖ in The Manifesto Church: Records of the Church in Brattle Square, Boston: With Lists of Communicants, Baptisms, Marriages, and Funerals, 1699-1872, eds. Ellis Loring Motte, Henry Fitch Jenks, and John Homans II (Boston: The Benevolent Fraternity of Churches, 1902), 5; 72 Benjamin Colman preached from Chronicles 2, chapter vi, verse 18, ―But will God in very deed dwell with men on the earth? Behold, heaven, and the heaven of heavens, cannot contain thee; how much less this house which I have built.‖3 This first public meeting of the Brattle Street Church occurred amidst a heated theological debate among New England Congregational clergymen, which began a year earlier when the foundation of the church had first been conceived. Brattle Street‘s foundation was in reaction to theological, political, and cultural transformations that affected the whole of New England in the latter half of the seventeenth Samuel Adams Drake, Old Landmarks and Historic Personages of Boston (Boston: James R. Osgood and Company, 1873), 122; Thomas Brattle, Benjamin Davis, John Mico, Thomas Cooper, and John Colman to Benjamin Colman, May 10, 1699, in Samuel Kirkland Lothrop, A History of the Church in Brattle Street, Boston (Boston: WM. Crosby and H.P. Nichols, 1851), 45. 3 Colman, ―Lord‘s day, Decem. 24,‖ in Records of the Church in Brattle Square, 5. 73 century, all of which converged in the 1690s. While the foundation of Brattle Street Church did not make any radical departures from contemporary theological consensus, its foundation did represent the first concrete fragmentation of a theretofore unified New England Congregational community.4 In this sense, the foundation of the Brattle Street Church is representative of a radical development in the evolution of colonial Congregationalism. Brattle Street Church‘s foundation was not a random occurrence. There were a number of developments that caused its founders to establish a 4 Rick Kennedy, ―Thomas Brattle, MathematicianArchitect in the Transition of the New England Mind, 16901700,‖ Winterthur Portfolio 24, no. 4 (Winter 1989): 237 and 241 suggests that the ―liberalism‖ of the Brattle Street founders, namely the mathematician-merchant Thomas Brattle, has been exaggerated by the historical community. This assertion is correct when viewing the founders from a strictly theological or philosophical perspective. However, it oversimplifies the contemporary contextualization of the church‘s foundation. 74 new congregation, beginning with the Congregational Synod of 1662 and the adoption of the ―Half-Way‖ covenant. The decision was made in hopes of reversing flagging church membership and loss of piety characteristic of the 1650s, in which the church saw the Congregational Way – John Winthrop‘s original ―City upon a Hill‖ churchstate observing the sovereign law of Sola Scriptura, or scripture alone, – slipping through their fingers.5 As Patricia Bonomi notes, the clergy ―ever wary of complacency, were prepared to reform church practices . . . in ways that would command the continuing allegiance of New Englanders to the 5 John Winthrop, ―A Modell of Christian Charity,‖ in Francis J. Bremer, John Winthrop: America’s Forgotten Founding Father (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003), 179; Harry S. Stout, The New England Soul: Preaching and Religious Culture in Colonial New England (New York: Oxford University Press, 1986), 59. 75 Congregational Way.‖6 First suggested by Richard Mather, a prominent Puritan clergyman at this time, the covenant ex (...truncated)