DIGEST OF CASES REPORTED IN 1922

REPORTS OF PATENT, DESIGN, TRADE MARK, AND (Published under-Section 46 of the Patents and Designs Act, 1907.) EDITOR: FRANK G. UNDERHA~, M.A., BARRISTER-AT-LAW. VOL. XXXIX. TOGETHER WITH A DIGEST OF. CASES REPORTED IN 1922. LONDON PRINTED BY HIS MAJESTY'S STATIONERY O}'FIUE PRESS, 11-17, HARE STREET, E.2. PUBLISHED Al' THE PATENT OFFICE, 25, SOUTHAMPTON BUILDINGS, CHANCERY "LANE, W.C.2. 1922. OTHER CASES. ii REPORTS OF PArrENT, DESIGN, AND TRADE MARK CASES. [Vol. XXXIX. NO'l'ICE.-ERRATA. Note.-The Patent Office does not guarantee the accuracy of its publications, or undertake any responsibility for errors or omissions or their consequences. .The London cases in this volume were (with a few exceptions) reported by J. F. McARTHUR, J. Q. HENRIQUES, and J. H. EVANs-JACKSON, Barristers-atLaw ; the Reporter for cases in the Palatine Court is C. E. R. ABBOTT, Barrister-at-Law; and the Reporter for Scotch cases is J. KEITH, Advocate. The Judgments are taken from the shorthand notes of Messrs. MARTEN, ]\lEREDITH~ & CO. ERRATA. Page 28, line 18. For " No. 22,55-1" read" 29,554." Page 36, line ~8. Ajter" L. B. Sebastian" insert" and C. E. R. Abbott." Page 38, line 11. For" with" read" within." Page 98.. line 21. For" Applicants" read " Opponents." Pages 140 to 143. For" Howarth" read" Howatt" throughout. Page 147, line 18. For" 1918 " read 'It 1913." Page 195, line 4, For " Bloxham" read H Bloxam." Page :112, line 47. For" Now" read It6 New." Page 349, line 11. For" Register " read ,. Registrar." App. p. vii, line 2t5. For " passible " read" possible." NOTICE. iit Vol. XXXIX.] REPORTS OF PATENT, DESIGN, AND TRADE MARK CASES. CASES REPORTED. PAGB. AKTIENGESELLSCHAFT FUR AUTOGENE ALUMINIUM SCHWEISSUNG v. J... ONDON ALUMINIUM Co. LD. (No.2) ... .•. 296 146 AUSTIN MOTOR CO. LD. AND AUSTIN'S PATENT-IN THE MATTER OF 294 BENNET'S PATENT-IN THE MATTER OF 447 195 ARMSTRONG'S ApPLICATION FOR A PATENT-IN THE MATTER OF .•. BLOXAM u. KEE-LESS CLOCK CO. BRITISH THOMSON-HoUSTON CO. LD. v. B.T.T. ELECTRIC LA.MP AND ACCESSORIES CO. BRITISH THOMSON-HoUSTON CO, & CO. •.• LD. V. 167 CHARLESWORTH, PEEBLES 391, 399 49 BRITISH THOMSON-HoUSTON CO. LD. V. CORONA LAMP WORKS LD.•_ BRITISH THOMSON-HoUSTON Co. LD.. (No.2)... ... v. CORONA. LAMP' WORKS LD. LD. V. KING & CO. CO. LD. v. NAA.MLOOZE BRITISH THOMSON-HoUSTON POPE'S METAALDRAADLAMPENFABRIEK 212 391,399 BRITISH THOMSON-HoUSTON CO. VENNOOTSCHAP COLUMBIA GRAPHOPHONE CO. LD. V. MURRAY 391 34:1 24:3 33 389 239 BRUCE'S ApPLICATION FOR A PATENT-IN THE }\iATTER OF ..• CLORIU8 V. TONNER COHEN'S TRADE MARK-IN THE MATTER OF COLEMAN'::s PATENT-IN .THE MATTER OF ••• CRIGHTON'S PATENT-IN THE MATTER OF 2:'~ DUNCAN AND PIERPONT'S PA'J'ENTS-IN THE MATTER OF 311 DUNHILL v. BARTLETT & BICKLEY ... 426 EGG PRODUCTS LD.-IN THE MATTER OF AN ApPLICATION BY, FOR REGISTRATION OF A TRADE MARK FULL AGAR'S PATENTS-IN THE MATTER OF GEDYE & SONS LD;-[N THE MATTER OF AN ApPLICATION BY, ~'OR THE REGISTRATION OF A TRADE MARK 155 421 HIGGINSON & ARUNDEL V. BENTLEY & BENTLEY LD. 377 406 444 177 HOWARTH'S PATENT-IN THE MATTER OF 14:0 GREERS LD. V. PEARMAN & CORDER LD. •.• GRESLEy'SPATEST-IN THE MATTER OF ... 131 HUNT'S PATENTS-IN THE MATTER OF ISOLA LD. - IN THE MATTER OF REGISTRATION OF A TRADE MARK AN ApPLICATION BY, FOR 1.71 A2 CASES REPORTED. iv REPORTS' OF PATENT, DESIGN, AND TRADE MARK CASES. [Vol. XXXIX. CASES REPORTED. PAGE 419 JONES' PATENT-IN THE MATTER OF 1 :135 KING (THE) V. COMPTROLLER-GENERAL OF PATENTS (EX PARTE MUNTZ) M.'s ApPLICATION FOR A PATENT ••• MUMM (G. H.) & CO.-IN THE MATTER OF AY A.PPLICATION BY ... NESTLE (0.) & CO. LD. v. EUGENE LD. OSBORNE & NIELD (DREW'S ApPLICATION BY PATENT)-IN THE ~IATTER OF 261 379 38 AN SIMPSON, ROBERTS & Co. Ln.-IN THE MATTER OF THE ApPLIOATION BY, FOR THE REGISTRATION OF A TRADE MARK SMITH'S PATENTs-IN THE MATTER OF SOCIlilTE ()HIMIQUE MATTER OF .•• DES USINES DU RHONE'S PATENT-IN THE 143 372 313 27 SOC1ETE VINICOLE DE CHAMPAGNE-IN THE MATTER OF AN 4~PPLICArl'ION BY i~79 SUMMERS BROWN'S PATENT-IN THE MATTER OF 367 SUMMERS BROWN'S PATENT (No. 2).-;..I~ THE MATTER OF 445 TOMKINSON AND ADAM'S ApPLICATION 283 DCAR'S P1TENT-IN THE MATTER OF 269 UNION NATIONALE INTER-SYNDIC ALE DES MARQUES COLLECTIVESIN THE MATTER OF AN ApPLIOATION BY, TO REGr~TER TRADE MARKS .•• 97, 346 W., K. J., AND W. LD.-ApPLICATION FOR PATENTS BY WALKER & SQNS LD. r. KEGO (No.2) WALLACE v. TULLIS RUSSELL & COMPANY LD. ... WELDRICS Ln. v. QUASI-ARC Co. LD. WILLESDEN VARNISH Co. Lo. v. YOUNG & MARTEN, LD. WILSON v. CHALCO Ln. YOUNGS' PATENT-IN THE MATTER OF OFFICIAL RULINGS (see Nos. 6 & 11) 26:1 277 3 323 285 252 364 ApPEKDIX JOHNSON ANlJ TITLEY'S PATENTS-IN THE MATTER OF ... v Vol. XXXIX. ] REPORTS OF PATENT, DESIGN, AND TRADE MARK CASES. LIST OF DEFENDANTS IN CASES. PAGE BARTLETT & BICKLEy-DUNHILL v. BENTLEY & BENTLEY LD.-HIGGINSON B.T.T. 426 177 & ARUNDEL v. ELECTRIC LAMP ANI-, ACCESSORIES COMPANy-BRITISH THOMSON- HOUSTON C01\-IPANY LD. 167 v, CHALCO LD.-V,rILSON V. ... 2:52 CHARLESWORTH PEEBLES & CO.-BRITISH THOMSOM-HoUSTON CO. LD. v. 391, 399 COMPTROLLER-GENERAL OP PATENTS (EX PARTE MUNTZ)-THE KING V. ... 335 (No. 2)-BRITI$H THOMSON-HOUSTON CO. LD. v. 212 CORONA LAMP WORKS LD.--BRITISH THOMSON-HOUSTON CO. LD. v. CORONA LAMP WORKS LD 49 EUGENE LD.-NESTLE (C) & CO. LD. V. ••. 38 K.EE~-LESS CLOCK CO.-BLOXAM v. 19'5 KEGO (No. 2)-WALKER & SONS LD. V. ••. 277 KING & CO.---:BRITISH THOMSON-HOUSTON CO. LD. v. 391,' 399 LONDON ALUMINIVM CO. Ln. (No. 2)-AKTIENGESELLSCHAFT FUR AUTOGONE . A.LUMINIUM SCHWISSUNG v. MURRAy-COLUMBIA GRAPHOPHONE CO. LD. V. •.. 296 239 NAAMLOOZE VENNOOTSCHAP POPE'S METAALDRAADLAMPENFABRIEK-BRITISH THOMSON-HOUSTON CO. LD. v. PEARMAN & CORDER LD.-GREERS LD. v. QUASI-ARC CO. LD.-WELDRICS LD. v. v. 'TULLIS RUHSELL & COMPANY LD.-WALLACE V. TONNER-CLORIUS YOUNG & MARTEN Ln.-WILLESDEN VARNISH CO. LD. 391 406 323 243 3 285 LIST OF DEFENDANTS IN CASES. vi REPORTS OF PATENT" DESIGN, AND TRADE MARK CASES. [Vol. XXXIX'~ PATENTS UPHELD OR HELD INVALID . . ' -*t Patents held valid. Applicationfor revocation refused. Patents held invalid. o Application for extension refused, 00 Patents extended. :)I: OOAUSTIN l\fOTOR ANOTHER) ... Co. LD. OOBE,NNET *B~ITISH THOMSON-HoUSTON LD.... *BRITISH Ln. THOMSON-HoUSTON tCLORIUS OOCOLEMAN OOCRIGHTON oODREW OODUNCAN AND PIERPONT tELISON t ELISON OOFULLAGAR ••• OOGRESLEY ••• *HIGGINSON AND ARUNDEL ... OOHOWATT (see Errata) OOHUNT (AND ANOTHER) PATENTS UPHELD, OR HELD INVALID; OR REVOKED, OR REVOCATION REFUSED; OR EXTENDED, OR NOT EXTENDED. vii Vol. XXXIX.] REPORTS OF PATENT, DESIGN, AND TRADE MARK CASES. PATENTS UPHELD OR HELD INVALID. 0JOHNSON PAGE & TITLEY oOJOHNSON & TITLEY OORENARD *SCHOOP OOSMITH oOSOCIETE CHEMIQUE (AND OTHERS) DU OOSUMMERS BROWN .. " oOSUMMERS BR6WN **UCAR t W A~LACE (AND OTHERS) OOYOUNGS RHONE No. 29554 of (...truncated)