DIGEST OF THE CASES REPORTED IN 1908

REPORTS OF PATENT, DESIGN, TRADE MARK, AND OTHER CASES. EDITOR: JOHN CUr-fLER, ASSISTANT EDITOR: ONE OF HIS MAJESTY'S COUNSEL. FRANK G. UNDERHAY, BARRISTER-AT-LAW. VOL. XXV. TOGETHER WITH A .DIGEST OF CASES REPORTED IN 1908. II~LUS'l'RATED OFFICIAlj JOURNAlj (PATENTS). LO'NDON~ PRINTED FOR HIS ~IAJESTY'S STATIONERY OFFIOE 1 By DARLING & SON, LTD., 34-40, BACON STREET, E. PUBJ~ISHED AT THE PATENT OFFICE, 25, SOUTHAMPTON BUILDINGS, CHANCERY LANE, LONDON, W.O. 1908, (Published under Section 46 01 the Patents and Designs Act, 1907.) NOTICE. "I'he London-Cases in this volume were (with a few exceptions) reportedby the ASSISTAN'f EDITOR,. and J. F. McARTHUR, C. H. CARDEN NOAD, R. E. V. BAX, J. Q. HENRIQUES, and A.D. ',JAFFE, Barristers-at-Law. The Reporter for the Cases in the Palatine Court is C. E. R. ABBOTT, Advocate : and the Reporter for Irish Cases is HENRY HOLT, Barristerat-Law. . The Judgments are taken from the Shorthand Notes of Messrs. MAR'I~EN, CO. MEREDITH & ERRATA. Page 18, line 26, for " mosiac " read " mosaic." " 120, " II,for 7 Webs P.O. 196 read 1 Webs P.O. 167. " 156, " 10, for 1882· read 1884. " 199 " 36, for 22 read 23. " 227, Add f(Jotnote~"'It wasagreed by theparties tothe actions that, in the above Drawing, the arrow showing the direction of theJlow between t and p ought to point upwards." •••• z. ..... _ " 230, line 47, for "Canadian" read "French." " "lines 54 and 55, insert a minus sign before 1820 and before 195°. " 232, line 44, for "French" tread " Canadian." " 233 " 18, delete "of " after " cold." " 260 " 5, f01" 22 read 32. " 297 " 21, for 20 read 30. " 344 " 9, for " Paterson " read" Patterson." " 427 " 36, Insert in blank «pace "426, line 4a." 23, for 5 read 6. , " 470 " " 526 ".' 25, for 485 read 585. " 553 " 663 " ". 5, for " Petition " read "Patent." 53, delete comma after " was,' Barrister-at-Law; the Reporter for Scotch Cases is GEORGE D. VALENTINE, CA.BE S REP 0 RTED. * Denotes a Patent Case. t Denotes a Design Case. IN THE MATTER OF ApPLICATIONS FOR TRADE MARKS BY *ALSOP FLOUR PROCESS LD. u. 513 477 FLOUR OXIDIZING COMPANY J~D: 477 #ANDREWS' PATENT-IN THE MATTER OF *ARNOT v. DUNLOP PNEUMATIC TYRE COMPANY tBAYER u. SYMINGTON-IN THE MATTER OF BAYER'S DESIGN J.JD. ... 309 56 #BESTON V. VVATTS 19 532 *BOARD'S PATEN'I'-IN THE MATTER OF ..• VALADON & BOUSSOD, u. tBOUSTEAD CO. v. DEMPSTER, MOORE & CO. *BRITISH LIQUID AIR COMPANY LD. Ln. *BRITISH 42 MARCHANT v. LD. 121 BRITISH OXYGEN COMPANY ... ORE ... 218,577 CONCENTRATION SYNDICATE LD. v. MINERALS 741 SEPARATION LD. *BRITISH UNITED SHOE l\fACHINERY COMPANY & SONS lAD. *BRITI~H V ACUUM COMPANY Ln. u. FUSSELL (A.) •••368, 631 Ln. u. EXTON HOTELS COMPANY LD. *BROCKIE'S ApPI~ICATIONS FOR PATENTs-IN THE l\IATTER OF ~~BRO'VN'S PATENT (No. 1434· OF 1899)-IN THE MATTER OF *CONSOLIDATED PNEUMATIC TOOL COMPANY V. CLARK 617 813 86 574 *CONSOLIDATED PNEUMATIC TOOL C01\-IPANY V. INGERSOLL SERGEAN'r DRILL OOMPA.NY 574 PAGE ALBERT BAKER & CO. (1898) AND AERATED BREAD COMPANY LD.- 4 *CRAIG PAGE 1, 259 u. DOWDING ••• 421 #DANSK REICYLRIFFEL SYNDICAT AKTIESELSKAB V. SNELL .•• *DAVIES v. ~~EDISONIA LD. v. u. BRITISH ELECTROMOBILE COM.. 149 .•. v, WILLIAMS (BIRMINGHAM) LD. ~~FLOUR OXIDIZING COMPANY LD. *FODEN u. v. 511 428 CARR & CO. LD. ... 501,783 WALLIS AND STEVENS LD. *FRIED. KRUPP ACTIENGESELLBCHAFT-IN THE MATTER OF AN ApPLICATION FOR A PATENT BY 809 GESTETNER'S TRADE MARK-IN RE 156 *GILLETTE SAFETY RAZOR CO~iPANY LD. *HARRISON PATENTS COMPANY LD. v. ~f:HAY GAMAGE LD. ... 192,782 NICHOLSON (W. N.) & SONsLD. ~f:HART'S PATENT-IN THE MATTER OF *HASKELL GOLF BALL COMPANY LD. v. 299 .•• u. HUTCHISON (No.2) 194 v. GONVILLE HENNESSY & CO. 161 ... 125,361 v. KEATING *INGERSOLL SERGEANT DRILL COMPANY V. CONSOLIDATED PNEU- 61 MATIC TOOL COMPANY LD. *INTERNATIONAIJ HARVESTER COMPAN"Y' OF AMERICA JEFFERSON DODD LD. #KELVIN 'v. WHYTE, THOMSON & CO. v. R. A. V. u. DODD'S DRUG STORES LD.... *JOHNSON'S PATENT-IN THE MATTER OF KERFOOT 393 COOPER LD. PEACOCK 765 16 391,542,709 177 508 #KERSHAW'S PATENT--IN THE l\IATTER OF 473 KLABER'S PATENT-IN THE l\IATTER OF 334 PANY LD. 546 FORSE ~~ELECTROMOBILE COMPANY LD. tFETTES 823 DAVIES PATENT BOILER COMPANY LD. PAGE I{ODAK LD. v, ~~LEEDS;FORGE COMPANY LD. PANY I.,D. 416 GRENVILI.JE ..• o, DEIGHTON'S PATENT FLUE COM- 209 •.. v. ~~LINOTYPE AND 1\IACHINERY LD. ~~LYNCH & HENRY \VILSON & CO. LD. v. JOHN PHILLIPS ApPLICATION FOR MARK-IN THE MATTER OF & COY~... 694 ...207,684 ... REGISTRArrION OF A rrRADE 797 ... FRANKLIN & SON... 406 ~;t-MARKS' PATENT-IN THE MATTER OF .•• 553 lVIA.JOR BRO'J;HERS v. *MARTIN AND JAMES v. 27 OONSETT IRON COMPANY LD. NATIONAL SrrARCH OOMPANY-IN THE MATTER OF AN ApPLICATION FOR REGISTRATION OF A TRADE MARK (" OSWEGO ") NITEDALS T-LENDSTIKFABRIK PAI~E v. R. LEHMANN & 00. LD. ... & Co. LD.-IN THE MATTER OF THE TRA.DE MARKS OF PETERS LD. (C. A.) v. 802 793 329 387 DOMESTIC INVENTIONS COMPANY PHILIPPART V. WILLIAM WHITELEY IJD.; AND PHILIPPART'S TRADE MARK-IN THE MATTER OF ~~POULTON 5fl5 ... V. ADJUSTABLE COVER AND BOIL'ER BLOCK COMPANY .•. 808 RESARTUS COMPANY V SARTOR RESARTUS COMPANY REY v. LECOUTURIER; AND LECOUTURIER'S TRADE MARKS-IN THE 265 MATTER OF *RICKERBY ~~ROGER ROYAL v. v. DUNCA.N (JAMES) & COCHRANE & INSURANCE 529,661 248 CO. 00. COMPANY 9, 757 LD. v. MIDLAND INSURANCE 728 COMPANY LD. ROYAL WARRANT HOLDERS' ASSOCIATION V. SLADE & CO. LD. SCOTTISH UNION AND NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY 245 v. SC01'TISH NATIONA.L INSURANCE COMPANY LD. 560 tST. lVIUNGO MANUFACTURING COMPANY v. HUTCHISON, MAIN & COMPANY LD. 356 ~ICCULLOOH'S PATENT-IN THE MATTER OF ~~MCGLENNON'S ... 34~, 665 HOPKINS PAGE *STONE & CO. LD. v. TOMS AND MOORE v. 313 BROADFOOT & SONS LD. ••• 474 MERCHANT SER"VICE GUILD LD. TRACTION CORPORATION LD. v. 819 BENNETT ·l'RUE AND VARIABLE ELECTRIC LAMP SYNDICATE u. BRYANT ULLMANN (J.} & CO. v. LEUBA 673 UNION AGRICOLA SOCIEDAD ANONIMA'S rrRADE l\IARKS-IN THE 295 MATTER OF v. MASON, CA'l'TLEY & CO. 37 ~{:VJ.~.UTIN'S PATENT-IN THE }\IATTER OF 176 ~~VICKERS, SONS AND l\1AXIM LD. V. COVENTRY ORDNANCE WORKS LD. 207 VAN ZELLER *WATSON, LAIDLO'V tWHITELOCK v. & OOMPANY LD. V. CASSELS & WILLIAMSON ..• AUTOMATIC PHOXOGRAPII COMPANY... *Wl'fHAJ\{ BROS. LD. V. OATLO\V, l\:IARSDEN, AND DUNN *V{ULLASTON AND I{NOWLES v. CHAPMAN 337 615 788 733 461 TRADING SYNDICATE LIST OF DEFENDANTS IN ACTIONS. PAGE ADJUSTABLE COVER AND BOILER BLOCK COMPANY-POULTON v. ... 529,661 ATED PNEUMATIC TOOL COMPANY Ln. v, 61 ,AUTOMATIC PHONOGRAPH COMPANY-WHITELOCK V. ••• 615 BElNNETT-TRAcrION CORPORATION LD.· u. 819 BRITISH ELECTROMOBILE COMPANY LD.-ELECTROMOBILE COMPANY 149 { Ln.. u. BRITISH OXYGEN CO}IPANY LD. LD.-BRITISH LIQUID AIR COMPA (...truncated)