Does treating depression improve cognitive functioning in depressed patients with multiple sclerosis?
713
Abstracts /Archives of Clinical Neuropsychologv I.5 (2000) 653-850
other measures. The findings suggest that despite the appeal of quick scoring methods for the ROCF,
BQSS qualitative ratings hold better promise in evaluating patients with epilepsy.
Does treating depression improve cognitive
multiple sclerosis?
Cox DS, Mohr DC, Epstein L.
functioning
in depressed patients with
Participants
were relapsing
MS patients (N=63)
enrolled in a depression
treatment
study
(females = 46; mean age = 43.9, SD = 9.98, Ambulation Index = 2.57, range O-9). Patients completed
a neuropsychological
screening battery at baseline and post-treatment (16 weeks) which included the
HDRS, BDI, Digit Span, Symbol Digit, 7-24, Animal Naming, COWAT, Stroop, RAVLT, and 15
Item BNT.
Patients’ scores on the RAVLT-Delayed Recall declined significantly over the 16 week treatment
period (t = 2.37, p = 0.021). There were also significant increases between patients’ scores from Animal
Naming to Grocery Naming, and from the CFL Trial of the COWAT to the PBW Trial. Because the
forms were not counterbalanced at pre- and post-treatment administration, these changes are difficult
to interpret. However, the lack of consistency in the direction of change suggests these changes are due
to random error.
To test the hypothesis that treatment of depression can result in improvement in neuropsychological
function, slopes analyses were performed. For the sample as a whole, improved patient performance
on Symbol Digit Backward correlated with reduced depression (r=0.382, p= 0.006) as measured by
the BDI. This relationship is due to the patients who demonstrated a 50% reduction in HRSD scores
(n= 15, r= 0.503, p = 0.047) and does not hold when these patients are excluded from analyses.
Improved patient performance on Trials l-5 of the RAVLT negatively correlated with improvements
in depression on the BDI at post-test (r = - 0.338, p = 0.019) for the sample as a whole. Factor analysis
of the neuropsychological
measures reveals a 4-factor solution, with RAVLT Trials l-5 loading on the
Attention factor. This improvement in performance on Trials l-5 on the RAVLT may reflect a learning
effect, although other studies have suggested that expected learning effects are not found in patients
with MS (Rao, 1986; Rao et al., 1994) However, patients’ performance on measures of memory,
learning, simple verbal language did not demonstrate learning effects. Patient performance on all tasks
was mildly impaired (around - 1 SD), as is consistent with past research on cognitive functioning in
MS (Ryan et al., 1996; Tsolaki, 1994; Franklin et al., 1988). The finding that patient performance on
moderately complex tasks of verbal attention may be further impaired by depression and may improve
with successful treatment of depression is consistent with some findings (Amett, 1999). However, the
lack of consistency in the direction of our findings is more consistent with past research suggesting that
cognitive deficits in MS are not impacted by co-morbid depression (DeLuca et al., 1995; Amato, 1995;
Moller et al., 1994).
Specific neuroanatomic lesion locations
multiple sclerosis
Cox D, Mohr DC, Epstein L, Huang L.
related to impaired
cognitive
performance
in
Participants
were relapsing
MS patients (N= 31) enrolled in a depression
treatment
study
(females = 23; mean age = 43.6, SD = 9.8, EDSS = 2.9, range O-6). Magnetic resonance imaging
(MRI) studies were completed on all patients. Regions of T-2 hyperintensity
corresponding
to
(...truncated)