Assessment of Feasibility to Use Computer Aided Texture Analysis Based Tool for Parametric Images of Suspicious Lesions in DCE-MR Mammography
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
Computational and Mathematical Methods in Medicine
Volume 2013, Article ID 872676, 6 pages
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2013/872676
Research Article
Assessment of Feasibility to Use Computer Aided
Texture Analysis Based Tool for Parametric Images of
Suspicious Lesions in DCE-MR Mammography
Mehmet Cemil Kale,1 John David Fleig,2 and NazJm Emal1
1
2
Bilecik Şeyh Edebali University, Turkey
Franklin University, OH, USA
Correspondence should be addressed to Mehmet Cemil Kale;
Received 2 October 2012; Accepted 6 March 2013
Academic Editor: Anke Meyer-Baese
Copyright © 2013 Mehmet Cemil Kale et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution
License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly
cited.
Our aim was to analyze the feasibility of computer aided malignant tumor detection using the traditional texture analysis applied
on two-compartment-based parameter pseudoimages of dynamic contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance (DCE-MR) breast image
data. A major contribution of this research will be the through-plane assessment capability. Texture analysis was performed on
two-compartment-based pseudo images of DCE-MRI datasets of breast data of eight subjects. The resulting texture parameter
pseudo images were inputted to a feedforward neural network classification system which uses the manual segmentations of a
primary radiologist as a gold standard, and each voxel was assigned as malignant or nonmalignant. The classification results were
compared with the lesions manually segmented by a second radiologist. Results show that the mean true positive fraction (TPF)
and false positive fraction (FPF) performance of the classifier vs. primary radiologist is statistically as good as the mean TPF and
FPF performance of the second radiologist vs. primary radiologist with a confidence interval of 95% using a one-sample 𝑡-test with
𝛼 = 0.05. In the experiment implemented on all of the eight subjects, all malignant tumors marked by the primary radiologist were
classified to be malignant by the computer classifier. Our results have shown that neural network classification using the textural
parameters for automated screening of two-compartment-based parameter pseudo images of DCE-MRI as input data can be a
supportive tool for the radiologists in the preassessment stage to show the possible cancerous regions and in the postassessment
stage to review the segmentations especially in analyzing complex DCE-MRI cases.
1. Introduction
Dynamic contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging
(DCE-MRI) has become an important imaging approach
for the evaluation of microcirculation in tumors [1]. It is
becoming a capable noninvasive method to monitor tumor
response to therapies; however, current practice requires
radiologists to manually identify and segment tumors from
the imaging data. Frequently used methods of identifying
tumors on DCE-MR images are based on pseudoimages of
parameters obtained by locally fitting time-intensity curves
to a two compartment exchange model for contrast agent
concentration [2] or use the three time point method [3].
These approaches are very tedious, time consuming, and
prone to intra- and interobserver variation.
Texture analysis has been applied in medical imaging
for several applications. Tourassi described the role of image
texture analysis in the medical imaging field [4]. Lerski
et al. used texture analysis on MRI for tissue characterization and segmentation of brain tissues [5]. Kovalev et al.
implemented a method for object recognition and matching
with multidimensional cooccurrence matrix calculations [6–
8]. Gibbs and Turnbull used a cooccurrence-based texture
tool on postcontrast MR breast images, showing that there is a
difference in terms of the spatial variations in voxel intensities
between benign and malignant lesions [9].
Neural networks are widely used for image classification [10]. Some examples of neural network classification on MRI prior to our method are briefly presented
here. Vergnaghi et al. used an artificial neural network
2
to automatically classify the enhancement curves as benign or
malignant [11]. Lucht et al. described a voxel-by-voxel neural
network classifier which compared the performance of quantitative methods for the characterization of signal-time curves
acquired by DCE-MR mammography [12–14]. Tzacheva et al.
implemented a region-based neural network classifier which
segments malignant tissues using a static postcontrast T1weighted image as input [15]. Szabó et al. implemented
an artificial-neural-network- (ANN-) based segmentation
method for DCE-MRI of the breast and compared it with
quantitative and empirical parameter mapping techniques to
test the discriminative ability of kinetic, morphologic, and
combined MR features [16, 17]. Twellmann et al. introduced
a model-free neural network classifier where he suggested
that an improvement could likely be achieved using texture
features [18].
We present a computer aided diagnostic (CAD) tool
based on statistical texture voxel-by-voxel analysis of pseudoimages generated by the local curve fitting of parameters
from a two compartment exchange model. The texture processing is based on statistical methods originally presented by
Haralick et al. [19]. The CAD tool we describe in this paper
is a texture-based classifier which uses two-compartmentbased DCE-MRI breast datasets. Compared to the studies
of Gibbs and Turnbull, the work reported here focuses on
the parameter pseudoimages derived from curve fitting of
the two-compartment model from the original MRI dataset.
Classification of the outcome images by the texture-based
analysis tool is obtained using an artificial neural network
trained with data marked by a radiologist.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Data Acquisition. The two-compartment model for contrast agent exchange is the basis for the work presented
here [20]. In this model, the primary compartment represents intravascular space, with extravascular (extracellular)
space as the secondary compartment. Typically the twocompartment model is characterized by the following parameters. The first-order rate constant for transfer from the
primary (vascular) compartment to the secondary (extravascular, extracellular) is 𝑘pe . The rate constant in the reverse
direction is 𝑘ep . Injection flow rate for the contrast agent is
𝑘in , and the first-order rate constant for elimination of the
contrast agent from the primary compartment is 𝑘el . The peak
intensity reached for a given voxel during the time course of
the DCE-MRI acquisition is 𝐴.
To identify voxels representing malignant tissues, radiologists rely on the property that microvessels in malignant
tissues are more frequent and porous than normal. This
difference is represented in the local parametric values of
𝐴, 𝑘ep , and 𝑘el , which are used by the reader to mark voxels
and regions as mali (...truncated)