Microcephaly is associated with early adverse neurologic outcomes in hypoplastic left heart syndrome
nature publishing group
Clinical Investigation
Articles
Microcephaly is associated with early adverse neurologic
outcomes in hypoplastic left heart syndrome
Patrick T. Hangge1, James F. Cnota1, Jessica G. Woo2, Andrea C. Hinton3, Allison A. Divanovic1, Peter B. Manning4,
Richard F. Ittenbach2 and Robert B. Hinton1
Background: Hypoplastic left heart syndrome (HLHS)
is associated with significant mortality and morbidity. Fetal
head growth abnormalities have been identified in a subset
of HLHS fetuses, but it is unclear whether specific patterns of
maladaptive growth affect clinical outcomes. We hypothesized
that poor fetal head growth is associated with an increased
frequency of adverse clinical outcomes.
Methods: We retrospectively examined a cohort of HLHS
patients from midgestation to 1 y of age. Fetal and birth
anthropometric measurements were analyzed using the Olsen
standard, and clinical outcomes were obtained.
Results: A total of 104 HLHS patients were identified over
a 12-y period; fetal data were available in 38 cases. HLHS neonates demonstrated a high incidence of microcephaly (12%),
small head size (27%), and poor head growth (32%). Allcause mortality was 31% at 30 d and 43% at 1 y. Neurologic
outcomes were observed in 12% of patients and were significantly increased with microcephaly (43 vs. 4%; P = 0.02). The
average length of hospital stay following stage I palliation was
33.4 ± 33 d, correcting for early death.
Conclusion: In term nonsyndromic HLHS, fetal and neonatal microcephaly are associated with early adverse neurologic
outcomes but not mortality.
H
ypoplastic left heart syndrome (HLHS) is a complex cardiovascular malformation (CVM) strictly defined as atresia or stenosis of the aortic and mitral valves and hypoplasia of
the left ventricle and ascending aorta (1). HLHS is uniformly
fatal without a series of palliative reconstructive surgeries in
the first years of life. Despite dramatic improvements in treatment, HLHS continues to be associated with significant mortality and morbidities (2–4), including short- and long-term
central nervous system (CNS) abnormalities (5–7). In addition, there is a rapidly growing population of adult survivors
with chronic morbidities that are only now beginning to be
understood (8). Although some surgical risk factors have been
identified, such as the presence of a genetic syndrome, low
birth weight (LBW, <2.5 kg), or a prohibitively small ascending
aorta, our ability to predict adverse clinical outcomes remains
limited (4,9,10). Understanding the noncardiac parameters of
fetal HLHS may lead to the identification of new risk factors
that may ultimately improve clinical management.
Impaired postnatal growth is commonly associated with
many types of CVM, including HLHS, and has been attributed to disruption of normal feeding behavior in the neonatal period. Postoperative failure to thrive is common, often
requiring gastrostomy (G)-tube placement (11). Poor growth
has been associated with genetic and environmental factors,
but the prevailing view identifies a hypermetabolic state and
malabsorption as common causes (11,12). However, increasing evidence shows that growth abnormalities begin before
birth (11–13), suggesting the contribution of other necessary
genetic and environmental factors. The majority of HLHS cases
are now diagnosed in utero, contributing to increased survival, and are not typically associated with fetal demise (9,14).
Given the complexity of development and growth in general,
it remains unclear why some HLHS fetuses and infants have
growth abnormalities and others do not.
Late CNS outcomes have been observed in stage III surgical survivors at school age, including learning disabilities,
attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder, fine and gross motor
abnormalities, and speech and behavioral problems (2,15). The
prevailing view is that chronic cyanosis and multiple cardiopulmonary bypass surgeries early in life lead to cognitive, motor,
and behavioral deficits later in life (6,16). However, recent
studies have implicated additional factors in the relationship
between CNS abnormalities identified in neonates after birth
but before surgery (17,18). Furthermore, early CNS abnormalities, including agenesis of the corpus callosum, as well as
holoprosencephaly and microcephaly, have been identified in
approximately one-quarter of HLHS neonates (5,15). Recently,
we described poor fetal head growth and white matter injury
despite normal brain weight in HLHS, identifying a spectrum
of fetal CNS pathology (19). It is unknown whether these fetal
head growth abnormalities are associated with adverse clinical
outcomes.
In this study, we examined fetal head growth and clinical outcomes in HLHS. There is an emerging interest in fetal
Division of Cardiology, The Heart Institute, Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center, Cincinnati, Ohio; 2Division of Biostatistics and Epidemiology, Cincinnati Children’s
ospital Medical Center, Cincinnati, Ohio; 3Division of Maternal Fetal Medicine, Good Samaritan Hospital, Cincinnati, Ohio; 4Division of Cardiothoracic Surgery, The Heart
H
Institute, Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center, Cincinnati, Ohio. Correspondence: Robert B. Hinton ()
1
Received 28 June 2012; accepted 13 December 2012; advance online publication 15 May 2013. doi:10.1038/pr.2013.61
Volume 74 | Number 1 | July 2013 Pediatric Research
61
Articles
Hangge et al.
growth in the context of CVM, but its relationship to clinical course is largely unknown. We hypothesized that poor
fetal head growth would be associated with an increased frequency of early adverse clinical outcomes. In term nonsyndromic HLHS, fetal and neonatal microcephaly is associated
Table 1. Fetal and neonatal anthropometrics by timing of diagnosis
All patients
Fetal
Neonatal
104
42
62
69 (66)
26 (62)
43 (69)
Aortic atresia/mitral
atresia (n, %)
51 (55)
27 (64)
24 (48)
Aortic atresia/mitral
stenosis (n, %)
21 (23)
5 (12)
16 (32)
Aortic stenosis/mitral
stenosis (n, %)
20 (22)
10 (24)
10 (20)
N
General characteristics
Male sex (n, %)
Newborn HLHS phenotype
Fetal characteristics
EGA (wk)
26.6 ± 5.0
NA
Fetal weight (g)
1,211 ± 783
NA
61 ± 29
NA
SGA (weight ≤ 10th
percentile)
3 (9%)
NA
Fetal HC (mm)
242 ± 47
NA
Fetal HC percentile
46 ± 29
NA
Fetal microcephaly
(HC ≤ 3rd percentile)
3 (8%)
NA
Fetal small head
(HC ≤ 10th percentile)
5 (13%)
NA
Fetal weight percentile
with early adverse neurologic outcomes but not with mortality or other clinical outcomes. A better understanding of fetal
growth, especially fetal head growth, may improve long-term
risk stratification and counseling for late outcomes in HLHS
and other CVM patients.
RESULTS
Study Population
A total of 157 HLHS patients were identified at Cincinnati
Children’s Hospital Medical Center over the 12-y period.
Among the 104 patients who qualified for the study, there were
42 fetal diagnoses and anthropom (...truncated)