Electro-optic spatial light modulator from an engineered organic layer
ARTICLE
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-26035-y
OPEN
Electro-optic spatial light modulator from an
engineered organic layer
1234567890():,;
Ileana-Cristina Benea-Chelmus 1 ✉, Maryna L. Meretska
Larry R. Dalton 2 & Federico Capasso 1 ✉
1, Delwin L. Elder
2, Michele Tamagnone
1,
Tailored nanostructures provide at-will control over the properties of light, with applications in
imaging and spectroscopy. Active photonics can further open new avenues in remote monitoring,
virtual or augmented reality and time-resolved sensing. Nanomaterials with χ(2) nonlinearities
achieve highest switching speeds. Current demonstrations typically require a trade-off: they either
rely on traditional χ(2) materials, which have low non-linearities, or on application-specific quantum
well heterostructures that exhibit a high χ(2) in a narrow band. Here, we show that a thin film of
organic electro-optic molecules JRD1 in polymethylmethacrylate combines desired merits for
active free-space optics: broadband record-high nonlinearity (10-100 times higher than traditional
materials at wavelengths 1100-1600 nm), a custom-tailored nonlinear tensor at the nanoscale, and
engineered optical and electronic responses. We demonstrate a tuning of optical resonances by
Δλ = 11 nm at DC voltages and a modulation of the transmitted intensity up to 40%, at speeds up
to 50 MHz. We realize 2 × 2 single- and 1 × 5 multi-color spatial light modulators. We demonstrate their potential for imaging and remote sensing. The compatibility with compact laser diodes,
the achieved millimeter size and the low power consumption are further key features for laser
ranging or reconfigurable optics.
1 Harvard John A. Paulson School of Engineering and Applied Sciences, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA, USA. 2 Department of Chemistry, University of
Washington, Seattle, WA, USA. ✉email: ;
NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | (2021)12:5928 | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-26035-y | www.nature.com/naturecommunications
1
ARTICLE
R
NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-26035-y
ecent advances in both traditional and novel electro-optic
materials that exhibit a χ(2) nonlinearity have resulted into
an unprecedented richness of active photonic devices, that
find applications in communications1–3, electric field metrology4,5,
dynamic beam steering6, and quantum science7. Multi-pixel, largearea spatial light modulators (SLMs) are a prerequisite to achieve
massively parallel dynamic and reconfigurable control over the
diverse properties of light. They promise to revolutionize applications in industry and fundamental science. In reconfigurable
photonics, multipixel optical components can control light ondemand, but they need to be compact and consume minimal
power per pixel. In massively parallel remote sensing8, high-speed
SLMs can generate parallel optical channels that scan the environment in three dimensions, but operation at high speeds is
mandatory to resolve small changes in the position and velocity of
objects within a short timeframe. In the area of ultrafast optics,
SLMs can manipulate femtosecond pulses through pulse-pickers,
but must accommodate a broad optical bandwidth and switching
speeds commensurate with the repetition rate of these lasers,
typically around few MHz to GHz. In fundamental science, SLMs
play a crucial role e.g., in the sorting and reconfiguration of cold
atoms for quantum simulation9, and reaching higher speeds can
access entirely new physics. In industry applications, such as selfdriving cars10, high-speed SLMs can monitor a scene if they are
compatible with low-power electronic circuits, chip-based laser
diodes that typically have a broad linewidth and low foot-print
packaging.
Among all existing SLM technologies, SLMs that employ electric
tuning enabled by χ(2) materials are outstanding candidates to
reach high speeds in parallel multipixel architectures. They are
intrinsically compatible with massively parallel radio-frequency
(RF) electronic circuits that promise to deliver the necessary
electrical controls by hybrid electronic-optical integration. In this
case, the SLM is essentially a two-dimensional array of free-space
electro-optic modulators. Commercial SLMs instead use bulky
digital micro-mirror arrays11 or liquid crystals12, which not only
limit them to around 10 kHz but also do not employ nanostructures. Few state-of-the art SLM demonstrations address the
quest for ever-higher speed by making use of narrow-band surface
plasmon resonances in rather complex prism-based schemes using
χ(2) nonlinear materials13, but the nano-scale engineering of the
individual pixels remains unexplored and the employed nonlinearity is rather low. Flat lens technology around metasurfaces14
is a powerful platform that permits engineering of the properties of
light at a sub-wavelength scale in an extremely compact device.
Static single-pixel metasurfaces have addressed multiple needs
(focussing, polarization control15, or correcting optics16) or multipixel metasurfaces (next-generation biodevices17). Consequently,
an ideal platform for high-speed SLMs combines highperformance χ(2) materials with nanostructures. Current demonstrations of monolithic metasurfaces from χ(2) materials typically
trade off an operation around a sharp resonance in materials with
moderate but broadband χ(2) effect e.g., in lithium niobate18,19 or
colloidal nonlinear nanocubes20 against an efficient χ(2) effect in
application-specific engineered III–V heterostructures, which is
however narrowband and located around its bandgap6. While
many demonstrations are single-pixel, few exciting multifunctional
metasurfaces with multiple electronic controls have emerged
experimentally6,21,22 and theoretically23. Important to mention are
also metasurfaces based on transparent conductive oxides22,24–26
that have enabled SLMs recently27, gate-tunable low-dimensional
materials28 or phase change materials such as e.g., GST29–33 that
are excellent candidates in scenarios, where high switching speeds
are not required. Microelectromechanical34,35 or thermo-optically
controlled36 systems are ideal for low speed applications that do
not require pixel-level control.
2
Custom-engineered organic nonlinear molecules instead
overcome this bandwidth-nonlinearity limitation since they have
electro-optic coefficients that are 10–100 times higher than
standard materials (up to r33 = 560 pmV−1 in bulk layers and
200 pmV−1 in nanoplasmonic gaps of gold electrodes37), over the
entire band from 1100 to 1600 nm (see Supplementary Note 7).
They are anticipated to deliver high-end SLMs, owing to their
terahertz-compatible bandwidth (up to 2.5 THz38), high index of
refraction and recently reported long-term thermal and chemical
stability39. Only little work studies such molecules beyond silicon
photonic circuits (where they reach highest electro-optic
couplings4 and integration with complementary metal-oxidesemiconductor (CMOS) electronics40) for large-area electro- (...truncated)