A surgeon led smoking cessation intervention in a head and neck cancer centre
Tang et al. BMC Health Services Research
A surgeon led smoking cessation intervention in a head and neck cancer centre
Ming Wei Tang 0 3
Richard Oakley 2
Catherine Dale 2
Arnie Purushotham 1
Henrik Mller 4
Jennifer Elizabeth Gallagher 0 3
0 Division of Population and Patient Health, King's College London Dental Institute at Guy's, King's College and St Thomas' Hospitals , Denmark Hill Campus, London SE5 9RS , UK
1 Guy's & St Thomas NHS Foundation Trust, Division of Cancer Studies, King's College London , London , UK
2 Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust , London , UK
3 Division of Population and Patient Health, King's College London Dental Institute at Guy's, King's College and St Thomas' Hospitals , Denmark Hill Campus, London SE5 9RS , UK
4 King's College London, Cancer Epidemiology and Population Health , London , UK
Background: The government has recognised the role of healthcare professionals in smoking cessation interventions with integrated care pathways for identification and referral of at-risk patients who smoke. Referral for suspected cancers has been suggested as a 'teachable moment', whereby individuals are motivated and more likely to adopt risk-reducing behaviours. A head and neck cancer referral clinic could therefore provide opportunities for smoking cessation intervention. This study aims to pilot a brief smoking cessation intervention during a consultation visit for patients referred with suspected head and neck cancer and evaluate its acceptability and impact. Methods: A brief script for smoking cessation intervention which included a smoking cessation referral was designed to be delivered to patients attending a rapid access clinic. Patient outcome data was collected by the stop smoking team for patients who accepted the referral. A subset of these patients was also interviewed by telephone; these findings were combined with data provided by the stop smoking services to assess the acceptability and impact of pilot smoking cessation intervention on patients. Results: In total, 473 new patients attended the clinic during the study period, of whom 102 (22%) were smokers. Of these, 80 (78%) accepted a referral to stop smoking services. A total of 75 (74%) patients were approached subsequently in a telephone survey. Of the 80 newly referred patients, 29 (36%) quit smoking at least temporarily. Another eight patients reduced their smoking or set a quit date (10%), so the experience of attending the clinic and the intervention impacted favourably on almost half of the patients (46%). The patient survey found the intervention to be acceptable for 94% (n = 50) of patients. Qualitative analysis of patient responses revealed five elements which support the acceptability of the intervention. Conclusions: The findings of this pilot study suggest that discussion of smoking cessation with patients referred for suspected head and neck cancer may have an impact and facilitate the process towards quitting. A possible diagnosis of cancer appears to present a 'teachable moment' to encourage positive health behaviour change.
Smoking cessation; Stop smoking; Head and neck cancer; Oral cancer; Prevention
-
Background
Cancers in the head and neck region account for about 3%
of all cancers diagnosed in England [1]. The incidence of
head and neck cancer nationally and in south east London
is increasing [2].
The majority of head and neck cancers are squamous
cell carcinomas and the main risk factors are tobacco
smoking, alcohol consumption, and human papilloma
virus infection. In a large international study, tobacco
and alcohol together explained 73% of upper
aerodigestive tract (UADT) cancer burden, of which almost
29% was due to tobacco alone, less than 1% alcohol
alone and 44% by the joint effect of tobacco and alcohol
[3]. Smoking was an independent risk factor for head
and neck cancer while alcohol consumption in the
absence of smoking conferred little or no risk. The joint
effect of tobacco and alcohol increased with the number
of pack-years and drink-years [4]. Tobacco smoking is
the main modifiable risk factor for head and neck cancer
and reducing smoking prevalence is one of three key
commitments at the heart of the NHS cancer plan [5].
The government has commissioned several white
papers [6-9], which provide guidance for tobacco control
policy in England. These documents highlight the
important role of healthcare professionals in smoking
cessation. It is within their capacity to proactively discuss
the issue of smoking with patients as it is linked to
improved general health. Integrated care pathways must be
developed and utilised for identification and referral of
at-risk patients who smoke. The NHS stop smoking
service plays a key role within this care pathway. Studies
have shown that smokers accessing this service are four
times more likely to achieve a four-week quit than those
without this assistance [10]. Godfrey et al., found NHS
smoking cessation services to be a cost-effective
lifesaving intervention when compared to many other
health-care interventions [11]. Although not ideal, there
is evidence that cutting down smoking can be an
important part of the process of stopping [12,13].
The importance of making every contact count for
health has been emphasised in recent health policy [14].
Patients referred via the two week wait route are perceived
by the GP as being at high risk of cancer and early
intervention will potentially improve their outcome. With the
increasing incidence of head and neck cancer, the initial
thrust to pilot a disease prevention program stemmed
from the South East London Tumour Working Group.
The impact of a smoking cessation intervention is
plausibly translatable to patients at risk of other smoking
related illnesses.
Events such as attending a head and neck cancer
diagnosis service have been suggested to be a teachable
moment whereby individuals may become motivated to
adopt risk-reducing behaviours. Several studies have
shown high rates of smoking cessation amongst patients
with newly diagnosed head and neck cancer [15,16]. This
finding may be explained using the health belief model
whereby patients perceive a susceptibility to head and
neck cancer and its threat, which may be a cue to action
because the benefit of quitting smoking is evident [17].
A teachable moment in the health care setting may
be exploited to encourage smoking cessation in
patients with suspected head and neck cancer [18]. The
initial diagnostic clinic provides such an opportunity
for healthcare professionals to help modify patient
behaviour by giving smoking cessation advice and
directing patients towards existing smoking cessation
services. Valid concerns about such an intervention
include whether the intervention is effective in
contributing to smoking cessation, and whether the intervention
may be unduly stressful at a moment of anxiety and
concern [19].
The aims of this study were to assess the acceptability,
and impact, of a brief smokin (...truncated)