The Relationship between Sleep-Wake Cycle and Cognitive Functioning in Young People with Affective Disorders
April
The Relationship between Sleep-Wake Cycle and Cognitive Functioning in Young People with Affective Disorders
Joanne S. Carpenter 0
Rbecca Robillard 0
Rico S. C. Lee 0
Daniel F. Hermens 0
Sharon L. Naismith 0
Django White 0
Bradley Whitwell 0
Elizabeth M. Scott 0
Ian B. Hickie 0
0 Clinical Research Unit, Brain & Mind Research Institute, University of Sydney , Camperdown, NSW , Australia
Although early-stage affective disorders are associated with both cognitive dysfunction and sleep-wake disruptions, relationships between these factors have not been specifically examined in young adults. Sleep and circadian rhythm disturbances in those with affective disorders are considerably heterogeneous, and may not relate to cognitive dysfunction in a simple linear fashion. This study aimed to characterise profiles of sleep and circadian disturbance in young people with affective disorders and examine associations between these profiles and cognitive performance. Actigraphy monitoring was completed in 152 young people (16-30 years; 66% female) with primary diagnoses of affective disorders, and 69 healthy controls (18-30 years; 57% female). Patients also underwent detailed neuropsychological assessment. Actigraphy data were processed to estimate both sleep and circadian parameters. Overall neuropsychological performance in patients was poor on tasks relating to mental flexibility and visual memory. Two hierarchical cluster analyses identified three distinct patient groups based on sleep variables and three based on circadian variables. Sleep clusters included a 'long sleep' cluster, a 'disrupted sleep' cluster, and a 'delayed and disrupted sleep' cluster. Circadian clusters included a 'strong circadian' cluster, a 'weak circadian' cluster, and a 'delayed circadian' cluster. Medication use differed between clusters. The 'long sleep' cluster displayed significantly worse visual memory performance compared to the 'disrupted sleep' cluster. No other cognitive functions differed between clusters. These results highlight the heterogeneity of sleep and circadian profiles in young people with affective disorders, and provide preliminary evidence in support of a relationship between sleep and visual memory, which may be mediated by use of antipsychotic medication. These findings have implications for the personalisation of treatments and improvement of functioning in young adults early in the course of affective illness.
-
Funding: IBH was funded by a National Health and
Medical Research Council Program Grant (No.
566529) and Australian Fellowship (No. 464914).
DFH was supported by a grant from NSW Health
Mental Health and Drug & Alcohol Office. SLN was
funded by a National Health and Medical Research
Council Clinical Development Award (No. 1008117).
RR received a postdoctoral training award from the
Fonds de la recherche en sante du Quebec. RSCL
and JSC were supported by the NHMRC Centre of
Research Excellence in Optimising Early
Interventions for Young People with Emerging Mood
Disorders (No. 1061043). The funders had no role in
study design, data collection and analysis, decision to
publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing Interests: The authors have read the
journals policy and have the following conflicts. DFH
has received honoraria for educational seminars from
Janssen-Cilag and Eli Lilly. EMS is the (unpaid)
Clinical Director of Headspace Services at the BMRI,
the (unpaid) Coordinator of the Youth Mental Health
Research Program at the BMRI, and Deputy Director
of St Vincents Private Hospital Young Adult Mental
Health Unit. She has received honoraria for
educational seminars related to the clinical
management of depressive disorders supported by
Servier and Eli Lilly pharmaceuticals. She has
participated in a national advisory board for the
antidepressant compound Pristiq, manufactured by
Pfizer. IBH is a Commissioner in Australias new
National Mental Health Commission from 2012. He
was a director of headspace: the national youth
mental health foundation until January 2012. He was
previously the chief executive officer (till 2003) and
clinical adviser (till 2006) of beyondblue, an Australian
National Depression Initiative. He is the executive
director of the Brain and Mind Research Institute,
which operates two early-intervention youth services
under contract to headspace. He has led a range of
community-based and pharmaceutical
industrysupported depression awareness and education and
training programs. He has led projects for health
professionals and the community supported by
governmental, community agency and
pharmaceutical industry partners (Wyeth, Eli Lily,
Servier, Pfizer, AstraZeneca) for the identification and
management of depression and anxiety. He has
received honoraria for presentations of his own work
at educational seminars supported by a number of
non-government organisations and the
pharmaceutical industry (including Servier, Pfizer,
AstraZeneca, and Eli Lilly). He is a member of the
Medical Advisory Panel for Medibank Private and
also a Board Member of Psychosis Australia Trust.
He leads an investigator-initiated study of the effects
of agomelatine on circadian parameters (supported in
part by Servier) and has participated in a multicentre
clinical trial of the effects of agomelatine on sleep
architecture in depression and a Servier-supported
study of major depression and sleep disturbance in
primary care settings. The competing interests do not
alter the authors adherence to all the PLOS ONE
policies on sharing data and materials.
Adolescence and young adulthood is a key developmental period with a heightened incidence
of affective disorders (defined in this paper to include major depressive disorder, bipolar
disorder, and anxiety disorders) [1, 2]. Affective disorders have been associated with a range of
cognitive deficits, including dysfunction in areas of new learning, memory, attention, and
executive functioning [38]. Many of these deficits are present in the first episode of mental
illness [9, 10] and have been shown to persist into remission [1113]. This may be reflective of
such deficits being risk-factors for the development or recurrence of these disorders, or
epiphenomena of other causal factors or risk-factors. Poorer neuropsychological performance has
been linked to poorer clinical, social, and occupational outcomes [1416] and as such
uncovering any potential causal or mediational factors is important to identify targets for therapeutic
interventions.
One factor that could potentially be associated with cognitive dysfunctions in affective
disorders is sleep and circadian rhythm disturbance. Sleep disturbances are found in major
depressive disorder (difficulty initiating and maintaining sleep, and abnormal sleep duration [17,
18]), anxiety disorders (altered sleep duration, insomnia [1821]), and bipolar disorder
(decreased sleep duration during manic and hypomanic episodes [22, 23]). Sleep disturbances in
affective disorders oft (...truncated)