CURRENT AND FUTURE TREND OF RESEARCH IN ACADEMIC WRITING: A BIBLIOMETRIC ANALYSIS
Journal of English Educational Study (JEES)
Volume 7 Issue 1 May 2024 Page 112-121
E-ISSN:2655-0776
CURRENT AND FUTURE TREND OF RESEARCH IN ACADEMIC WRITING:
A BIBLIOMETRIC ANALYSIS
Evi Karlina Ambarwati, Indah Purnama Dewi, Praditya Putri Utami, Nina Puspitaloka,
Alvin Yahya Makarim Nazar
Universitas Singaperbangsa Karawang
, , ,
and
Submitted: 2024-03-12
Accepted: 2024-03-25
Abstract: This study was a comprehensive bibliometric analysis of the literature of Academic
Writing in various higher education contexts and mapped the current state of the trend as well as
identified gap for future research. There were 991 documents retrieved on Academic Writing in
Higher Education from database citation index Scopus (2013 to 2022) under certain conditions.
The documents were then analyzed using OpenRefine version 3.5.2, VOSviewer version 1.6.17
from Leiden University, Microsoft Excel and Tableu Desktop from the perspectives of the number
of yearly publications, countries, authors, citation numbers, and keywords. The findings show that
the number of publications on Academic Writing is generally growing.The research topics shows
that academic writing instruction across classroom contexts reflect the 21st century life skills and
learning through students’ active participation, i.e. peer assessment, peer learning, and selfregulation. Likewise, information, media and technology are instilled through e-learning and
computer-aided instruction. Last, the functional view of grammar in academic writing establishes
new research focus.
Keywords: academic writing; bibliometric analysis; research trends
INTRODUCTION
Writing is an important skill in academic context. This is the case because writing is the
primary communication method in academia (Craswell & Poore, 2011). Likewise, it is one of
the most difficult skills for many students to master, either for L1 and L2 users of English
(Bailey, 2014). Hence, teaching the skill requires proper attention. Efforts to illuminate teaching
academic writing have been made in various classrooms across the globe that handbook for
teaching academic writing for each context is mostly available, for example in English as a
second language classroom (Paltridge et al., 2009), UK (Ganobcsik-Williams; 2017) and Europe
(Björk et al., 2003). Many researches were also conducted to provide pedagogical support.
Various aspects of academic writing are interesting to be researched. Studies were conducted
on curriculum models in different classroom contexts, for example genre-based approach in
Iran, Japan, Indonesia, UK and China (Ariyanfar & Mitchell, 2020; Nagao, 2019; Wijayanti et
al., 2017; Wingate, 2012; X. Xu & Li, 2018); product-based approach in Iraq, Iran, and
Malaysia (Abdulrahman & Kara, 2022; Naghdipour, 2016; Nordin & Mohammad, 2018;
Selvaraj et al., 2019) as well as process approach in South Africa (Ngubane et al., 2020). Other
112
Ambarwati, et.al. Current....
Journal of English Educational Study (JEES)
Volume 7 Issue 1 May 2024 Page 112-121
E-ISSN:2655-0776
researchers looked into the various aspect of feedback for improving students’ writing quality
(Ferris et al., 2013; Truscott & Hsu, 2008).
However, as with other aspects of life, the new global economy and 21st century society set
a new direction for writing instruction. First, many academic writing classrooms instill the 21st
century learning and life skills by allowing students to take more initiatives and participations
about their writing skill. For example,studies investigated the application of self-regulated
learning and metacognition theories to acquire academic writing skill(Chen et al., 2022; InanKaragul & Seker, 2021). Likewise, many writing classrooms provided many opportunities for
students collaboration (Pham, 2021; Valizadeh, 2022). Last, students were given more social
responsibility to provide feedback to their peers (Bürgermeister et al., 2021; Sunzuma et al.,
2022).
Next, information, media and technology skills creates the technology affordances in writing
classroom. For example, studies investigated technology enhanced academic writing instruction
in blended learning environment
(Rahman et al., 2020; Scott et al., 2020)and flipped
classroom(Fathi & Rahimi, 2022; Qader & Arslan, 2019). Various technological tools, such as
Google Docs was also utilized to facilitate collaborative writing (Alharbi, 2020; Valizadeh,
2022)and feedback (Alharbi & Alqefari, 2021; Hoa & Lap, 2021). In regards to feedback,
though, Automated Writing Evaluation (AWE) is currently popular among students and
instructors (Ambarwati, 2021; J. Xu & Zhang, 2022; Zhang & Hyland, 2018). Also, the issue of
academic integrity which might result from the timely copy-paste access from the Internet’s
open sources begin to rise (Ledwith & Rísquez, 2008; Pennycook, 2016; Walker, 2010).
Therefore, considering the significant change in culture, politics, economy and technology
development, this article seeks to provide an overview of the current situation and trends in
academic writing studies based on database citation index Scopus from 2013 to 2022. Moreover,
it aims to provide useful information for future academic writing research by means of data
analysis visualization using VOSviewer version 1.6.17, OpenRefine version 3.5.2, Microsoft
Excel and Tableu Desktop. Thus, the research questions are to be addressed in the present study:
What is the bibliometric information regarding publications about academic writing, including
the number of annual publication, authors, and citations?, Who are the most influential authors
in the field of academic writing? And What are the publication trends in academic writing?
METHOD
Bibliometric analysis involves quantitative assessment of bibliographic materials by means
of statistical methods (Broadus, 1987). This study employed bibliometric analysis of the
literature on academic writing in post-secondary classroom context and mapped the current state
113
Ambarwati, et.al. Current....
Journal of English Educational Study (JEES)
Volume 7 Issue 1 May 2024 Page 112-121
E-ISSN:2655-0776
of the field, prominent topics as well as predicted the future trend in the field. There were 3
phases involved, i.e. Data Collection, Data Visualization and Data Analysis (Figure 1).
Figure 1. Bibliometric Analysis Method
The documents for this study were selected from database citation index Scopus, one of the
world’s largest and extensive scientific publication databases across numerous fields. The
database was collected on 15 September 2022. There were 1954 sample documents extracted
from the title-abstract keywords “academic writing” AND “higher education” OR university OR
college OR “tertiary education”. Then, the documents were filtered by the time span of 2013 to
2022. Only article was chosen as the target document type.
Finally, 991 documents were obtained. The documents cover various subject areas, i.e. social
science (54.1%), arts and humanities (29.5%), computer science (3.5%) (...truncated)