STRATEGY FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF PROFESSIONAL ABILITIES FOR AAL OF ENGINEERING CORPS USING IPA, SWOT AND ISM METHODS
International Journal of ASRO
Volume 12, Number 02, pp. 1-9
Apr 2021
STRATEGY FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF PROFESSIONAL
ABILITIES FOR AAL OF ENGINEERING CORPS
USING IPA, SWOT AND ISM METHODS
Mukhlis1, Juni Hari Budianto2, Suparno3, Anton Nugroho4
1,3,4Indonesian
Naval Technology College, Bumimoro-Morokrembangan, Surabaya 60187, Indonesia
Engineering Department, Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember, Surabaya, Indonesia
e-mail:
2Industrial
ABSTRACT
Mechanical engineering corps of Indonesian Naval Cadets Department in charge of producing
professional Engineering Corps Officers with knowledge and skills in the field of Indonesian Navy
logistics management and warship engine engineering. There were still some of the obstacles that exist
in the Study Program will certainly have an impact on the performance displayed by the graduates in
their duties. This study used the IPA (Importance Performance Analysis) method to see the
performance of graduates, the SWOT (Strength, Weakness, Opportunities and Threat) method in
formulating strategies and the ISM (Interpretative Structural Modeling) approach in determining
priorities and strategy mapping with the aim of producing a roadmap of chosen strategy. The results
showed that the mapping of the position of the performance attributes of graduates in the Quadrant
Analysis and the level of satisfaction at the level was quite satisfied with a satisfaction score of 63.6%.
By using ISM method approach, five levels of hierarchical structure are generated to be used as a
reference in determining the roadmap for the professional development strategy of the engineering
corps of Indonesian Naval Cadets.
Keywords: Engineering corps of Indonesian Naval Cadets Department, IPA, SWOT, and ISM.
1.
INTRODUCTION
Engineering,
Warship
Electronics
Engineering, Logistics Management and
Marine Matra Finance and Defense
Management. Marine Aspects Land aspect,
with the vision "The realization of a Navy
Academy that is capable of producing
Responsive Navy Officers, Tanggon and
Trengginas" and the mission "organizing an
educational process consisting of effective
and efficient teaching, training and nurturing to
produce graduates of Indonesian Navy
Officers
who
are
fighting
spirit,
professionalism, discipline, pride, hard work
and smart work as well as having high physical
fitness, through the proper application of
management and educational technology.
The duties of the Indonesian Navy based
on Law No. 34 of 2004 concerning the
Indonesian National Army are to carry out TNI
duties in the marine sector in the defence
sector, enforce the law and maintain security in
the marine area national jurisdiction in
accordance with the provisions of national law
and international law that have been ratified,
carrying out the diplomatic duties of the Navy in
the context of supporting political policies
outside
country
that
has
been determined by the government, carrying
out TNI duties in development and
development the strength of the marine
dimension and carry out the empowerment of
the marine defence area In order to support the
implementation of this task, the Indonesian
Navy carries out the preparation of human
resources through task-oriented education.
Mechanical engineering corps of
Indonesian Naval Cadets Department which
oversees
the
Warship
Mechanical
Engineering Study Program, is responsible for
the Teaching and Learning Program for
Technical Corps Cadets which aims to
educate and equip Engineering corps of
Indonesian Naval Cadets who have the spirit
of a warrior saptamarga warrior who has
Indonesian Naval Academy is one of
the first educational institutions of Indonesian
Navy Officers located in the city of Surabaya,
with five study programs namely Marine
Defense Management, Warship Mechanical
1
physical fitness, professionalism of the marine
dimension with knowledge and skills in the
field of Logistics Management of the
Indonesian Navy and Warship Mechanical
Engineering so that it can support the tasks of
the Department of Machinery in preparing KRI
as a Mechanical Division Officer, Electrical
Division Officer and other positions at the
same level as KRI and able to develop
personally as a cadre of Navy leaders.
intagibles. Respondents were asked to access
the level of performance and importance about
service attributes.
Table 1. Performance and importance level
assessment scores
Value
Performance Importance
1
Very
Very
dissatisfied
unimportance
2
Not satisfied
Not Importance
3
Quite satisfied Quite Importance
4
Satisfied
Importance
5
Very satisfied
Very imporyant
In the implementation of teaching and
learning activities, the Study Program still
experiences several obstacles in its
implementation, this of course will have an
impact on the output of the results of students,
as for the constraints, these obstacles include:
This study used two variables X and Y,
where X is the level of performance and Y is the
level of Importance / expectation from user’s
Indonesian naval 2nd fleet command materiel
service, after the data is collected then the data
is processed to assess the level of performance
and level of Importance / expectations. The
formula:
𝑋𝑖
𝑇𝑘𝑖 = 𝑥 100%
(1)
a.
The absence of a Real Engine
Simulator facility, this facility is a simulation of
the field of duty of an engine division officer
consisting of the Engine Control Room (ECR)
and the Engine Room complete with Basic
Motor equipment to the actual Auxiliary Motor,
this can help cadets in facing the terrain. The
assignment later, so far, is still using the
Pusdiktek Kodiklatal so that the frequency of
use is limited due to alternating with Kodiklatal
students.
𝑌𝑖
Description :
Tki
=
Respondent's
level
of
conformity
b.
Lack
of
laboratory
education
personnel (Laboran) in the Sapudi building
and Jaya Wijaya building both in number and
qualifications. So far, it has only been filled
with members of the rank of NCO or civil
servants without a course or training in
accordance with the equipment or material to
be taught to the cadets.
Xi
=Performance scoring scores
Yi
=Importance
assessment
score
then the service attribute is mapped into
quadrant Analysis where the horizontal axis (X)
will be populated by the performance value and
c.
There are no permanent lecturers who
have linear postgraduate qualifications in the
field of Mechanical Engineering so that the
Department of Technology has difficulty
finding the right lecturers for cadets.
the upright axis (Y) will be filled with the
Importance value:
𝑥=
d.
There are still conflicting schedules
between teaching and learning activities in the
classroom or in the laboratory with the
parenting activities of the Youth Corps
Regiment.
𝑦=
∑ 𝑥𝑖
n
∑ 𝑦𝑖
𝑛
(2)
(3)
Description:
X = Average performance score
Y = Average Importance score
2.
n = number of Respondents
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Importance Performance Analysis
Martila and James (1997) introduced
the Importance Performance Analysis (IPA)
method which is a mmulti-attribute model and (...truncated)